A mental health crisis among health care workers in the U.S. has worsened, a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report released Tuesday found.

More than double the number of health care workers reported harassment in 2022 compared to 2018, and about half are considering leaving for a new job, representing an increase, while turnover intention decreased among participants of other fields.

Burnout, staffing shortages and wages all contributed to health care worker walkouts across the nation last month. These concerns have existed for decades, say experts, but the  pandemic pushed workers to the edge.

“The COVID-19 pandemic only intensified many health workers’ long-standing challenges and contributed to new and worsening concerns including compassion, fatigue, depression, anxiety, substance use disorders and suicidal thoughts,” said Debra Houry, the CDC’s chief medical officer, in a Tuesday media briefing on the report. “Burnout among these workers has reached crisis levels.”

Advertise with us

Conducted through phone and in-person interviews as well as online surveys of hundreds of health care workers across the country, the study found that burnout increased to 46% in 2022, compared to 36% in 2018. Of those who experienced harassment on the job, that figure skyrocketed to 81% who said they felt burnt out, as well as 85% of workers who said they felt anxious and had been harassed — which could include bullying from colleagues, altercations with patients or patients’ family members, or negative comments.

The report called for employers to work to maintain their staffs, include workers in decisions and decrease stigma in talking about mental health issues and accessing resources. The CDC also announced that its National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, or NIOSH, is expected to launch a national initiative to support health employers with resources to improve employee mental health.

“Leaders … must take a very strong role in being accountable and responsible for the safety, health and well-being of their workers,” said Casey Chosewood, NIOSH director. “We need to do a better job of increasing training for supervisors and managers, increasing flexibility, modeling and encouraging people to take time off, assuring adequate staffing, building labor management, cooperation efforts, all of these things really go a long way to helping create a better workplace environment.”

Local health care workers have suffered too.

Pittsburgh native and registered nurse Nadia Moore was feeling the heat pre-pandemic and used the opportunity to create an online resource database for nurses, called Nurses Anonymous. A group formed around the site, and met virtually throughout the pandemic to offer support through long hours and burnout.

Advertise with us

On the website, Moore writes that she co-founded the resource because she knew she needed community herself.

“I needed to know that someone could really see me and the pain I was feeling and hold that space for me to process it, instead of suppress it,” she states. “That’s why I started Nurses Anonymous. It’s a community where we can show up for each other the same way we show up for our patients.”

“Hospital systems around the nation are experiencing similar issues, and UPMC is no exception,” said Jennifer Berliner, director of physician well-being at the UPMC Heart and Vascular Institute. She said both individual and systemic changes are on UPMC’s radar.

“We’re approaching well-being from all angles,” said Dr. Berliner. “And we’re trying to be very innovative in how we’re offering resources in order to decrease the activation energy in accessing these resources.”

This includes programs like Physician for Physician, which Dr. Berliner says is a free and 24/7 resource for health care workers to talk to a trained peer if they experience a negative patient outcome or coworker interaction. CuRBside, which stands for Confidential Referrals for Behavioral health, is another call line that provides resources to UPMC health care employees and their families, and a warm handoff to a mental health provider if necessary.

Advertise with us

And her team is working to train physicians for a six-month mentoring program, and she said they are working to expand these programs to more of UPMC’s health care workforce, including nurses. On Oct. 3, UPMC received recognition from the American Medical Association for supporting the well-being of its workers.

She sees the hospital system as equipped to tackle the structural changes recommended in the CDC report.

“I am having lots of conversations with nurses about this, about how we can change the way we used to work,” she said. “I think this is a solvable problem.”

In addition to system-wide changes, lines of communication and transparency need to remain open, said Alicia Kaplan, medical director for the Center for Adult Anxiety & OCD at Allegheny Health Network and a psychiatrist.

“I’m seeing burnout everywhere, but especially with the hospital health care worker,” she said. “We certainly have to pay attention to the health care worker and support them. … If we don’t, we’re not going to get the care we need.

Advertise with us

“The important thing is that we’re able to communicate how we are feeling, what we need, and are able to make group decisions together,” she added. “That’s very rewarding, validating and empowering, and that gives us energy.”

The CDC report found that health care workers employed in supportive environments were less likely to report negative mental health or burnout.

“Not every health care worker we surveyed had the same outcome, some did much better than others,” said Dr. Chosewood in the Tuesday briefing. “Those that had supportive work environments, those that trusted management, those that had support to work productively, those that did have say and agency, they succeeded more. … We believe that there are positive ways forward.”

Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com