If you aren’t this person, you know one.

As soon as a child’s fever spikes, so does parental anxiety. The medicine cups fly. Someone’s drawing a bath. There may be a call to the pediatrician’s after-hours line.

Here’s the tough love: In most cases, those are overreactions.

“We don’t treat fevers just because you have a fever,” said Todd Wolynn, pediatrician and co-founder of Kids Plus Pediatrics in Squirrel Hill, Pleasant Hills and Cranberry. “Fevers are the body’s sign that it’s responding to some sort of situation, whether it’s infection or a revved up immune system from a vaccine.”

Advertise with us

The antidote to fear-based reactions — and having confidence that fever is not, in itself, an enemy — is education.

It’s important to know that clinicians don’t classify an elevated temperature as “fever” until it reaches 100.5 degrees Fahrenheit or higher.

To know that, caregivers must assess how warm the child is.

A “tactile temperature” is the clinical term for “feels warm.” While this method is often used to rule out fever — “He doesn’t feel warm” — it is often viewed as less reliable when it comes to positively identifying one.

According to a 2017 meta-analysis, tactile assessment correctly identified a fevered patient 87.5% of the time, though identifying the height of the fever, or that the warmth was due to fever and not something else, was far less accurate.

Advertise with us

Instead of relying on mom or dad’s hands, a thermometer is an important inclusion in any medicine cabinet. Knowing which kind is best is debatable, however.

Mercury thermometers are a known hazard. Dispose of those in accordance with local ordinances.

Wolynn calls tympanic (in the ear) thermometers “tricky.” That notion is supported by a 2021 study that notes differing temperatures between left and right ears. The study identifies asymmetries in ear structure and user technique as contributors to temperature reading inaccuracies, and recommends measuring temperature in the same ear as a result.

Wolynn also vetoes pacifier thermometers due to lack of accuracy.

Temporal (forehead) thermometers get his go-ahead, though accuracy hinges on good technique and, according to a study from 2009, can be influenced by factors such as perspiration and ambient temperature.

Advertise with us

Digital oral thermometers also make Wolynn’s A-list, so long as the patient hasn’t had anything to eat or drink within the past 15 minutes.

But for children 2 years old and younger, the gold standard method is a rectal temperature to most accurately assess core body temperature.

In cases when a fever is confirmed, the question is what to do next.

For babies 2-months-old and younger, any clinical fever should be met with a call to their pediatrician.

“That’s before kids can get any vaccines, so they’re relying on antibodies from their mom via the placenta,” Wolynn said. “And we know that fevers in kids that age can rarely represent bacterial infection, which can be life-threatening.”

Advertise with us

For kids with a history of febrile seizures — which tend to run in families — it’s entirely appropriate to immediately treat a fever with Tylenol, ibuprofen or a combination, in accordance with their health care provider’s advice.

For the rest, Wolynn preaches a discerning approach.

Whether the fever is a vaccine response or due to illness, caregivers should ask themselves how the child is behaving: Are they playing and having conversations, or are they sluggish and seem significantly affected?

If it’s the latter, he supports the use of an anti-fever medication.

When it comes to whether the child should be seen by a medical practitioner, his criteria includes three questions.

Advertise with us

1. Is the fever over 105 degrees Fahrenheit?

“It’s not that the kid is going to explode. It’s just two standard deviations above the average fever, so we want to know about it, and we may want to see you,” Wolynn said.

2. Has the fever lasted for five days or more?

“That’s a little longer than the average viral illness, so I’d want to hear about it,” he said.

3. Does the fever present with other concerning symptoms?

Advertise with us

Wolynn cites examples such as pain in the ear(s) or throat or suspected dehydration, evinced by decreased drinking and urination or the inside of the mouth feeling sticky rather than wet.

When those clues are present, or the caregiver is otherwise concerned, make an appointment, or at least a phone call.

To address the Dumbo in the room, fever discussions are sometimes muddied by fears that treating a fever impedes the body’s ability to fight the viral intruder on its own.

The answer is probably not.

“There haven’t been any great studies saying not to give Tylenol or ibuprofen because you’re going to make them sicker,” Wolynn said.

Advertise with us

The same question lingers in the zeitgeist when it comes to whether anti-fever medications impede the effects of vaccines.

In that case, it depends.

Because the evidence isn’t strong enough to think otherwise, Wolynn supports treating a vaccine-associated fever if the child is feeling “lousy,” but not otherwise.

“You’re literally giving things to the body that modify, not just fever, but other processes … you want your body to respond to the vaccine as it normally would,” he said.

Unequivocally, he does not support proactively treating an otherwise healthy child (with no history of febrile seizures) with Tylenol or ibuprofen before receiving vaccines, in the hope of staving off fever.

Advertise with us

A 2009 study assessed healthy infants, aged 9 to 16 weeks, treated with three prophylactic doses of Tylenol leading up to routine vaccines. The result was a substantial reduction in antibody response to those immunizations.

As always, there are exceptions to general advice. Patients with kidney concerns or sensitive stomachs might avoid ibuprofen. Patients with liver concerns might avoid Tylenol. A host of other medical conditions could require tailored approaches.

But for the majority of fever fighters, Taylor Swift said it: You need to calm down.

“We want to get people out of the mindset of, ‘Oh no, my kid’s temperature is 99 or over 100.5. I have to do something about it,’” he said. “There’s nothing suggesting you need to treat them.”

Abby Mackey is a registered nurse and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites