Traditional acts of chivalry might include holding a door. Others might have a superior officer help his love interest remove her weighty dragon scale armor after she was wounded in a sparring match.

Walking along a secluded beach together might qualify as a swoon-worthy moment, but so might the telepathic exchange of romantic thoughts, an ability forged by a couple’s mythical creatures.

The latter depiction of romance — heightened by the pressures of strife or war in a fantastical world — is having a major moment in literary fiction.

Romantic fantasy, or “romantasy,” is flying off the shelves and into the hands of women 84% of the time, according to a Romance Writers of America survey.

Advertise with us

Sociologically, a large part of the answer to “why?” is BookTok, a vein of the popular — and embattled — social media app TikTok, where influencers show what they’re reading and what they thought about it, contributing to the sales of 20 million print books in 2021, according to Bookscan data.

While books could be influencer-driven impulse buys, like Owala water bottles or hair curling headbands, there’s evidence that BookTok followers are actually reading — all 528 pages of romantasy author Rebecca Yarros’ brick-like “Fourth Wing,” for instance.

Her second book, “Iron Flame,” became Waterstones publishing’s fastest selling pre-order in a single day, and super-fans lined up at bookstores for the chance to snag the first copies, signaling that the “why” isn’t bound to BookTok alone.

“People have always turned to fiction for escapism,” said Atesede Makonnen, assistant professor of English, with a focus on pop culture and romance, at Carnegie Mellon University. “Every generation has something to escape from, and right now, it seems like romantic fantasy is the escape.”

In an interview for PBS NewsHour, Yarros points to one possible reason.

Advertise with us

“[Y]ou’re coming out of a post-pandemic world, and I think a lot of reading really shot up during the pandemic,” she said. “So you have people who are coming into reading fiction that weren’t there before.”

The people may be new, but the genre, in ways, is not.

Makonnen has a special interest in when novels gained the form we think of today.

In part, they’re departures from the prose form called romance. Popularized in the 18th and 19th centuries in Europe, they too contained elements of fantasy, such as castles and ghosts — a double-whammy of escapism, so to speak.

While he doesn’t prefer the term “escapism” — “distraction” is better, he noted — Keith Oatley, professor emeritus of cognitive psychology at the University of Toronto, has studied how deeply fiction can affect the reader.

Advertise with us

“What we found is that people who read fiction understand people better than other people who don’t read fiction, and they have better empathy for others,” he said. “Here’s the thing about romance, you ready? The two genres that work best to create this effect are romance stories and detective stories,” two of the top-selling literary genres.

That empathy seems to be the conduit to distraction, allowing us to push aside our own responsibilities, take on the intentions of the protagonist and, “if that protagonist behaves in a way that we like, we feel fond of that person,” he said.

The thinness of the veil between fiction and reality is emphasized by a 2006 study, published in the journal NeuroImage, where participants were asked to read words with strong odor associations, like jasmine or cinnamon, and more ordinary words, like door or cup.

As observed via an fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging) machine, language centers of the brain activated while reading all of the words, but for scent-associated words, participants’ olfactory cortexes also lit up, indicating that they perceived words on a page as though they were sensing them with their own organs.

The immersive nature of fiction, and the allure of romance, led to concern as romance gave way to the novel, according to Makonnen, that they might “create expectations” in readers, “teach them something they shouldn’t know,” or would cause them to “turn away from reality.”

Advertise with us

But in 2024, when the book industry is fueled by young adults talking about literature through a ring light so they can look cute while doing it, those aren’t anxieties. They’re selling points.

“Obviously, we can have very healthy relationships with reading, but the idea that it could be that powerful, I think that’s still a big part of our reading experience,” she said. “It’s amazing. People who say they don’t like reading will try something like a Sarah J. Maas [romantasy] book and, suddenly, they’ve read the entire series.

“That’s powerful, I think.”

Abby Mackey is a registered nurse and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites