The first sentence of nearly every story and study written about breakfast includes the phrase “most important meal of the day,” but the more recent of those go on to note something unexpected.

While breakfast has been associated with weight management, and cardio-metabolic and cognitive performance, many experts still find the evidence is inconclusive.

Further, breakfast data citing its impact on daily nutrient and caloric intake, especially when compared to breakfast skippers, use inconsistent definitions of “breakfast” and what it means to bypass it, muddying their conclusions.

Here’s what can be said.

Advertise with us

Breakfast revs the body metabolically after each day’s incidental fast, which occurs while sleeping.

Simplicity has long been a hallmark of this early meal.

Greeks and Romans consumed bread, cheese, wine, honey and oil. Later, working class folks adopted cooked grains to prepare them for the day ahead. The rich began including eggs around the 1600s.

And today, many Americans opt for the modern version of gruel, which transformed “simplicity” to convenience: commercially made cereal.

But with the jury still out on breakfast — and evidence that versions of boxed cereal marketed to Americans contains considerably more added sugar than their international counterparts — perhaps it’s time for a breakfast reset.

Advertise with us

Here, six Pittsburgh athletes and/or nutritional experts discuss what is on their breakfast plates and why.

Colin Champ, M.D.

(Courtesy of Colin Champ)

Director of the AHN Cancer Institute Exercise Oncology & Resiliency Center, radiation oncologist and nutrition researcher

On a typical day, Champ scrambles six whole eggs from pasture-raised chickens, or turns them into an omelet, with raw, aged cheese from grass-fed cow’s milk, onions, lots of spinach, Himalayan salt, pepper, and sometimes Calabrian chiles or kimchi, all of which “tells [his] brain, ‘We are ready to go for the day.’”

Champ follows a nutrient-dense, “non-reductionist” diet, which is unusual in American culture, he finds.

“Much of the population is vitamin/nutrient/protein deficient, partially due to reductionist eating approaches that often limit nutrient-dense foods,” he said. “A good breakfast aims to avoid all three!

Advertise with us

“This breakfast helps to maximize body composition (i.e., low body fat and high muscle), which studies show is a vital component of healthy aging.”

Jack Suwinski, baseball player

(Justin Berl / Getty Images)

Outfielder, Pittsburgh Pirates

Choosing consistently nutritious meals takes discipline, but sometimes biology gives a helpful nudge.

“I have Celiac disease, so gluten-free for me. That puts me in a pretty easy lane,” Suwinski said. “It helps me stay away from waffles and pancakes, breakfast pastries and cereal. I’m not really having those anyway.”

Instead, he opts for a gluten-free bagel with avocado and eggs, or bacon or sausage with fruit, plus coffee and plenty of water.

Advertise with us

He calls those meals “pretty basic,” though they aren’t without consideration.

When choosing fruit, he thinks about mixing colors, and therefore nutrients. And while gluten is quite actually off the table because of his body’s penchant to view it as an invader, he still takes care to eat a clean, minimally processed diet.

“It gives me good energy and something in my stomach to work off of,” he said. “It makes you feel good. It’s a good start to the day.”

Amy Scheuneman, runner

(JJ LaBella / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Director of youth programming at P3R, which organizes the Pittsburgh Marathon

Scheuneman completed the Ironman 70.3 Pennsylvania Happy Valley in July, the Erie Marathon in September and, just a few weeks ago, competed in the Boston Marathon, all while fueled by her typical breakfast of plain oatmeal with blueberries, and a “little” drizzle of honey.

Advertise with us

“Blueberries are considered a super fruit with lots of nutrients, fiber and antioxidants. The oatmeal keeps me full for a long period of time, so I can make it through any workout or race without feeling hungry. And the honey gives it a sweet kick to get me going in the morning and satisfy that sugar craving,” she said.

She knows that her main audience — kids — might also enjoy that drizzle of sweetness, though she urges moderation.

“Parents should be very mindful of all the added sugar in youth food options, especially sugary cereals. Read labels and limit ‘added sugar’ to 25 grams per day,” she said. “Many kids love breakfast foods, so hopefully this is an easy meal to get your kids as much nutrition as possible to start their day on the right foot!”

Auburn Paulone, registered dietitian

(Courtesy of Auburn Paulone)

University of Pittsburgh assistant athletic director for performance nutrition

Paulone enjoys variety in her morning meals, rarely eating the same thing two days in a row. But the nutritional makeup of those meals remains consistent: protein-focused with a balance between fruit, grains and healthy fats.

Advertise with us

And if you think that means she eats a rotation of toast, scrambled eggs and oatmeal, think again: “Anything can fit into breakfast,” she said. “It doesn’t necessarily have to be a ‘breakfast’ food.”

As a result, peanut butter and jelly sandwiches with 1% milk, egg salad with crackers and grapes, and two-to-three hard-boiled eggs with peanut butter crackers and blueberries all make appearances on her morning plates.

For more traditional options, she eats egg sandwiches with fruit, three scrambled eggs with mini French toast bites and grapes, steel-cut oats with blueberries and 1% milk, or Greek yogurt with a banana, honey and cinnamon.

While she adds in glasses of 1% milk for additional protein, she splashes in some fun with vanilla extract, chocolate syrup or chocolate protein powder.

Natalie Gentile, M.D.

(Courtesy of Natalie Gentile)

Family and lifestyle physician and founder of Rebel Wellness, LLC in Shadyside

Advertise with us

Before Gentile teaches her 9:30 a.m. workout classes at Rebel Wellness, she’s dressed her two kids, prepared them — and herself — for the day and gotten all of them out of the door.

That’s why her breakfasts are premade and portable.

A favorite is chia seed pudding, made in batches of four or five jars at a time.

In each jar, she combines three tablespoons chia seeds (adding five grams of protein, 10 grams of fiber and omega-3 fatty acids), one tablespoon real maple syrup and one cup unsweetened soy milk (adding 12 grams of protein), and gives the jars a shake before setting them in the refrigerator.

Each morning, Gentile just grabs a jar, and tops the mixture off with some berries or cinnamon for added fiber and nutrients.

Advertise with us

Tommie Lin O’Hanlon, ballerina

(Michael Henninger)

Pittsburgh Ballet Theater principal artist

O’Hanlon’s success during a busy day of rehearsals relies on a strong nutritional foundation each morning. Part of that success is planning.

Two “egg muffins,” baked ahead of time, with an English muffin or toast, provide enough protein and carbohydrates, which she’s careful to embrace, to keep her jetés flying high all day long.

Using two muffin pans, she cracks two eggs into each slot. For even more protein, she adds cottage cheese, then whichever fixings seem tasty: ham and cheese, broccoli and cheddar, sausage and bell peppers, or potato and turkey sausage.

Eating two of these egg muffins, with her bread of choice, plus a full glass of water with added electrolytes, fuels her body each day, but the foods she avoids are just as impactful.

Advertise with us

“I try to eat whole foods as much as I can, and limit highly processed foods and alcohol,” she said. “The inflammation processed foods and alcohol cause in the body is not worth it for me. That being said, I still allow myself these things on the weekends and holidays or in less intense times of work. Just like being en pointe, it is all about the balance!”

PG columnist Jason Mackey contributed to this story.

Abby Mackey is a registered nurse and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites