Just after Thanksgiving, Jennifer Carpenter stood in an operating room at Allegheny General Hospital, holding her mother’s kidney. Carpenter, a transplant surgeon, removed and flushed the organ, preparing it to be sent to a man in Colorado who had been on dialysis for two years.
It was not the first, nor the second, third or fourth time that Carpenter’s family had been involved with kidney transplants. Her mother, father and aunt are all kidney donors. Her sister has received two kidneys. And she is the surgical director of the living donor kidney transplant program at Allegheny Health Network.
“We ended up going from, one daughter needed a transplant to one became a transplant surgeon,” said Colleen Beer, Carpenter’s mother. “It’s kind of cool that it’s all in the same family.”
Their family story started 29 years ago, at the Olive Garden restaurant after the first communion of Carpenter’s sister, Maggie Beer. Maggie, then 7, came back from the bathroom complaining that her urine was dark.
Two weeks later, her entire lower body swelled dramatically. At the doctor’s office, her mother helped her to give a urine sample, and realized it was pure blood.
Eventually, Maggie was diagnosed with IgA nephropathy, a kidney disease in which clumps of antibodies deposit themselves in the kidneys, causing inflammation and damage.
Read More
“I didn’t realize how many functions your kidneys are responsible for,” said Colleen, and Maggie became sick in ways that her mom never imagined. She didn’t gain weight. She had high blood pressure. One medication caused problems with her gums, another made her face swell. And she was always tired.
“It was like her mind was in a fog,” said Colleen. “She couldn’t think, couldn’t concentrate, couldn’t remember.”

Carpenter, who is five years older, watched her little sister struggle. “It was really hard to watch her be sick and have to be in and out of hospitals,” she said. “She hates needles — every shot was just really traumatic for her.”
When Maggie was 14, her kidney function declined to the point that she either needed a transplant or dialysis. Her father, Dan Beer, volunteered his kidney and was luckily a match.
They had their surgery at the University of Iowa, recovering just a couple of floors apart. Maggie remembers watching a particularly funny episode of the prank caller show “Crank Yankers” with her mother, and then going down to her father’s room to tell him about it. As her mom recounted the episode, she and her dad recoiled in pain from their abdominal surgeries.
“Him and I were just clutching our stomachs saying ‘STOP,’” said Maggie.
After her transplant, “everything changed for the better,” she said. She had more energy, started growing normally, and could concentrate better as she began high school.
“She totally changed her personality,” said her mom. “This was a girl who couldn’t think past lunch — now she is making plans for her future.”
She went to college at the University of Iowa, but a couple years into college, her body rejected the first kidney. She became sick enough that she had to go on dialysis, which caused major complications. The dialysis caused painful calcium deposits in her legs, and she ended up needing crutches to walk. She was hospitalized with sepsis and lost so much weight and muscle mass that she was down to 80 pounds.
“I literally almost died,” said Maggie. “Everything about my body was just failing.”
Maggie needed another kidney and, this time, her aunt was a willing donor and a match. At 23, she received her second kidney. After dropping out of college due to health issues, she was able to get her degree in linguistics after the transplant, then moved to Japan to teach high school English.
In the meantime, Carpenter had graduated from the University of Iowa and gone to Northwestern for a graduate physical therapy program. After a year she came home and told her mother that she wanted to go to medical school instead.
She began medical school at the University of Illinois with the ultimate goal of becoming a pediatric surgeon. “I wanted to operate on kids like my sister,” she said.
But as she went through a demanding surgical residency program at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, it was the transplant rotation that made her feel inspired.
“Even as a tired resident, when I was on the transplant rotation, I wanted to get up, go to work,” she said. “I wanted to fly around and recover organs.”
She went to Georgetown University for a transplant fellowship and moved to Pittsburgh three years ago to direct AHN’s living kidney donor program.
While Maggie is now healthy, the family knows that donor kidneys don’t last forever. A living donor kidney often lasts for 15 or 20 years, said Carpenter. Maggie is now 36, with a kidney donated 13 years ago. “You can see your numbers trending upwards and you think you feel maybe a little more side effects, hints that you aren’t feeling as well as you used to,” said Maggie. “This kidney is going on 14 years, which is great for a second kidney. You try to keep it going as long as possible but it’s got to come out eventually.”
Colleen, 64, remembers discussing the situation with Carpenter, saying that she wanted to try to give her kidney to Maggie when she needed it, but wondering if she would be too old. “Is she going to want a 68-year-old kidney?” she asked.
Carpenter recommended that she donate her kidney as soon as possible — altruistically, to a stranger. Doing so on Maggie’s behalf would give Maggie a voucher of sorts to use later in life, putting her at the top of the list when she needed a kidney.
Immediately, Colleen knew she would do it.
“I had always known I would donate my organs after I died,” said Colleen. “I’m not donating to Maggie, but I donated so somebody else can get off dialysis.”

A kidney donation surgery requires two doctors, and while transplant surgeon Lorenzo Machado did the majority of the procedure, Carpenter was the one to remove and handle the kidney.
“That was kind of a cool thing, that my daughter took one of my organs out,” said Colleen. “I totally trusted her. I know her hands, how precise she is, how she wants everything to be perfect.”
During recovery, Maggie made sure to come in and tell her mother jokes, giving her the same taste of laughter after abdominal surgery that her mother had given her and her father after their surgeries.
After the surgery in November, Colleen recovered in Carpenter’s house until she was well enough to drive back to Iowa. The experience has given Carpenter more insight into what her patients go through.
“I feel like I have a little insider information if you will about what it is going to look like, what is considered normal, what is abnormal,” she said. “It’s even simple things like what I think you should be wearing, or how you can go from lying in bed to sitting up without using muscle groups that will cause you more pain.”
Recently, Colleen received a letter recently from a man in Colorado who received her kidney, telling her that he had been on dialysis for more than two years, and how it has changed his life.
Six months after the transplant, she is fully recovered, she said, doing a phone interview during a 10-mile walk. “I wish people knew how easy it was to donate, and how it’s really not changing your life at all,” she said. “I feel the same, other than that I need to make sure I stay hydrated.”
A few months after coming to Pittsburgh while her mom got the transplant, Maggie moved here permanently in March — the first time in decades that she and Carpenter have lived in the same city.
“It’s just really special because now we have an adult relationship where she’s healthy,” said Carpenter. “The kidney transplants have really given us the sister relationship that we’ve always wanted.”
It’s something that she wants for other families as well, and tries to encourage by promoting organ donation.
“We’ve come so far in regard to the field of surgery, the practice of medicine — it’s much easier for people to donate,” she said. “One of my jobs is to remove those barriers of the fear of what could happen. If I can do anything to help remove those barriers, that’s my ultimate goal.”
Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.