A representative for Juul told a ninth-grade class that its popular e-cigarette is "totally safe," two young students testified in a congressional hearing Wednesday.
Caleb Mintz told a House subcommittee that the presenter showed the device to students and said it was safe more than once during the closed-door assembly. The remarks came during a mental health and addiction seminar with no teachers present, according to the teen.
"For my classmates who were already vaping, it was a sigh of relief because now they were able to vape without any concern," Caleb said.
The testimony was the highlight of the first day of a two-part hearing to examine the company's role in the youth nicotine addiction epidemic. It was the first time the San Francisco-based company testified before Congress.
Illinois Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi, who led the hearing, said he was "shocked" by the teens' testimony.
"This is very disturbing behavior, to say the least," he told the panel.
Another teen, Phillip Furhman, said the presenter recommended the e-cigarette device and even took one out to show him.
A Juul spokesperson told the Daily News the presentation was conducted as part of a "short-lived" Education and Youth Prevention Program that ended in September 2018 "after its purpose -- to educate youth on the dangers of nicotine addiction -- was clearly misconstrued."
James Monsees, the company's co-founder, told the panel on Thursday that the product was never intended to be used by teenagers.
"We never wanted any non-nicotine user, and certainly nobody under the legal age of purchase, to ever use Juul products," he said.
But the device has been quite popular with young users. A 2018 survey found that one-fifth of middle and high school students have seen the e-cigarette used in school.
The Federal Drug Administration has been trying to crack down on the epidemic by enacting regulations on sales and marketing of such products.
Caleb told the subcommittee that the Juul representative only mentioned his connection to the company after teachers left the room. He also said the presenter seemed to be targeting students' "rebellious side."
"When teens are told not to do something, they are more likely to do it," Caleb told the panel.
"I believe the presenter was sending mixed messages by saying 'Juul is totally safe,'" he said, "and following up every 'totally safe' with, 'But we don't want you as customers.'"
Research experts and the teens' mothers, Meredith Berkman, and Dorian Fuhrman, also testified at Wednesday's hearing. They are the co-founder of an advocacy organization called Parents Against Vaping E-cigarettes, which they launched last year after learning their children were vaping.
In a statement, Juul listed a series of initiatives it has taken since November to combat youth vaping. They include shutting down the company's Facebook and Instagram accounts, advocating for legislation banning the sale of Juul pods to anyone under 21 and strengthening its retailer compliance program with more 2,000 secret shopper visits per month.
Mr. Monsees testified that Juul developed its blockbuster vaping device and flavor pods for adult smokers who want to stop. He acknowledged statistics showing “a significant number of underage Americans are using e-cigarettes, including Juul products.”
“Juul Labs isn’t big tobacco,” Mr. Monsees told members of the House subcommittee, adding that “combating underage use” is the company’s highest priority.
Krishnamoorthi questioned Mr. Monsees about what he said were similarities between the design of the original Juul device and packaging for Marlboro cigarettes. He cited minutes from a 2016 Juul board meeting that mentioned a settlement with Philip Morris International, which sells Marlboros outside the U.S., to remove triangle and diamond shapes from Juul branding. Mr. Monsees said Juul paid “zero dollars” as part of the settlement.
“There was never any intent,” to copy Marlboro, Mr. Monsees said. “The last thing we wanted was to be confused with any major tobacco company.”
Last year, Altria, the parent company of Marlboro-maker Philip Morris USA, bought a 35% stake in Juul.
During his testimony, Mr. Monsees reiterated past steps taken by Juul, including shutting down its Facebook and Instagram pages and pulling several of its flavored pods out of retail stores to keep Juuls out of the hands of teens.
Mr. Monsees said he understands the negative scrutiny of his company, but assured lawmakers Juul’s aim is to “eliminate cigarettes for good.”
“This is an industry that has done wrong for a truly long period of time,” Mr. Monsees said. “We are changing that from the inside out with products delivered by innovative people and a company that is 100% committed to changing the fabric of this market.”
Rep. Mark DeSaulnier, D-Calif., called Mr. Monsees “an example of the worst of the Bay Area. You don’t ask for permission, you ask for forgiveness. You’re nothing but a marketer of a poison, and your target is young people.”
The Associated Press and The Washington Post contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.