This is the second article in our occasional Inter/actions series, looking at items that don’t play nicely with others.
Using activated charcoal to blacken coffee, toothpaste, ice cream and lemonade is not a new trend, but studies continue to debunk its benefits, especially of the dental variety.
Medically, activated charcoal is used by toxicologists when someone has ingested an acute poison. It’s also used for water filtration. Charcoal works well in these instances because it is “adsorbent”: That is, instead of absorbing or metabolizing chemicals, activated charcoal is chemically sticky and picks up what it interacts with while moving through the digestive tract and through water.

But the substance is also indiscriminate, said Michael Lynch, associate medical director of the Pittsburgh Poison Center. It’s not picky about what it binds to, though it does prefer big molecules to small ones. This means that trendy charcoal latte or charcoal pill meant for “detox” can actually clear medicines out of your body that you took on purpose.
“If you took a blood pressure or heart medicine an hour ago, [charcoal] could limit how much medicine is in your system,” said Lynch. “If you’re a 22-year-old, not on any medications, and you have it in a cocktail, fine. But if you’re on meds, there is some potential for risk that may be underrecognized.”
The “hangover cure” tale of activated charcoal, too, is nonsense, said Lynch. The intoxicating alcohol compound, ethanol, is small compared to other molecules; and remember, charcoal likes big molecules. Never mind the fact that the ethanol has left the digestive system by the morning after a night of drinking, but the sticky compound wouldn’t pick it up anyway.
Lynch said he’s seen a general trend in the past few years toward “natural” products and therapies, with the goal of reducing exposure to chemical additives. While that goal is not inherently negative, these products aren’t guaranteed to have an inherent benefit either.
The charcoal toothpaste trend gained momentum when these products were marketed for teeth-whitening, with claims its abrasive quality could clear away plaque. But studies on the whitening effect of charcoal toothpaste have found it does little by way of long-term impact — and might also lead to undue harm.
A recent review of 11 studies that measured activated charcoal toothpaste and whitening effect found it performed worse than traditional whitening products and peroxide solutions.
Not only did charcoal toothpaste not whiten teeth, but it was more abrasive than other methods. A 2020 article by researchers at the Nordic Institute of Dental Materials found that two charcoal toothpaste products they tested were 10 times more abrasive than controls. This abrasion can strip away enamel to reveal a tooth’s dentin, which is yellower in color and more sensitive without its protective coating.
A separate 2022 article by University of Maryland dentistry professors found that evidence of activated charcoal’s efficacy was lacking and urged providers to educate themselves on the impact of charcoal toothpaste, and to point interested patients toward the evidence.
Mary Anne Melo, senior author on that paper, said her patients began asking a few years ago if they should be using the black paste.

“It proved the need to be informed about some of the differences with charcoal toothpaste,” said Melo, a clinical professor at the University of Maryland School of Dentistry.
Namely, she and her colleagues found that many charcoal toothpastes were free of fluoride, which has shown to prevent cavities, and that charcoal could adsorb any fluoride already in the mouth, such as from drinking water.
“I do not recommend you use charcoal toothpaste,” she said.
Whether it clears away useful medicines or fluoride, it’s always a good idea to look out for potential interactions, even if something is marketed as natural.
“If you’re going to do a homeopathic remedy, be aware of the potential risks,” said Lynch. “And, as always, everything in moderation.”
Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.