When Americans recall March 13, 2020, the day former President Donald Trump declared a state of emergency due to the spread of COVID-19, one of the first changes that come to mind is the closing of schools.

That move had a major impact in schools of nursing, where gaps in education could be the difference between life or death.

Shifting toward online learning for lecture-based courses was one thing. Recreating hands-on lab courses was another. But most daunting was how to reconfigure clinical courses — the ones often carried out in hospitals and skilled nursing facilities — when they were not open to students at all or only in a limited capacity.

“We clearly were aware, particularly those of us in health professions, that the pandemic was coming. It’s one of those times, like many other historic moments, that you never forget,” said Lynn George, Ph.D., dean of Carlow University School of Nursing. “We’d been working behind the scenes to get prepared for what we saw as a shift that would be profound. We didn’t really know how profound it was going to be until almost two years later.”

Advertise with us
Carlow University School of Nursing dean, Lynn George. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

At a time when hospitals are facing a dire shortage of nurses, with a new survey from the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania finding more than a quarter of registered nurse positions in the state were vacant as of November and December, nursing training is especially crucial.

School’s Out

During the first week of March 2020, Community College of Allegheny County’s dean of nursing, Kathy Mayle, attended the annual Black Summit of the National Brotherhood of Skiers at Ketchum and Sun Valley, Idaho. If that rings a bell, it’s because that congregation of nearly 700 skiers resulted in at least 126 cases of COVID-19 symptoms and 20 testing positive, a significant outbreak in the early phase of the pandemic.

Community College of Allegheny County’s dean of nursing, Kathy Mayle, was uniquely prepared to guide students after her own bout with COVID-19. (Courtesy of CCAC)

Though she’s never spoken about it publicly, Ms. Mayle said she and her husband were the first two cases of confirmed COVID-19 in Allegheny County.

She said she was “sick as a dog” and so fatigued she couldn’t walk up the steps for 30 hours before watching her husband suffer similarly. She said she called her doctor knowing “this wasn’t a typical flu.” They were approached in full HAZMAT suits when tested, were ordered to West Penn Hospital and escorted through a private entrance, interviewed for an hour each over the phone and were the anonymous subjects of an Allegheny County Health Department news conference to announce COVID-19 had reached the county. They were both released from the hospital after a few bags of IV fluids and plenty of blood tests with the caveat they would remained quarantined at home for the prescribed time period.

Advertise with us

The experience helped Ms. Mayle and associate dean of nursing Jayne Anne Karcesky shape CCAC’s plan for how to proceed with nursing education in the pandemic, which each school had to submit to the state board of nursing.

Classes and labs going virtual required instructors to rework their courses and, in some cases, to learn new software in little time. Plenty of that relied on the schools’ IT staff, but there was no such support when it came to again planning clinical experiences. The National Council of State Boards of Nursing, which oversees the profession’s licensure exam, supported research saying up to 50% of nursing students’ clinical training “could be done virtually and still be effective,” Ms. Mayle said, a quantity the students at the time — regardless of the institution — had largely already reached by mid-March 2020.

Different kind of testing

Another early-pandemic set-back in the process of nursing students reaching the hospital floor was a shutdown of testing sites for the National Council Licensure Examination, known as the NCLEX, the exam taken after graduation that turns graduate nurses (GNs) into registered nurses (RNs).

Sites reopened incrementally and in accordance with local restrictions, and when they did, test-takers were greeted with a different exam, which was designed to be equally rigorous.

Advertise with us

“The time limit of the exam was shortened to four hours in order to lessen exposure of each candidate and maximize the number of candidates testing per day,” wrote Jason A. Schwartz, director of outreach, marketing and advocacy for the national council, in an email to the Post-Gazette. “The difficulty levels and passing standards of the exams were not changed.”

Those changes were based on research conducted by the organization ahead of the pandemic, providing confidence the shorter version was still able to determine the measurement of a candidate’s ability.

By Oct. 1, 2020, the exam reverted to its previous five-hour length. And in April 2023 nurses will see another new version of the exam based on a decade of research, the Next Generation NCLEX.

“This research found that clinical judgement underpins almost everything nurses do, even at the entry-level,” Mr. Schwartz wrote.

While most of the exam will stay the same, new items will include case studies and questions aimed at clinical judgment, which aligns well with how local nursing schools made up for lost in-person experience in 2020.

Advertise with us

Kicking it new school

Of the nursing schools surveyed for this story — at Carlow University, CCAC, University of Pittsburgh and UPMC — all reported about a two-week hiatus during which the programs pivoted toward virtual learning, a process that dictated teamwork as never before.

“There was no complaining or blaming,” said Ms. Mayle. “We knew our backs were against the wall. We knew we owed it to our students to give them the education they deserved given the circumstances we were in.”

They leaned on a number of nursing-specific virtual programs that present complicated patient scenarios and ask students to unravel the clinical picture. These were done under the virtual guidance of clinical instructors and involved group discussion. For some schools, these resources were already in their tool kit, but for others it was an added expense.

Though that might sound like a poor substitute for real-life experience, nursing deans say it wasn’t. Rather than students waiting for clinical instructors before completing tasks or hoping for the chance to be involved in a procedure they had never seen, all the students were exposed to educationally germane content.

Advertise with us

“It really challenged them,” Ms. Mayle said. “Students got more out it than they would on a floor. Learning virtually, you were being challenged at every opportunity.”

A few in-person clinical opportunities resumed by late spring, with the programs returning in earnest that fall. But there were new rules: only four students per group (compared to seven or eight previously) and they could not be assigned to COVID patients.

