Mindy Hoffman attended her father’s burial on a spring day in 2011 in Westchester County, N.Y. Leaves were just beginning to unfurl on the bare branches of trees, the bite of winter finally letting up. As Mindy’s mother, Helen, watched her husband’s casket descend into the ground, she tapped Mindy on the arm and said, “Look, someone died.”

Helen had been given a diagnosis of dementia in 2007. Mindy first noticed a slight change in her mother’s handwriting. Then she started losing her way to the register in stores. She continued to decline for 10 years, as Mindy and her brother adjusted to their new reality. Helen had a happiness in her eyes throughout her life, said Mindy. “After two to three years, it turned into a blank stare.”

Someone in the world develops dementia every three seconds, according to the organization Alzheimer’s Disease International. In 2020, 55 million people were living with dementia and cases are increasing. Alzheimer’s is a specific neurological condition that leads to dementia symptoms, affecting more than six million people in the U.S.

Dementia does not affect only those who have it — it is estimated that more than 11 million people provide unpaid care for people with Alzheimer’s, valued at nearly $272 billion. In Pennsylvania, the Alzheimer’s Association estimated there were 401,000 caregivers for people with dementia in 2021, putting in unpaid labor valued at $10 billion.

Advertise with us

Watching a loved one forget your face and retreat into themselves can be excruciating. But media, such as television shows, can help us relate to characters going through similar experiences. The popular television show “This is Us,” set partly in Pittsburgh, follows a family for decades as the mother, Rebecca Pearson, played by Mandy Moore, develops Alzheimer’s disease. Her grown children, Kevin, Randall and Kate, deliberate throughout the show about how to provide the best care for Rebecca, like whether to enroll her in a clinical trial for a novel Alzheimer’s treatment.

Dementia affected both grandmothers of Jennifer McCartney, a student at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health. While watching the show "This Is Us," she said, "I remember thinking, ‘am I going to go through this same thing?’” (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Dr. Jessica Burke, a professor in the department of Behavioral and Community Health Sciences and vice dean at University of Pittsburgh, and Dr. Beth Hoffman, a postdoctoral associate at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health, and others in the public health department wanted to see how viewers related to the show. They sent a survey to 720 people and conducted four focus groups with 12 participants, all of whom had direct experience with Alzheimer’s.

Their findings, published Aug. 31 in the Journal of Health Communication, showed that “This is Us” reduced stigma and increased discussion of Alzheimer’s among families.

Mindy, Beth Hoffman’s aunt, said she usually stays dry-eyed when watching TV, but not while watching “This is Us.” “I thought they covered it so beautifully,” she said. “But it was so close to my reality, that I just felt like I was reliving it.”

Other research has explored the impact of TV shows on public health. In a 2013 essay published in Conservation Magazine, now called Anthropocene, the science writer Fred Pearce highlighted a study in which Indian households that owned a TV had lower birth rates and more empowerment among women. The researchers attributed this to new soap operas, which showcased female independence and safer sex practices like birth control. In the essay, Pearce writes, “They saw their urban sisters working outside the home, running businesses, controlling money, and — crucially — achieving these things by having fewer children. Here was TV showing women a world of possibilities beyond bearing and raising children—a world in which small families are the key to a better life.”

Advertise with us

Indeed, “Entertainment can help us process complicated topics . . . it walks you through an experience” said Burke. As many as 12 million people watched “This is Us” season 6 (the season that deals the most with Rebecca’s cognitive decline) when it aired. Beth Hoffman said “This is Us” was a great example of media being a powerful tool for communicating accurate health information. During the focus groups, participants told researchers that they thought Rebecca’s progression from early-stage dementia into Alzheimer’s was realistic.

Burke and Hoffman also wondered whether viewers would relate to specific characters. In the show, Rebecca’s children process her condition differently and don’t always see eye-to-eye on solutions. One son, Randall, wanted to move Rebecca across the country to enroll her in the clinical trial, whereas Kevin adopted the attitude that Rebecca would be fine.

Researchers were expecting viewers to identify with either Kevin or Randall, but their results showed that most people identified with both characters. In the focus group, participants said that at some points, they were Randall, wanting to do everything they could to help their loved one. Many called Kevin’s optimism unrealistic, though they understood it.

Jennifer McCartney, a graduate student at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health who is a friend of Beth Hoffman’s, identified with Randall. “If there’s a problem, I want it solved,” she said.

She watched her maternal grandmother, Hazel, decline from dementia for 20 years until her death in 2016. By the time McCartney left her home in Erie, Pa., to attend college at Chatham in 2007, Hazel had no idea who she was.

Advertise with us

McCartney, who also lost her other grandmother to dementia when she was a baby, helped write the focus group guide for the study and is listed as a collaborator in the paper. She has an older brother and sister who live in different parts of the country, and said she couldn’t imagine having to coordinate who would move home to care for their parent, as Kate did in the show.

Both of Jennifer McCartney's grandmothers, Ginny McCartney (left), and Hazel MacKinlay, were affected by dementia. (Courtesy of Jennifer McCartney)

The last time McCartney saw her grandmother alive, she was flipping through a deer-themed calendar, her eyes widening in surprise at discovering each month’s picture. She turned the pages and exclaimed each time, “Look, a deer!”

After watching “This is Us,” McCartney started thinking more about her parents’ risk of developing Alzheimer’s, and her own. “I told my parents, ‘you have to have your decisions made,’” she said. She worries about a genetic component. “While watching the show, I remember thinking, ‘am I going to go through this same thing?’”

Both she and Mindy Hoffman said the slow and specific descent into Alzheimer’s means that proper mourning gets turned on its head. “The worst part about it is that they die while they’re still living,” McCartney said.

“The diagnosis is like a funeral, but then it keeps going on and on,” Mindy Hoffman said.

Advertise with us

With the accuracy and transparency of shows like “This is Us,” along with new research into treatments for Alzheimer’s, she said she hopes that one day, other people won’t have to live through what she did.

“When she passed, I had already grieved,” she said. “My mother had been gone for years.”

Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com 

Correction: An earlier version of this article misstated the title of one of the researchers. Beth Hoffman is a postdoctoral associate at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health. Photo captions accompanying the article misspelled the name of Hazel MacKinlay.