On the “NFL Today” broadcast Sunday, retired NFL star J.J. Watt had some news. His brother, Steelers linebacker T.J. Watt, “just got out of the MRI tube,” he announced, and was diagnosed with a grade 2 MCL sprain. “It is a best-case scenario for him,” he said.
T.J. Watt injured his left knee late in the third quarter during Saturday’s game against the Baltimore Ravens in a collision with teammate Montravius Adams.
So what is an MCL sprain?
And what does that “best-case scenario” mean for the Steelers heading into the playoffs?
An MCL, or medial collateral ligament, runs along the inside of the knee, connecting the thigh bone, or femur, to the shin bone, or tibia. “It is one of the primary stabilizers of the knee,” explained Sarah Manspeaker, associate professor in the department of athletic training at Duquesne University.
When the MCL is injured, it is often during contact sports that also involve twisting and cutting, such as football, ice hockey and soccer. The injury can occur through a sharp change in direction or — more often — a collision involving the outside of the knee.
Read More

When an MCL sprain occurs through a collision, “they are usually struck on the outside of their knee and they become sort of knock-kneed,” said Matthew Silvis, medical director of sports medicine at Penn State Health and team physician for the Hershey Bears minor league hockey team. “It stretches the inner part of their knee and the ligament either stretches and goes back to normal like a rubber band, or it can tear.”
If the ligament is injured, it can range in severity from grade 1 to grade 3. A grade 2 sprain would generally show on an MRI as having some thickness, swelling or a partial tear.
Top of mind for Steelers fans, of course, is recovery time. While every athlete is different, Mr. Watt has the advantage of being highly motivated, in excellent shape with excellent medical care. But he would still miss at least one playoff game.
“The fastest he’d be able to come back is a full week from now, but likely it would be at least two weeks,” said Vehniah Tjong, associate professor at Northwestern University, in an interview Monday evening. “Depending on how he meets his milestones, it could be shorter or longer.”
Dr. Tjong, team physician of Northwestern University’s football team and the U.S. women’s national soccer team, said that the dangers of Mr. Watt coming back too early are limited agility on the field, as well as the potential to injure other ligaments in the knee or to more seriously injure his MCL. If he plays this season, he will likely be doing so with a leg brace to support the knee and prevent further injury, she said.
Dr. Silvis estimated a range between two and four weeks for an athlete to return from a grade 2 MCL sprain.
“Some athletes can heal faster, but you want full range of motion, good strength and to be able to participate and handle the functional demands of the sport,” he said. “If you meet that criteria you are ready to go back, whatever the timeline is.”
Treatment for an MCL sprain includes time for the swelling to go down, and then exercises to improve range of motion and strengthen the knee. Some sports teams use a treatment called PRP, or platelet-rich plasma, in which an athlete’s own blood is spun in a centrifuge and injected into the injured area.
“It may speed up the injury healing but there’s no clear evidence,” said Dr. Tjong. “It depends on the team culture.”
And for the Steelers, one focus has to be on keeping Mr. Watt — who on Sunday became the first NFL player to lead the league in sacks in three separate seasons — healthy not just for the remainder of this season but for the future.
“There’s a high recurrence rate,” said Dr. Silvis. “If you have injured your MCL one time, you can certainly injure it again. If you are T.J. Watt and you are going back to professional football, you certainly are in a sport that has a high risk of being struck again.”
Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.