This article is based on the most recent episode of our parenting podcast, 412 Kids.

Paul Guarino can read Ascend Climbing’s Fruity Pebbles-colored holds like a roadmap, knowing which bulbous, dimpled, angular and little-more-than-a-sliver grips might allow him to Spider-Man his way to each wall’s top.

For Guarino and those like him, that level of skill certainly bestows confidence. Still, should that feeling ever evolve toward arrogance, humility can be found just a few grips away.

“A couple of years after a kid starts climbing, a 7-year-old might come up to me and say, ‘Hey, do you mind if I work in on this boulder with you?’ he said. “That’s just like a 30-year-old would do,” and perhaps with the same climbing proficiency.

Advertise with us

Guarino is also one of Ascend’s three owners who, together, choose to foster youth programming, with “youth” meaning any child — of any age — capable of following the gym’s safety rules and cultural etiquette with a parent’s oversight.

The space won’t become overrun with children anytime soon, however. For many parents, the idea of kids climbing — let alone “bouldering,” which is performed without a rope — exceeds their tolerance for risk.

But for this generation of kids, so might monkey bars, as some moms and dads rush over to cushion a presumptive fall. Tree climbing is often met with near-hyperventilation. And holding a pincer-laden stag beetle, even on a stick, is a nope-on-a-rope.

All of that “protection” aligns with research published earlier this year, showing that 78% of parents have a low tolerance for risk when presented with a series of potential play scenarios, such as, “Would you allow your child to climb a tree within your reach?”

For parents who allow “riskier” play, however, the side-eyed glances can be venomous (while stag beetles are not, for the record).

Advertise with us

This particular schoolyard battle is reserved for the adults, the so-called “helicopter parents” versus those more comfortable with risk. But evidence — from experts and research — has plenty to say about why these parenting styles exist and which is most conducive to the long-term success of tiny Tarzans.

Helicopters vs. free flyers

Childhoods with inherent risk — say, working the farm or following instructions to “get out of the house and play,” with no real plan for when or how to return — largely belong to bygone eras.

The shift toward sheltering kids began about 50 years ago, according to Allegheny Health Network child and adolescent psychiatrist Gary Swanson, when dual-income families became a preference, if not a financial requirement.

“You’re putting kids in daycare, in after-school programs, and they’re all supervised by adults, and all the adults feel responsible to make sure nothing bad happens to them,” he said. “And when the parents come home, they want to spend more time with their kids.”

According to scholars, the real pivot point seen globally, not just in the U.S., was around 1985.

Advertise with us

“Kids became more scheduled. They have more activities, and parents are there all of the time, coaching them and things like that,” he said. “That’s great, but the question is, what about the kid being able to do some of that stuff independently?”

“Helicopter parenting” isn’t a clinical term. It has no formal definition. But it’s generally characterized as a parenting style marked by overprotection and control, with imagery of a parent hovering — like a helicopter — over their children in nearly all situations.

Aside from working parents seeking scarce quality time, their urges to oversee are also motivated by perceived environmental risks.

“It’s all about fear,” said Jamie Hanson, a University of Pittsburgh assistant professor of psychology who researches how children and adolescents interact with their environments. “We see these high-profile news cases. Maybe a child is abducted. Our phones flash with an Amber Alert. A lot of these events are really rare, but we have these preconceived notions of, ‘Oh my God, my kid’s going to get abducted.’”

The same thinking might lead a parent to prevent their child from jumping over a small creek, scaling a hillside or bouldering at their local rock wall, because maybe, at some point, they could get hurt.

Advertise with us

But risk exists beyond tree limbs and creek beds.

Both Hanson and Swanson point out the vulnerability necessary to experiment socially, to paint a picture for the first time, to go out for a sport. Seeing the possibility of foibles, failure or disappointment, stereotypical helicopter parents might referee social interactions, over-direct kids’ courses through new activities or be the voice in a coach’s ear.

While there might be short-term satisfaction associated with those behaviors, Hanson said, there could also be long-term consequences.

