In May of 2020, Becky Keenan entered West Penn Hospital at 35 weeks pregnant, experiencing what she thought was preterm labor. But in triage, she and her husband were told that the baby boy they’d already named Caleb had no heartbeat. Keenan simultaneously gave birth and mourned Caleb, “one of the three most perfect things I have created in my lifetime.” And as she grieved, she couldn’t help but be aware of the joy around her of other families, celebrating perfect beings of their own.

Keenan, a psychologist, knew the research on stages of grief, such as denial, anger and depression, and knew that eventually she was supposed to feel acceptance and find meaning.

But at first, those later stages were hard to fathom.

“I couldn’t imagine finding meaning in the death of my perfect child,” she said. “It actually made me really angry. It felt ludicrous to think of that.”

Advertise with us

But Tuesday, at West Penn Hospital, two and a half years after the stillbirth of her 5-pound, 8-ounce baby, she did.

In a project initiated by the Keenan family and supported by the AHN West Penn Hospital Foundation, the hospital opened a “butterfly suite” in honor of Caleb – a private, soundproof set of rooms tucked into a corner of the hospital where families experiencing a perinatal death can birth and mourn their baby in private.

“We really wanted from its inception to make the worst day of someone else’s life a little bit less awful,” said Keenan, of Shaler. “The creation of this physical space is a big part of how we’re hoping to do that.”

The Keenan family – Becky, her husband Jeff, their 6-year-old son Carter and 7-month-old daughter Kennedy – toured the suite as it officially opened Tuesday. Rather than the baby-focused environment of a typical labor and delivery room, the butterfly suite is neutral, decorated with a piece of abstract art representing a butterfly, a symbol of perinatal loss. In addition to the labor and delivery room is a comfortable family waiting room, so that families don’t have to make awkward and painful conversation with joyous families waiting for babies to be born.

In recent years, butterfly suites have opened from Ohio to Australia to support grieving families. According to the Allegheny Health Network, the one at West Penn is the first in the Pittsburgh region.

Advertise with us
Carter looks at abstract art of a butterfly, which is a symbol of perinatal loss. (Anya Sostek / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Stillbirth is defined by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention as the death of a baby before or during delivery after the 20th week of pregnancy. About 1 in every 175 babies in the United States is stillborn, according to the CDC, about 21,000 babies per year.

“I think it’s time for a paradigm shift in how we care for bereaved families,” said Marta Kolthoff, an obstetrician and director of Olivia’s Angels perinatal palliative care program at AHN, who worked with the Keenans to create the butterfly suite. “This should be the standard of care. All families deserve this.” About 70 patients per year experience a perinatal death at West Penn Hospital, she said.

Kolthoff has also worked with staff at West Penn on how to interact with families experiencing perinatal death. The Keenans remember hearing congratulations from well-meaning staff members on the labor and delivery unit, for example. They have told their story on multiple occasions in training sessions for doctors and medical residents.

Kolthoff has also held training sessions for staff at all levels, telling them, for example, not to tell grieving families that they can have more children, but instead to say sorry for their loss and to ask the baby’s name. “Often staff say to me, ‘I’m so happy to have this training because I never knew what to say. I never knew what was going to be upsetting to them,’” she said.

In addition to the privacy and sensitivity afforded by the birthing suite, Jeff Keenan hopes that its very existence will be a comfort to families in their position.

Advertise with us

“This space shows people that you’re not alone in what happened to you,” he said. “It has happened to someone else and the hospital and the staff are here to support you.”

On Tuesday, a hospital worker affixed a plaque to the door outside the labor and delivery room of the birthing suite noting that it was “in honor of Caleb.”

And the whole Keenan family took pictures there, as Becky Keenan pointed out the butterfly art to Carter and Kennedy wiggled and then fell asleep in her father’s arms.

“I think it’s really a concrete experience and memento for them for a brother who will always be abstract for them,” said Becky Keenan. “It’s also a great example to let them know that when bad things happen to you, you have choices about how you handle it.”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com.