The dos and don’ts of nutrition during pregnancy preoccupy nearly every nibble and nosh for the 40-ish weeks there’s a bun in the oven.

Whether breastfeeding, formula feeding or a combination, there’s at least a year of concern over the baby’s potential food sensitivities, which impacts what a nursing mom can consume (coffee? broccoli?) on through if the formula contains unwanted additives. And there are additional questions, such as: Which type of water is the right type to mix with it?

It’s no wonder that when children reach toddlerhood, beginning at age 1, parents are ready to pounce on the next anxiety-ridden nutritional adventure.

Here’s a tip: Skip the “toddler formula.”

Advertise with us

The American Academy of Pediatrics’ Committee on Nutrition penned a “clinical report” aimed at “formulas” whose advertising is directed at older infants and toddlers age 6 through 36 months.

The lengthy report, released Oct. 20, highlights issues with the products across many facets, and reinforces some of the ideas released in a 2019 “consensus statement” by the AAP and other health and nutrition organizations.

Nutritionally, they add avoidable sources of added sugar and salt. Their labels lack “standardization of nomenclature.” (Translation: The meaning of the words used on the canisters aren’t consistent from one brand to another.) The group calls the manufacturers’ marketing practices “questionable,” seemingly because these products’ purported value — “29 nutrients to support your toddler’s optimum development,” for example — contrast with the advice of many medical professionals.

And as opposed to infant formulas, these older infant-child formulas (OIYCFs) are not subject to the Infant Formula Act, enacted in 1980 and amended in 1986, which means there is no criteria for what these products contain, and the manufacturing facilities are not subject to the same inspections.

“Just stop buying it,” said Joe Aracri, system chair of pediatrics with Allegheny Health Network Pediatric Institute. “We never really recommended toddler formulas anyway. They’re just not necessary.”

Advertise with us

The punchline of Aracri’s reasoning is that these young kids should be eating their calories, not drinking them. The backstory is a little more nuanced.

First, the issue is growth rate and how that influences hunger.

During the first year of life, babies approximately triple their weight and rack up 10 inches of height. Through the second year, however, those numbers are cut in half.

“These toddlers don’t require a ton of calories,” Aracri said. “When kids drink these toddler formulas, or even drink too much milk,” no more than two cups per day for children under 2, “it kills their appetite.”

If they don’t have an appetite at meal time, they encounter the next issue: the loss of experimentation and whole food nutrition that comes with physically eating their calories.

Advertise with us

“It’s very important to expose your child to many different textures and flavors so they won’t become picky,” Aracri said. “It’s really important to set meal times, keep them well-rounded, and have children experience everything.”

For that matter, Aracri advises against pureed foods in pouches, which don’t require children to take food off of a spoon and move it around their mouths, important motions for speech development, he said.

Avoiding those pouches becomes easier with his next recommendation, which is to limit snacks far more than parents tend to, ensuring hunger at meal times.

All of that begs the question of why parents are compelled to use these toddler formulas — a $92 million industry in 2015, according to a 2020 study — excessive snacks and pouches for on-the-go eating in the first place.

“They market these things for toddlers because toddlers don’t eat the way their parents think they should eat. So, parents are always afraid they aren’t getting ‘enough’ in,” Aracri said. “Toddler milks kind of prey on that idea.”

Advertise with us

The American Academy of Pediatrics, and Aracri, recommend assessing toddler nutrition over the course of a week. For example, during one dinnertime, maybe a child only takes one bite of vegetables and two bites of noodles. In general, that’s OK, they say, because two days later, they might ask for seconds.

Steadying expectations for toddler eating habits seems to be a key step toward helping parents just say no to toddler formula and, in a delightful change of pace compared to most parenting advice, Aracri’s is uncomplicated.

“Chill out,” he said. “Don’t give your child food ‘just to get something into them.’ Parents need to realize it’s OK if your child misses a day of eating.”

Abby Mackey is a registered nurse and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites