By this time of year, New Year’s celebrations feel like distant memories, relegated to a few stray pieces of confetti found in dusty corners of party rooms.
The same is true for New Year’s resolutions, with an estimated 80% failure rate by mid-February. Like most years, some of the most common 2024 resolutions centered on nutrition and fitness: losing weight, exercising more and/or eating better.
In a country where nutrition-related diseases are widespread — among adults, more than 70% are overweight or obese, 50% have diabetes or prediabetes, and 50% have cardiovascular disorders — those resolutions are almost prescriptions for a healthier life.
But food- or weight-related resolutions — adopted at any time of year — can be a slippery slope for some. Masquerading as ways to improve health, “resolutions” can become preoccupations, invading a person’s thoughts and influencing their behaviors throughout every day and, ultimately, affecting their health status.
While those ways of thinking and being may not meet the rigorous definitions of clinical eating disorders, they do describe another clinically significant finding — disordered eating.
Housed underneath the broader eating disorders umbrella, it’s less discussed, and less formalized. Because disordered eating lacks the attention anorexia or bulimia nervosa receive, people affected by these pervasive thoughts about weight may not realize their “healthy” motivations could do the opposite.
Creating that awareness is part of the purpose of National Eating Disorders Awareness Week, which kicks off on Monday.
“We have people coming into our clinic saying, ‘I started this from a place of health promotion.’ Or, ‘I got feedback from a person in my life or a health care provider or a magazine that suggested I lose weight. I felt really good. I received a lot of positive comments,’” said Rachel Kolko-Conlon, clinical psychologist and assistant professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine’s department of psychiatry. “From there, it just goes farther and farther.”
Clinicians view relationships with food on a spectrum, with “normal” eating at one end, clinical eating disorders on the other and, in the middle, disordered eating.
“We can see one person progress from normal eating all the way to a clinical eating disorder,” said Jennifer Beckjord, psychologist and director of eating disorders services at UPMC Western Psychiatric Hospital. “But someone can engage in non-normative eating [or disordered eating] and never develop an eating disorder.”
What challenges individuals and clinicians is the current wellness-focused American climate, where fad diets and radical exercise plans reach the mainstream as fast as social media influencers can click “post,” normalizing behaviors that might otherwise be viewed as extreme.
“When you go into any social media application, we’re bombarded with weight and eating messages,” Beckjord said. “We have really fascinating data from the ’80s and ’90s that, as Western culture spreads and as people have gained internet and social media access, the rise in eating disorders follows,” across all genders and backgrounds, not just the stereotype of affluent white girls.
“When it comes to who’s at risk for disordered eating or an eating disorder, you can think of it as concentric circles or a Venn diagram,” Kolko-Conlon said. “There are individual factors — biology, genetics. And we know those interact with factors outside of ourselves — familial, peer, teacher/coach/school factors. These are all circles that build out and show how all of these factors interact and overlap in someone’s life, resulting in compounding risk.”

Verifying a clinical eating disorder is certainly nuanced but somewhat straightforward, as their criteria exist in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders — the standard for mental health diagnoses in the U.S. and Canada.
While that criteria helps to identify trends, it also can create them.
Since the newest edition of the DSM published in 2013, known as the DSM-V, spikes in eating disorder risk have been observed, including among young males.
That data doesn’t necessarily identify an objective increase in prevalence, but the effect of new diagnostic criteria, Beckjord said.
Identifying anorexia nervosa, for instance — the eating disorder most commonly associated with extreme thinness — now lacks references to body weight percentage, since the disorder is more about behaviors than weight. And it no longer includes amenorrhea (or the loss of menstruation, due to low body fat percentage, in this case) among its criteria, removing the implication that anorexia only occurs in females.
Contributing to the uptick of childhood eating disorders since 2013 is the addition of ARFID, or avoidant and restrictive food intake disorder. The diagnosis recognizes young people with self-imposed eating restrictions, due to sensory preferences or previous negative experiences, that affect weight, nutritional status or health.
But disordered eating doesn’t have its own entry in the DSM or an agreed-upon set of criteria. And because the behaviors are often masked as methods to improve health, they can easily elude the afflicted and clinicians.
The thoughts and behaviors, if severe enough, can be labeled, per the DSM, as OSFED, or other specified feeding or eating disorder, though that doesn’t capture all cases, which leads to difficulty identifying prevalence.
A 2023 meta-analysis concluded that 22% of the world’s children and adolescents are affected by disordered eating. Because of societal influences and relatively low awareness about disordered eating, for example, the numbers for adults are less clear.
A good first step to reaching those in need of assistance, however, is creating awareness around which food-related behaviors might be objectively problematic in a social landscape marred with especially subjective definitions of “normal.”
According to Kolko-Conlon, a self check-in can help.
Think about how much time eating, weight or appearance occupies your mental space. If those thoughts, or the behaviors that result, are affecting your time management or social life, that might be a red flag. Examples such as dodging social situations in favor of workouts or avoiding events where eating might be expected could signal a concerning relationship with body image.
Also, think about your value system, or why you’re engaging with certain food or exercise habits. If you were raised with a strict vegan diet, for instance, and are carrying that on, and/or if it aligns with your current beliefs, those rationales are viewed as “safer” compared to someone who might view the diet as an excuse to cut calories.
In a related category, Kolko-Conlon might ask if the behaviors bring her patients joy, knowing that genuine joy is different from only enjoying what comes from them: Think marathon running for the thrill of adventure versus for marathon running simply for calorie burn.
Regardless of values or joy, food and exercise behaviors shouldn’t hinder health, meaning medical practitioners should find you well upon physical exam and through diagnostic testing, such as blood work.
And examine your weight maintenance strategies. If purging behaviors, the use of diet pills, excessive exercise (including having to “make up for” certain foods) or restrictive eating (such as skipping meals) are in your repertoire, it might be time to consider what should happen next.
Kolko-Conlon and Beckjord agree that the “cure” for some cases of disordered eating could be found by simply bringing attention to these behaviors through self-reflection. For others, professional support might be necessary.
But for all of them, the stigma and bias around body weight, shape and size in Western culture is yet another -ism, driving a desire for acceptance, and maybe a few well-meaning resolutions that go too far.
“The disordered eating rates are probably much higher than the diagnosed. Awareness around disordered eating could help those affected expose their resources, rather than just keeping it all internalized,” Kolko-Conlon said. “Recognizing who might be in their life, who offers helpful support, or are making comments that might make you feel poorly, this is really important awareness.
“Even wondering about this is really important, and could let you know that maybe now is the time to take action.”
Abby Mackey is a registered nurse and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.