For more than five years, conversations have been happening across Pennsylvania about plans to create a pathway to make doula support available to Medicaid beneficiaries.
Research shows that pregnant people who have doula support are more likely to have better birth outcomes, including reduced risk of cesarean and a reduced need for pain medication. And the presence of continuous support helps expectant parents to feel safe.

These are just a few of the benefits an individual may experience while having a doula present during pregnancy and birth. But accessibility issues have persisted, notably as doula services have not been covered by Medicaid in Pennsylvania.
Historically, most families have paid for doula support out of pocket, or by grant programs that cover the cost. This presents a challenge for families with income barriers who qualify for Medical Assistance and the doulas supporting them. According to the Pa. Department of Health, of the 671,145 births that occurred between 2017 and 2021, 224,162 births — about 33% — were covered by Medicaid.
Years of discussion led, in October, to the Certified Perinatal Doula Credential, a state issuance that allows doulas to work with Medicaid.
Doulas with the credential will be able to enroll as providers and provide reimbursable services with Medical Assistance beginning Feb. 1, per the state DHS. This solution is interim, until the Senate bill solidifying the amendment is passed.
Read More
The need for credentialing
As doulas, we care a great deal for the community and the families we serve. When supporting families that simply cannot pay, this care can result in a loss financially. Doulas spend countless hours with the person they have been hired to support, making referrals, doing check-ins and home visits, providing education, maintaining records and more.
The costs associated with supporting families with income barriers leave many doulas without a livable wage.
The new credential expands access to birthing support, as it allows doulas to not have to turn families away due to inability to pay.
In 2021, the concept of credentialing was presented by the DHS and Pennsylvania Certification Board. Most doulas were skeptical about the concept of credentialing certifications when applications started being accepted in January 2022 — and with good reason.
Due to racism and classism, the credentialing in birth work has a dark history in the United States. Methods used in the past to develop credentialing processes have created greater barriers — to accessing culturally competent care from midwives for Black families and families historically placed in the margins — that persist to this day. There is no research that supports the idea that more regulation improves maternal health outcomes, so the concept of creating credentials and certifications needs to be handled with great care.
So, why use credentialing now? There certainly are pros and cons. I have wrestled with this idea over the years and continuously reflect on how midwives were treated and feel a sense of responsibility to ensure that what happened to past Black midwives does not happen to present-day doulas.
Common misconceptions
One pervasive misconception is that the Certified Perinatal Doula credential is required for all doulas in Pennsylvania.
Credentialing of doulas is unique, in that it is not required to serve families as a doula in general. The Certified Perinatal Doula credential is exclusively for use with Medical Assistance insurance companies (also known as Managed Care Organizations).
Doulas who are interested in being credentialed as in-network providers for MCOs beginning Feb. 1, as was announced by DHS in a commonwealth-wide commission meeting held in October, will need to obtain the Certified Perinatal Doula credential.
Conversely, doulas who are not interested in seeking credentialing to be reimbursed for services provided to Medicaid beneficiaries need not apply.
The Pennsylvania Doula Commission has received grant funding from the Jewish Healthcare Foundation so that doulas may obtain subsidy grants to cover the $50 cost of the Certified Perinatal Doula credential application.
Another misconception is that specific training organizations are required for the credential that qualifies a doula to work with Medical Assistance.
In fact, pathways to credentialing for experienced and/or class-trained doulas have been developed to ensure that no one is left behind. No training organization has been excluded, and the requirements for training are the same as those for practicing doulas. Experienced doulas who have never been certified with a training organization can pursue certification through client evaluations.
Risks remain
But what are some of the risks associated with Medicaid reimbursement for and credentialing?
One risk is bias. Biases are present everywhere we go. Unfortunately, doulas have not always been allowed in some medical spaces.
At times, we must prove that we are doulas, having to show documentation. These interruptions delay support for the person laboring in the hospital. Hospitals will have to understand that a doula obtaining the Certified Perinatal Doula credential is not meant to replace any previously held training or experience.
The credential is to unify the doulas who want to be recognized by Medical Assistance. By not allowing doulas to enter labor and delivery facilities based on certification — or lack thereof — hospitals cause harm to the individuals in their care who are relying on that doula’s presence.
As we embark on this journey of credentialing with Medicaid, it is wise to manage misplaced expectations. There are individuals who believe that reimbursement for doulas will improve the racial disparities that exist in maternal and infant health. This incorrect thinking assumes that racial inequities only occur with Medicaid participants or that most Medicaid participants are of the global majority.
I would caution anyone thinking that doulas are the solution to racial disparities to remember that there are many things that are out of a doula’s control, such as: personal bias of providers, racism that may exist in hospital policies and systemic and/or environmental racism, just to name a few. All have an impact on health outcomes during pregnancy and postpartum.
Outcomes should not be left on the shoulders of doulas alone. Gov. Josh Shapiro on Oct. 31 signed Act 5, formerly known as Senate Bill No. 262, to make maternal mortality and morbidity a reportable event in Pennsylvania. October also saw the launch of the Black Maternal Health Caucus, to address the state’s maternal mortality crisis.
All agree that to see measurable improvement in outcomes, much work is needed to turn the current statistics around. Until those times come, doulas will always be present to provide continuous support to the families we serve in the community. And we will continue to examine the benefits, risks and alternatives to how we as professionals can improve how we support families in Pennsylvania.
Gerria Coffee is the president of the Pennsylvania Doula Commission.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.