Shooting victims have a relatively high survival rate when Pittsburgh paramedics reach them in time, and officials hope they can continue to bolster that survival rate by beginning the blood transfusion process at the scene or on the ambulance rather than waiting until a victim is on the operating table.

The city’s EMS officials are in the early stages of working to get a pilot program going that would allow ambulances to carry whole blood. Right now, the bureau relies on its rescue medicine partners at UPMC Mercy and UPMC Presbyterian to provide the blood to a physician who then brings it to a scene.

That works well in cases where someone is trapped in a vehicle that requires complicated extrication, said Assistant Chief of EMS Mark Pinchalk, but it does little to help at the scenes of other types of trauma, like shootings, stabbings and crashes without entrapment.

“Our goal is really to have the capability next year … to have a more robust blood program where we can push blood to more scenes and maybe get it to some of these shooting scenes,” he said. “That’s the next thing to try to bump survival.”

Advertise with us

Regulatory issues at the state and federal level mean that, right now, EMS providers rely mostly on saline to try to raise a trauma victim’s blood pressure or pulse. Chief Pinchalk said most EMS departments try to align their practices with the military, which has determined that whole blood is one of the best measures to increase trauma survival.

“If you look in their guidelines, they list like 15 possibilities for fluid and 15 out of 15 on the list, the very bottom thing, is normal saline, which is what we administer just because that’s the only thing regulatory-wise ground paramedics in Pennsylvania can give,” he said.

The red tape isn’t impenetrable, he said, but it can be a pain. Among other boxes EMS will have to check is getting the ambulances and stations licensed as blood banks.

Chief Pinchalk said the saline is a stop-gap measure, and EMS personnel do use it judiciously. It can only do so much, though, and, among other things, it can cause hypothermia and it doesn’t have clotting capabilities.

Pittsburgh’s EMS crews already have a solid record in getting some of the most traumatically injured victims to the hospital alive. In the first nine months of 2022, 95.5% of victims with penetrating gunshot wounds survived the transport to the hospital. When excluding individuals with penetrating brain injuries, that number goes up to 97%.

Advertise with us

“While we don’t want to see violence, we’re very successful in responding to it,” Chief Pinchalk said.

The blood program that they have in place now — where blood is brought to scenes that require extensive rescue or extrication — has already paid off. In one incident this year, an individual who required extrication had a broken pelvis and internal bleeding.

“That person likely would have died during the extrication process,” he said.

Another person was trapped after a car crash and in traumatic arrest. They were given blood and survived to be discharged from the hospital.

In San Antonio — one of the first cities in the country to carry whole blood on ambulances — the program has seen quantifiable successes since its implementation in 2018.

Advertise with us

Prior to the city’s whole blood transfusion program, Tiffany Kieschnick-Rivas likely would not have survived her 2019 car crash. She was driving to a gas station to run an errand when she had a stroke and flipped her car into a ditch.

Her spleen ruptured, and she was in cardiac arrest. Paramedics who arrived at the scene believed she would ultimately be a fatality, according to interviews Ms. Kieschnick-Rivas has done.

She was in traumatic cardiac arrest when first responders arrived. The National Institutes of Health estimates that only about 2% of people who go into traumatic cardiac arrest survive to be discharged from the hospital.

The whole blood given to Ms. Kieschnick-Rivas not only saved her life, but she began to come back into consciousness at the scene.

She’s since become an advocate for the program and for blood donations, as getting the blood poses problems of its own.

Advertise with us

Getting the blood

San Antonio’s EMS and fire department brokered what San Antonio medic officer Lt. William Bullock called a bit of a sweetheart deal with a local blood bank and trauma center.

The emergency services in the city buy the blood from the South Texas Blood and Tissue Center. It stays with the ambulances for 15 days. Whatever is left after that, one of the local trauma centers essentially buys back the blood at full cost.

That means the city’s emergency services have a 0% waste ratio, Lt. Bullock said.

It also has to be the right kind of blood. For one, it has to be whole blood rather than parts of the blood broken down into separate components: red cells, white cells, plasma and platelets.

Advertise with us

O-negative is the universal blood type — any person of any blood type can safely receive O-negative blood. Only about 13% of the population is O-negative, though, so it is already in short supply. Many hospitals or blood and tissue banks are reluctant to give it up.

In San Antonio, officials solved the problem by going with O-positive blood that is, essentially, on the lower end of the positive range. The O blood types exists on a range: One can be O-positive and very positive or O-positive and on the lower end of the positivity scale.

People who are in the latter category are called low titers. O-positive blood from low titers is generally safe to use in place of the true universal blood type, O-negative.

“It took coordinating a lot of individuals who accepted the fact that it’s all for the greater good,” Lt. Bullock said.

There are even more logistics to sort out: Where will the blood be kept and how long will it be kept. In San Antonio’s case, the blood is kept in a freezer on specific ambulances for 24 hours. Then the coolers are switched out, and it stays in the new cooler for another 24 hours. The blood itself stays with one truck, and there are safeguards to let medics know if the blood is getting too cold or too warm.

Advertise with us

Those are pieces of the puzzle that Pittsburgh EMS officials are sorting through as they work to get the pilot program off the ground.

Chief Pinchalk said with pilot program approval, his EMTs and paramedics could pick up the blood directly from the hospital and eliminate the need for a middleman blood bank.

The red tape is worth the reward, said Dr. Allan Philp, chief medical officer and chief trauma surgeon at Allegheny General Hospital.

“It’s laborious — somebody has to look at it and if it’s close to expiring you need to get it back to the blood bank,” he said. “There is some process and a bit of work involved, but I think if you look at the outcome improvements, that’s a small price to pay.”

Dr. Philp, who served in the military in Iraq and Afghanistan, said there are really two principles to keep in mind: Sooner is better, and replace what the person is losing.

Advertise with us

“The sooner you start to replace the bleeding, the better they do,” he said, noting that whole blood is the ideal compared to saline and other fluids.

“This sounds kind of silly, but they’re not bleeding fluid, they’re bleeding blood,” he said. “Replacing what they’re losing makes sense even though it took us many years to get our hands around that as a medical community.

“They’re bleeding blood, give them blood,” he said.

Indeed, said Chief Pinchalk, the earlier blood can get into a person in hemorrhagic shock, the better their chances for survival. Whole blood is the gold standard, he said, “because you’re replacing what they’re losing.”

“Anything else, you’re replacing volume, but you’re not replacing oxygen carrying capability, you’re not replacing coagulation factors and stuff like that,” he said. “So that’s your biggest bang for the buck to enhance survival.”

Advertise with us

Whole blood could have likely saved some hemorrhagic shock victims who did not survive their transport to the hospital, he said.

Some are beyond help, he said, like those suffering from penetrating brain or heart injuries.

“Some have pretty catastrophic injuries, but I do believe that there are going to be patients that it would have definitely helped with survival,” he said.

Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com