Sequelae of the shield

Rather than labeling parenting types as “helicopter” or “risk-taking” — or its extreme, sometimes dangerous, cousin, “free-range” parenting — one study described them instead “as safe as possible” versus “as safe as necessary.”

A body of research shows helicopter parenting is correlated with anxiety and depression in kids, though Swanson sees many possible reasons for that relationship.

Advertise with us

Anxious, helicoptering parents’ mindsets — “It’s scary out there” — may influence the way kids think, causing them to believe the world is a dangerous place, he said.

Or an anxious parent may have an anxious child simply because of the heritable nature of neurobiology.

A third scenario, he suggested, could begin with a neurodivergent child — someone who’s anxious or dysregulated — which stimulates an exaggerated protective response from the parent.

“The short answer is it’s probably a little bit of all of that,” Swanson said.

In cases where the child does bring their own mental or neurobiological differences to the proverbial table — such as ADHD, autism spectrum disorder, OCD, etc. — Swanson finds that a parent’s additional involvement may be appropriate. Those are not helicopter parents.

Advertise with us

His belief in appropriate risk-taking applies mostly to “typical” kids, as does Hanson’s.

“The biggest thing I think about is how we tackle failure. Failure is just a natural part of life,” he said. And when allowed to navigate non-ideal situations independently, people will be more apt to “learn a little bit quicker” the next time they’re in a tight spot — on the playground, in a tree or maybe, someday, in a boardroom.

Efficaciousness or esteem?

Guarino, and others in the climbing community, argue that climbing injuries, in kids or adults, are no more common than those seen in football, hockey or any other mainstream sport, partially because of preparation.

“We aren’t teaching them to climb at first,” he said. “We’re teaching them to be in the space. How do you stay safe? How do you fall correctly? Risk management is a part of climbing.”

Those learned responses to non-ideal situations are the same ones kids can cultivate on their own when given the space to do so.

Advertise with us

“If a kid tries to grab a bee, it’ll sting you, and the kid will figure out how not to do that,” Swanson said. “I’m not saying it’s not OK to say, ‘Hey, don’t touch that,’ but if the kid does, they’ll learn. It’s not so bad to learn that way.”

And despite more guarded varieties of parenting being the norm, Hanson doesn’t see them lasting.

“I really think we’re in a period of flux. I think we know we’ve overcorrected,” he said.

For self-identified members of that “we,” so-called “parenting pods” or self-segregated groups of like-minded parents are emerging.

Within them, parents may have overt conversations about when they will allow their children to have their own cell phones, for instance, to provide social constructs that reinforce their parenting beliefs. Or for pro-creek, pro-tree climbing parents, pods allow them to know their kids will all play with the same level of freedom without frustrated stares or negative commentary.

Advertise with us

For parents seeking a gray area — freedom and chances to check in — Hanson discusses graded privileges. If a teen’s goal is to attend a concert with only friends, first allow them to visit a lower-stakes event, or try an Uber or bus ride as a trial run, all before agreeing to the concert.

Because though it may be uncomfortable for mom and dad, each age-appropriate, or ability-appropriate, “risk” a young person is allowed to take has the potential to leave a sparkle of accomplishment in their eyes, signaling an evolution in their sense of self.

“They talked to me like an adult,” Hanson recalled his 6-year-old saying, while “glowing and beaming,” after she was allowed to purchase something on her own at a local store.

Some might call that result “self-esteem,” but Swanson avoids that term in favor of “self-efficaciousness” — not just feeling good, but recognizing their own competence — which has been associated with good mental health, he said.

“You don’t want your kid to get hurt. I appreciate that,” he said. “But at the same time, getting hurt teaches you a valuable lesson. This is dangerous. There are risks to it.

Advertise with us

“I’m not asking you to let them go dance in front of a train. I’m asking you to let them go out for a walk, climb this hill that’s hard, ride this bike that’s hard, and let them feel good about those sorts of things.”

Abby Mackey is a registered nurse, and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites.