“Where are you applying?”

A family friend or relative looking to make conversation with a high school senior might think that’s an innocent question, but for some teenagers any mention of college is an emotional trigger right now.

The college application process is famously challenging, but combined with the altered high school experience in the pandemic and its impact on many teenagers’ mental health, this is an especially stressful season.

“My heart goes out to these current high school kids,” said Arun Ponnusamy, chief academic officer at CollegeWise, a national college counseling and test prep company. “There are waves of anxieties.”

Advertise with us

Jennifer DiVito, a 20-year-old University of Pittsburgh student from Moon, thinks of her own applications a few years ago as an endless demand for information and essays — and endless confusion about the process.

“There’s so much I wish I knew during college applications,” said Ms. DiVito, recalling trying to balance her academic workload, activities such as swimming, and figuring out how to apply to college.

Mr. Ponnusamy recommends starting as early as possible. That doesn’t mean that parents of seventh graders should be obsessing quite yet, but it does mean that even young high school students can start getting in the college mindset.

“It’s entirely appropriate for freshmen and sophomores in high school to go do some campus tours or do some of the virtual tours,” he said. “One of the things with younger students that I’ve really been encouraging is thinking about why they want to go to college and what role is it going to play in what you want to accomplish.”

When kids feel like they are driving the process, there’s a better chance that they will be motivated on their own to complete their college applications, he said.

Advertise with us

And if it’s a week until applications are due and not much is done, parents should know their families are not alone.

“Most kids procrastinate and wait until the deadline and make their parents anxious, but that’s not necessarily strange or a problem,” said Gary Swanson, a child and adolescent psychiatrist with Allegheny Health Network and father of nine children. His ninth and youngest child started college last fall.

“There’s no doubt that people are stressed out by the college application process,” he said. “Even the kids who aren’t going to college are stressed out by it because if you aren’t going to college, what are you going to do?”

Earlier this month, an advisory from the Surgeon General called the pandemic’s impact on teenagers’ mental health “devastating.” Even before the pandemic, it noted, “an alarming number of young people struggled with feelings of helplessness, depression and thoughts of suicide — and rates have increased over the past decade.”

Dr. Swanson has seen more teenagers struggling with depression after the tumultuous years of the COVID-19 pandemic and increasing numbers of teens who know someone who has died from the disease. For students dealing with mental health issues that include depression or feelings of being overwhelmed by the college application process, he recommended breaking it into small, more manageable chunks.

Advertise with us

“Avoiding it doesn’t make it any better,” he said. “Playing a video game and going to bed won’t solve the problem. They can break it into smaller tasks — get the common application done or do the five schools you most want to go to and block out a time to do it.”

Another source of college application stress is money. Karlissia Council, now 26, remembers that her mother had the idea for her to apply for a different scholarship every single day of her senior year. Ms. Council did it — in addition to extracurricular activities such as basketball, stage crew, the church daycare and schoolwork, to try to lessen the cost of college. Ms. Council, who graduated from Pittsburgh Obama, was motivated to be able to attend California University of Pennsylvania.

“My whole family went there, so I was trying to plan on going there since middle school,” she said. “Every day in high school, my last year, I would apply for a scholarship before I went to bed.” She wound up with a partial tuition scholarship through the Board of Governors, assistance from the Pittsburgh Promise and a $5,000 bowling scholarship, all of which helped offset Cal U's undergraduate tuition bill of nearly $4,000 per semester for in-state students.

Kevin Jarbo, a 37-year-old assistant professor in social and decision sciences at Carnegie Mellon University and a graduate of the University of Pittsburgh, remembers his stress not just about affording college but even affording the applications. "I had scraped together my birthday money and used that for applications, which only allowed me to apply to so many places,” he said.

It’s important for parents to have honest talks with their children about money, said Mr. Ponnusamy. “That’s a thing parents need to be able to say — We’re not going to be able to afford that college,” he said. “Some parents shy away from the tough conversations early, and it tends to be far more devastating later on than setting those boundaries early.”

Advertise with us

It can be a fine line for parents to offer their help, while trying not to nag or take over the process, he said. COVID-19 has also changed some aspects of the college application process, with some high schools changing classes to pass/fail during periods of online learning and disrupting the standardized testing schedule. Whereas SAT or ACT scores used to help students predict where they might be accepted, many colleges and universities have test-optional policies.

As a result, even families with older siblings in college are navigating new territory.

For parents who didn’t attend college or don’t have much experience with the application process and want to help, there are numerous resources, Mr. Ponnusamy said, from the school guidance counselors to admissions tools on the College Board website to resources from his company, College Wise.

“Just talk to your kids,” said Ms. Council, “because they’re going through a lot.”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com. 

Thandi Weaver was this fall’s City Charter High School intern at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.