To help brush up on skills that virtual learning didn’t require, CCAC began offering “bootcamps,” which were encouraged but not required. The sessions helped students practice the hands-on components of nursing, like injections and setting up IV tubing.

Students again made use of the schools’ “high fidelity simulation” labs. These are high-tech robots that speak, bleed and even give birth, which are now a common, and respected, part of nursing education.

At Carlow, some potentially once-in-a-lifetime clinical opportunities were offered.

Advertise with us

The university formed a partnership with Integrated Health 21, a health management company which performed screenings for anyone entering the campus, and as they became available, administered on-site COVID-19 tests and vaccines.

And Carlow nursing students assisted in Allegheny County Health Department mass vaccine clinics.

“They were alternative experiences that met the needs of our Carlow community, but it was a very rich learning experience for our students to participate in,” Ms. George said.

Special breed

Nurses are caregivers and educators, but first, they’re people.

Advertise with us

To care for staff across the campus, Carlow University offered yoga, meditation and mindfulness sessions virtually. To care for students, CCAC held virtual forums so nursing students could discuss any concerns about their education or anxieties about returning to clinical sites.

While the work is obviously stressful, people who are drawn to nursing, like police officers and firefighters, belong to a certain breed: One that runs toward crisis.

“We found students eager to move into the clinical setting, both to enhance their skills as well as to contribute to the care of others,” said Jackie Dunbar Jacob, Pitt’s dean of nursing. “They learned how to use protective equipment to keep them safe. We didn’t find any anxiety holding them back.”

That was true for Pitt junior nursing student, Elisabeth Tarazi, 21, who experienced clinical courses for the first time during the pandemic: “If I was a nurse at this time, that’s something I would have to face and actually interact with COVID patients, so it’s part of the job.”

Carlow University School of Nursing dean, Lynn George, DNP and senior nursing student, Zachary Cynkar, Wednesday, Mar. 2, 2022, in Pittsburgh. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Like many nursing students, senior Carlow student, Zachary Cynkar, 22, works as a patient care technician at a local hospital. When the first few cases of COVID showed up at his workplace, managers asked for volunteers to care for them. Mr. Cynkar, the son of a nurse and respiratory therapist, raised his hand.

Advertise with us

“I was really scared, but thinking about how my parents have been such an inspiration and how they would go into all of this, that’s what made me say, ‘OK, I’ll go into the COVID room. I’ll don the N-95 and the gown and the gloves to help these people.”

Did it work?

As the chief nursing executive at UPMC, Holly Lorenz oversees 20,000 UPMC nurses as well as the system’s five diploma nursing programs, which are hospital-based nursing schools completed in just four semesters, compared to two-year associates programs (like CCAC’s) or four-year bachelor’s degree programs (offered at Carlow and Pitt.)

“We’re experiencing a nursing shortage that I never thought I would see in my career,” she said, making the quantity and quality of recent and future nursing students of the highest priority to those in her position. Indicators of success include NCLEX pass rates, enrollment in nursing schools and employment.

Rates of graduate nurses taking the NCLEX for the first time dropped nationally from 88.18% in 2019 to 82.48% in 2021. But according to Ms. Lorenz, it’s understandable: “I think that was truly because the learning environment was very, very different.”

Advertise with us

Enrollment is up across all the schools surveyed. Proof of that, in UPMC’s case, is in the fifth diploma school they opened August 2021 and a sixth that will open in August 2022.

“What we’re seeing is that students are interested in becoming nurses because of what they witnesses and how heroic nurses were,” Ms. George said. “That was something I didn’t expect, but it’s certainly interesting because we’re in the middle of a nursing shortage.”

A recent report showed Pennsylvania is expected to have a shortfall of more than 20,000 nurses by 2026.

Because of that shortage, gaining employment for new nurses isn’t difficult, but setting them up for success is different, at least for now.

“We do see at the transition into professional practice, we’ve had to add a little more simulation into their on-boarding,” Ms. Lorenz said.

Advertise with us

In addition, UPMC nurses now participate in “huddles” at the beginning of every shift. Led by the unit managers, these are brief meetings to celebrate professional and patient wins and discuss key information for the shift.

Click to enlarge

New nurses hired into the Allegheny Health Network receive training specific to their needs after completing a survey to measure their level of confidence and competence in fundamental skills. “Using the responses from these surveys, we tailored their individualized orientation plan to ensure that they had additional practice in performing these tasks while on orientation as well as in using simulation equipment and in situ labs,” said Paula Coe, vice president of nursing education and professional practice at AHN.

Mother of invention

The group of nurses and nurse educators impacted by the pandemic are different, and there’s plenty of good about that.

In previous years, freshman nursing students at Pitt often complained about having to design a hand-washing protocol based on evidence — an indicator such basic, but lifesaving, skills didn’t grab students’ attention.

Advertise with us

“Prior to the pandemic, many students thought this was a wasted time exercise,” Ms. Dunbar Jacob said. “Now, the importance of proper hand-washing and other hygiene measures are taken much more seriously.”

CCAC and Carlow have found circumstances where virtual instruction actually had advantages over in-person learning, giving students room in their schedules that didn’t exist previously. And the use of virtual case studies as a guaranteed way to drive home clinical concepts is also here to stay.

But the hallmark of this experience for all involved was flexibility and creativity, due to a forced evolution in nursing education.

“It’s opened up our creativity,” Ms. Mayle said. “It’s opened up our people’s minds that, no, this is not the only way to educate a nurse. There are more ways to do it and do it well. There’s no stopping us. We’re not going back.”

Abby Mackey: amackey@post-gazette.com, Twitter @AnthroAbbyRN and IG @abbymackeywrites.