In the nearly 10 years that Russell Traister has been practicing as an allergist, he’s tested hundreds of patients for penicillin allergies. Of those, exactly two have tested positive.
The rest have often spent years with an allergy in their charts that prevents them from taking the most optimal medication.
“Labeling with penicillin allergies can have a lot of detrimental effects,” said Traister, a pediatric allergy/immunology specialist at AHN Pediatric Institute. “Everyone walks around with this allergy in their chart, and most of these are probably not real allergies.”
Excessive labeling of penicillin allergies is increasingly being recognized as a real problem nationally. A position statement approved in August by the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology urges “widespread and routine penicillin allergy evaluations, which are integral for successful antibiotic stewardship.”
About 8-10% of Americans have a penicillin allergy on their charts, according to a 2020 study. For hospitalized patients, that number rises to 15%. Estimates vary, but only about 1-10% of those with a penicillin allergy on their charts actually have a true allergy. Those allergies also generally include reactions to amoxicillin, a penicillin antibiotic.
The downside of the allergy is that when patients are prescribed an alternative antibiotic to penicillin, they usually have “poorer outcomes and worse reactions, and they are more costly,” said Christin Deal, an allergist at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh. “There are multiple reasons you don’t want to carry this allergy around with you.”
Read More
While in theory all of those patients could be evaluated by an allergist, that would be nearly impossible in practice. There are 30 million Americans who believe they have penicillin allergies, according to a different 2020 study, and fewer than 5,000 practicing allergists.

UPMC is working on a pilot program with Children’s Community Pediatrics to allow pediatricians to give allergy tests to patients who have penicillin allergies on their charts but appear to be at low risk for having an active allergy. The pediatrician would give them a dose of penicillin in the doctor’s office and observe them there for allergy symptoms.
“It’s new for us and definitely new for Pittsburgh,” said Deal, who is working on developing the program. “They are recognizing, just like the rest of the U.S., that the labeling is getting quite aggressive. There are a lot of patients labeled with this that don’t need to be labeled and they feel like they may be able to help.”
At UPMC Children’s Hospital, allergists have been looking at inpatients with penicillin allergies to see if they can clear them of the allergy label. Since 2020, said Deal, they found that of 60,248 patients, nearly 6% of them had been labeled with a penicillin allergy. Through the inpatient initiative, they were able to remove the allergy label from 16-19% of those patients.
Patients have a low risk of having a true penicillin allergy if they had a reaction more than 10 years ago, said Deal, noting that even for patients with a true allergy, 90% of people outgrow it after a decade. Patients are also at a low risk if they had a rash that wasn’t hives, or if their reaction occurred more than a day after the first dose.
Those with a true allergy often have a reaction — such as hives — that begins within an hour of taking the medication. Frequently, the reaction doesn’t occur the first time the medication is taken, she said.
Some patients do have uncomfortable side effects to penicillin, such as vomiting or diarrhea, which are not a true allergy but might be a reason to avoid the medication if possible.
Penicillin allergies are often marked into the medical record in early childhood: Most enter a patient’s chart before they turn 3. This often occurs because an infant or toddler is given antibiotics for a common illness, such as an ear infection or strep throat, and develops hives or another rash. Oftentimes, the hives are a symptom of the illness itself, and not a reaction to an antibiotic. But because of the possibility of an adverse reaction, it is frequently entered onto the patient’s chart, and often stays there for years, if not decades.
“They are 70 years old,” said Traister, “and they need to figure out this amoxicillin allergy.”
Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.