When parents of younger children bemoan the difficulties of raising their tiny tots, it’s not uncommon for more seasoned moms and dads to chime in with a “Just wait until they’re teenagers.”
No matter which war story of parenting they tell, the toughness of raising adolescents often boils down to one issue: the tension between child-like and adult-like behavior.
That’s the very same issue Beatriz Luna, Ph.D. Staunton Distinguished Professor of Psychiatry and Pediatrics and professor of psychology at the University of Pittsburgh, commented on in Supreme Court briefs regarding extended sentencing in the juvenile justice system.
But it wasn’t until she co-authored a study this October alongside a handful of other Pitt scholars and Pittsburgh-native Brenden Tervo-Clemmens, Ph.D., assistant professor in the department of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at the University of Minnesota, that the question “When does an adolescent start thinking like an adult?” received a definitive, clinically applicable answer.
The first-of-its-kind study, published in Nature Communications, assessed over 10,000 people age 8 to 25 years old, at four testing sites across the country, as they completed 17 different tasks of executive functioning, an umbrella term for humans’ ability to plan, switch from task to task, resist distractions and focus. Researchers then measured those reactions nearly two dozen ways.
“We have a standard unit of measurement when it comes to creating a growth chart for height, right? It’s a ruler. We’re still struggling to find those right ones in psychology,” Tervo-Clemmens said. “What we need to do — and we did it here — is show that no matter the ruler, or cognitive instruments in this case, they all showed the same thing.”
Read More
The results didn’t just affirm executive functioning improvements through these years of development, as demonstrated by previous studies, but identified the precise magnitude and timing of those achievements.
Specifically, the study showed a rapid burst of executive function development in late childhood to mid-adolescence (10 to 15 years old), a small-but-significant period of improvement through mid-adolescence (15 to 18 years old) and — the splashiest result — a stabilization to adult-level performance by late adolescence (18 to 20 years old.)
But that doesn’t mean a light switch suddenly flips at age 18.
“What we’re saying is cognition becomes stable at 18 to 20. Before that, there’s availability of adult-level cognition, it’s just not something you can use all the time,” Luna said. “And there’s so much emotion and reward processing when you’re younger that can derail you. But if you’re in a quiet room, making straightforward decisions, have a lot of time to decide, even younger people can make those decisions.”
Study participants were asked to complete executive functioning-related tasks such as resisting eye movement to a tempting object, written assessments and computer-based trials, such as identifying which image is different than the rest.
“We have them do many trials of these tests,” Luna said. “Every once in a while, they get it perfectly right, just like an adult would, which tells you they do have the capability. They just don’t have the ability to get it right all the time.”
These results now confirm the hunches of parents everywhere in ways that can be of clinical value.
“In this definition of what makes an adolescent an adolescent, this period of refining mastery, means that when we talk about treatment, we should think about involving the adolescent and thinking about autonomy,” Tervo-Clemmens said.
And Brayden Kameg, DNP, psychiatric-mental health nurse practitioner and co-owner of Peace of Mind Psychiatry in Bridgeville, knows it will have an impact on navigating the parent-child dynamics within her client base.
“I see adolescents with a variety of mental health diagnoses. Parents oftentimes get frustrated with their behavior, like why are they doing this?” she said. “I think this study is really helpful thinking about that plateau at age 18. I think it’s helpful to explain this to parents. ‘We hear this frustrating, however this is not going to be forever, and this is in line with what we expect developmentally.’”
Importantly, by the study demonstrating what is typical for these age groups, it consequently identifies what is atypical and perhaps worthy of professional intervention.
“When we think about the age of onset for a lot of mental health diagnoses, it is this young adult, late adolescent period, so bipolar and psychotic disorders. I think knowing that executive functioning plateaus at 18, when we see risk-taking or impulsive behaviors at that age, it might not be wise to chalk them up to being an 18-year-old,” Kameg said. “As clinicians, we may need to be more diligent in following up during that critical time period.”
Kameg, who is also assistant professor of nursing at the University of Pittsburgh, raises one concern about the everyday applicability of these data, however.
“My take is this 18-to-25-year-old group may show similar findings to adults on these executive functioning tests, but do they have the life experience and wisdom and ability to regulate their emotions to make adult-like decisions? That I don’t know,” she said. “When it comes to more complex psycho-social and social relationship, I don’t know that an 18-year-old is able to make the same sorts of decisions as a 35-year-old in more complicated situations.”
That’s in line with what the Tervo-Clemmens-led team hopes to accomplish next.
“We want to get these measurements out of the laboratory,” he said. “We want to be able to measure how cognition changes from day to day, when kids have a bad day at school or a good day. The goal is to leverage new technology to study cognition across contexts in real teenagers’ day-to-day lives.”
And someday, this information could be used to create a “cognitive pediatric growth chart” not unlike the graphs and waveforms used for charting pediatric height and weight, which is just another step toward addressing a generations-old question.
“You can go back 100 years, and there were people debating when adolescents reach adulthood. Some of the earliest psychological papers are written about this idea,” Tervo-Clemmens said. “One reason why this study, and why this moment in science, is there’s a big movement toward what we can and can’t say definitively.
“What is exciting about these big data and getting conclusive answers is we have data that can really validate our intuitions.”
Abby Mackey is a registered nurse, and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.