After nearly six hours standing in the sweltering heat at the Butler Farm Show grounds on Saturday, Jon Galland’s thoughts went to the simplest, least threatening explanation for the deafening “pop-pop-pop” heard from about 100 yards behind him: fireworks.
Mr. Galland, 48, of North Fayette, supports the Second Amendment, but hasn’t spent much time around weapons, he admits, which might be why he took an extra second to conclude that those miniature explosions were, in fact, gunfire.
From behind him, other ticketed attendees yelled, “Get down!,” as the tightly packed crowd members laid beside and atop one another, providing some of the only shade Mr. Galland had felt in hours.
“This is no joke. There’s gunfire, but I’m OK,” he texted to his wife, just before the crowd’s cell phones collectively entered S.O.S. mode, halting communication to loved ones for about 40 minutes.
Taking inventory of his surroundings, he looked forward to see a father using his body as a shield over his two young daughters, reminding Mr. Galland that his own 12-year-old son would have been there, if he hadn’t made a last-minute decision to dodge the day’s long hours and scorching heat.
For Pittsburgh-area kids, particularly those near Butler, their sense of security was invaded uniquely on Saturday with the assassination attempt of former President Donald Trump, whether they attended the rally or not. All of those children, to varying degrees and whether they were eyewitnesses or watched footage from home, are at risk for trauma reactions, threats to their mental health.
Read More
“Anytime there’s violence, and gun violence in particular, it’s scary for everybody, but especially for children and teenagers,” said Anthony Mannarino, clinical psychologist, co-founder of Allegheny Health Network’s Center for Traumatic Stress in Children and Adolescents and co-creator of Trauma-Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, a method that aids trauma-exposed children across the world.
“There’s chaos at the scene. Children are watching it live or on TV. That’s a former president of the United States, and kids might think, ‘How could this happen to a former president?’”
Rallying risk
Mr. Galland’s son’s decision to stay home caused him to miss the shooting by 20-year-old Thomas Crooks, of Bethel Park, which resulted in the death of Buffalo Township firefighter Corey Comperatore and injuries sustained by Mr. Trump and rally attendees David Dutch, 57, of Plum and James Copenhaver, 74.
“He’s a Trump fan. We wanted him to be informed. Obviously, we didn’t think those events were going to happen,” Mr. Galland said. “It’s not something you want your minor child to witness.”
Instead, his son was at the family’s home, blissfully unaware of the events that had transpired, when his mother walked in.
In a tone both measured and serious, she told him to turn off the video game and put on the news. When he was reluctant, she chose her words carefully: “Dad’s OK, but something happened at the Trump rally.”
As the boy saw, television accounts of the events are plenty graphic, but the younger Galland escaped a higher likelihood of a traumatic response by choosing to stay home that day.
“In person, it’s a real, live event. You hear the gunshots live. You see the people taking cover,” Dr. Mannarino said. “For all we know, the kids did see the people who were shot and were either wounded or died.”
For the next few weeks, it’s “quite likely,” Dr. Mannarino said, that those children might display difficulty sleeping, irritability and sadness, for example.
The same can be true for kids who watch coverage after the fact.
“There’s been pretty good research that, for events like 9/11 and other major disasters, when children watch too much TV or footage of those events, they can develop trauma-type reactions as if they were there,” Dr. Mannarino said.
These weren’t only traumatic events that happened to someone, somewhere. They happened startlingly close to home — with “home,” for many, being a physical and theoretical foundation of safety.
“The research shows that the closer you are to events like this happening, the more likely you’re going to be affected,” Dr. Mannarino said. “When people are in Butler County and that surrounding area, the kids there are going to be more at risk for developing some type of trauma-reaction.”
Talk to tame it
Dr. Mannarino’s novel approach to trauma-impacted kids, TF-CBT, has successfully assisted children following the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the current humanitarian disasters in Gaza and Ukraine, and more, and it bucks the notion that mental health practitioners should wait for children to autonomously voice their concerns before addressing them head-on.
The same advice goes for parents.
“Kids are bound to hear about it at summer camp or wherever. It’s going to be talked about by other kids, maybe teachers or counselors,” Dr. Mannarino said. “It might be as simple as, ‘Have you been thinking about the shooting that occurred when [former] President Trump was at the rally? What are your thoughts about that? Are you afraid?’ Don’t wait for the kids to bring it up. They could be too afraid.”
For some, getting kids to talk isn’t difficult. It’s what to say when they stop that can intimidate parents.
Much like Fred Rogers would, Dr. Mannarino suggests that parents point out “the helpers,” police and other authorities who assisted in the moment and who are working “to make sure it won’t happen again.” For children ages 10 and older, more detailed responses are appropriate.
Then, listen to their concerns, with a reminder that they can take an active roll in preventing violence by speaking up should they ever notice something suspicious.
Fall-time fall
John Reddick’s first memory is his mother, sitting on the family’s sofa and folding laundry, her attention glued to the television as tears streamed down her face.
It was November 1963, and in an effort for 3-year-old John to learn why his mother was so upset, he too turned toward the television, but all he saw were horses and an American flag, images he later learned were part of President John F. Kennedy’s funeral procession.
Mr. Reddick, 64, of Butler, who has young grandchildren in the area, knows they now share similar traumatic memories from their early lives, which according to researchers, places them at similar risk.
“Any of us who have experienced trauma earlier in life, no matter what it’s been, will be at risk for having trauma reactions to things later, to things like what happened on Saturday,” Dr. Mannarino said.
Kids battling mental health conditions are also at higher risk for processing events, such as the Trump shooting, as traumatic ones, which is alarming given the crisis-level number of children battling those conditions post-pandemic.
Per Dr. Mannarino, parents of those children should check in frequently, making sure the attempted assassination of Mr. Trump doesn’t regularly populate their kids’ minds for longer than a few weeks. However, the full impact may not be known until this fall.
Post-9/11 research shows a peak in childhood trauma reactions about six months after the attacks — a phenomenon that, according to Dr. Mannarino, could be observed for Butler-area kids, especially as presidential election campaign ads could serve as trauma triggers.
For now, Mr. Galland’s son has moved on from the intensity of Saturday, though not without thoughtful support.
Jon Galland is known to enter the house meticulously, removing his shoes and setting down his things before greeting his wife and son. But on Saturday, he rushed in, giving big hugs and kisses, before sitting down and carefully explaining what happened, with an emphasis on “the helpers.”
“I think he was a little bit surprised that someone might act out in that way, by shooting a gun and trying to bring deadly force to a candidate,” Mr. Galland said. “As a parent, you do pause, and you think, ‘I want to be able to say this in exactly the right way.’”
But there’s also power in what parents omit.
Outside of the initial news reports, his 12-year-old has only watched one thing on TV — President Joe Biden’s address the following night — which follows Dr. Mannarino’s primary piece of advice.
“That picture of President Trump grabbing his ear and the blood, if you see that over and over again, it gets imprinted on your mind, and we don’t want kids to have to deal with that,” he said. “The biggest thing from my vantage point, and we’ve learned this over and over, is just have parents turn the TV, and other media sources, off.”
Abby Mackey: amackey@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.