Even though health care professionals could effectively encourage COVID-19 vaccination over social media, a new study by researchers from the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health finds that most health care providers are failing to do so.
According to the researchers, their findings suggest that health care providers could better leverage the public’s trust in them to turn the tide on vaccine hesitancy.
Published June 8 in the Journal of Community Health, the study found that less than a third of the 476 already vaccinated health care workers at UPMC Western Psychiatric Hospital surveyed between April and June 2021 said they posted about receiving the COVID-19 vaccine on social media.
Nine-year-old Madeline lists 4 very good reasons explaining why she got vaccinated to protect herself and others from Covid ♥️ @NursesWhoVax @Voices4Vaccines @DrJenChen4kids @drfixus @greenhousemd @DrEricBall @GretchenLasalle @NICUBatman @DocEMurray @AAPPres pic.twitter.com/Wy50jr1CEk
— EMK (@eveamk) January 21, 2022
For the purposes of the study, “health care worker” was defined as anyone working in the hospital to provide for patients, including nurses, cafeteria staff, therapists, security personnel and physicians.
In the second part of the study, which analyzed 1,863 randomly sampled tweets deemed relevant to COVID-19 and made by individuals, only 14 percent of the 106 tweets thought to be authored by health care workers mentioned personal reasons related to vaccination, such as relieving one’s anxiety from becoming infected with the virus.
“I’m not surprised about that because health care workers are not necessarily urged to do that. If they are doing that, it’s because they decided to do it,” explained Sherry Pagoto, a clinical psychologist and director of the UConn Center for mHealth & Social Media, who was not involved in the study.
“What struck me about this was that about 50 percent of the people who did post, posted something that was neutral,” she added. The study specified these neutral tweets were usually retweets of news headlines or announcements from other individuals or organizations.
Even among the 106 tweets by health care workers, 34 percent were found to be neutral.
These neutral tweets and depersonalized narratives from health care providers, if made at all, have created a vacuum for anti-vaccination organizers to spread falsehoods about the COVID-19 vaccines, reinforcing vaccine hesitancy. The study urged health care providers to counter this misinformation over social media, as many have already done.
The power of social media
Although the anti-vaccine movement is small, it is loud. According to a 2021 study by the Washington-based nonprofit Center for Countering Digital Hate, “Just 12 anti-vaxxers are responsible for almost two-thirds of anti‑vaccine content circulating on social media platforms.”
According to Dr. Todd Wolynn, who runs Kids Plus Pediatrics in Pittsburgh and whose social media presence has drawn attention from the likes of People magazine, people might be pushing disinformation to downtalk evidenced medicine and sell essential oils or crystals. Individuals might also be looking for power through popularity on social media. “We’ve seen the open embrace of weaponized anti-science disinformation on the hard right” since 2016, Dr. Wolynn said.
Before social media, anti-vaccination organizations used to fight vaccine mandates against smallpox for the sake of personal liberty, such as the Anti-Vaccination Society of America and other regional leagues formed in the 1870s, the study’s lead author, Beth Hoffman, a postdoctoral associate in the Department of Behavioral and Community Health Sciences at Pitt Public Health wrote in the journal Vaccine.
However, their power was limited. The Supreme Court eventually affirmed the right of states to legislate vaccine mandates, and all 50 passed laws requiring students to be immunized with specific vaccines to attend school.
Ms. Hoffman said she thought social media might be the reason anti-vaccination organizing has been so successful in the present. She explained, “Back in the late 1890s with the opposition that eventually led to the Supreme Court case, it was a lot harder for anti-vaccine activists to organize, particularly across different regions. So while there were pockets here and there, the minority couldn't be as vocal as they are now.”
Ms. Pagoto agreed. “Social media can make social norms more salient,” she said. “Every post counts because it’s one more data point for people to perceive,” affecting their behavior, such as deciding to get vaccinated.
Ms. Hoffman said that about 25 percent of parents are vaccine-hesitant and still persuadable. There is even some skepticism about vaccines in the medical community. Her study cited previous research finding that roughly 10 percent of primary care physicians lack confidence in the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, and 32 percent lack confidence in the Johnson & Johnson vaccine.
The Pitt study helps explain why this may be. Ms. Hoffman said, “Clinicians or scientists, if those people aren’t on social media, anti-vaccine people will fill that void.”
Citing prior research, the study recommended that health care providers use personal narratives, especially the freedom from fear of becoming infected with the virus, combined with accurate science to encourage vaccination over social media.
TikTok messaging
Rather than wait for institutions to catch up with the modern ways of disseminating public health information, some medical professionals have taken matters into their own hands.
Dr. Wolynn said, “It is negligent for primary care practices not to have some form of social media presence to connect with patients.” As such, he recommended that every practice invest in at least a part-time communications director.
Health care providers may also fear trolling and backlash if they post to social media about vaccination. Dr. Wolynn founded Shots Heard Round the World, a nonprofit now owned by The Public Good Projects, to defend providers and their webpages against orchestrated online attacks by the anti-vaccination movement.
Although still a full-time pediatrician, Dr. Wolynn now puts 90 percent of his social media efforts into TikTok videos to educate his 57,000 followers about the benefits of COVID-19 vaccines and other health interventions while entertaining them at the same time, he hopes.
“My whole job is behavior change,” he said, “and yet we’re not using the world’s most powerful behavior change tool.”
Ethan Dodd: Edodd@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.