Last year, Rory Staunton’s parents were pleased when a study led by a University of Pittsburgh researcher showed that regulations put in place in New York state in the wake of Rory’s death at 12 years old from sepsis in 2012 were shown to improve adults’ chances of surviving septic shock.
But this week, a new study on the impact of those first-of-their-kind regulations in New York hit a little closer to home for the Stauntons.
A study published Tuesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association, again led by Pitt researchers, shows that New York’s regulations on sepsis had a dramatic impact on children’s chances of surviving septic shock.
The study found that in 54 hospitals in New York between April 2014 and the end of 2016, out of a total of 1,179 children with sepsis, 294 (25 percent) were given the full bundle of sepsis-required procedures within one hour of being admitted — the goal time of the state’s regulations.
Those 294 patients had a 40 percent better chance of surviving septic shock than did the other patients in the study — an important improvement since anywhere from 5 percent to 10 percent of children who go into septic shock die.
“Forty percent is a big improvement. This is incredibly important,” said Ciaran Staunton, Rory’s father, who, along with his wife, Orlaith, and daughter, Kathleen, led the push in New York for the state’s 2013 regulations on sepsis, which are officially called Rory’s Regulations. “It will save lives. This is why we began this.”
Sepsis, which is the leading cause of hospital-related deaths and 11th-leading cause of death overall in the U.S., is a body’s immune response to an infection that causes organ failure, tissue death and, if not treated in time, death. About 250,000 to 300,000 people die from sepsis annually in the U.S.
The New York regulations were based on the belief that a quicker diagnosis and treatment for someone with sepsis would result in lower mortality. The new study supports that hypothesis.
The study only found an association between the use of the so-called “1-hour sepsis bundle” — which is administration of antibiotics, taking of a blood culture and providing a lot of intravenous fluids, all within an hour — and improved chances of survival, not a direct causal link.
But it is the beginning of more research to come that hopefully will demonstrate even further whether such regulations can lead to saving lives, said Christopher Seymour, associate professor in Pitt’s Critical Care Medicine department and senior author of the JAMA study.
“Seeing that [the bundle] is associated with better outcomes shows there’s room for improvement” in treating sepsis, he said.
Maybe most intriguingly, the study found there was not a significant reduced chance of mortality for those patients who had some of the three steps in the sepsis bundle completed within an hour.
“It was reassuring to see that timely completion of the whole bundle was associated with reduced mortality,” said Idris Evans, lead author and assistant professor in Pitt’s Critical Care Medicine department.
This study also built on the study Dr. Seymour authored last year on the impact of New York’s regulations on adults there, which showed that for every hour of delayed treatment for adults with sepsis, the mortality rate went up 4 percent.
National statistics show that for adults, the risk of death from sepsis is even greater, with about 20 percent of adults diagnosed with sepsis dying from the immune response.
The increased mortality for adults is due to a combination of factors, including that immune systems get weaker with age, and adults are more likely to have other health issues when they contract sepsis, making it more difficult for them to recover.
Perhaps the biggest impact of the new study on children, combined with last year’s on adults, may be on states without similar regulations.
“This will stimulate a lot of interest in other states to adopt these protocols,” Dr. Seymour said.
Illinois adopted a similar set of regulations in 2016, New Jersey did the same earlier this year, and several other states, including Massachusetts, are moving forward with regulations.
Pennsylvania, where more than 9,000 people die from sepsis annually, is considering adopting similar sepsis regulations as part of an overall update of hospital regulations, Nate Wardle, spokesman for the Pennsylvania Department of Health, said in an email.
Adding sepsis regulations would be a major change for the state since Pennsylvania’s current regulations “do not specifically reference sepsis,” Mr. Wardle wrote.
The Staunton family met with former Pennsylvania secretary of health Karen Murphy in 2015, and the state held a conference on sepsis in 2016, which led Mr. Staunton to believe that “Pennsylvania has moved along in the right direction.”
In April, the Rory Staunton Foundation, which the family started to promote sepsis awareness and push for statewide regulations across the country, posted excerpts of a letter sent by Pennsylvania officials to Chris Aiello, a Pennsylvania resident who lost his 14-year-old daughter, Emily, to sepsis in 2015.
In the letter, the state said in part that, “Regulatory language … such as New York’s regulations, were reviewed and adapted for the department’s hospital regulations.”
But since the early interest expressed by the state in 2015, Orlaith Staunton said movement on Pennsylvania’s approval of sepsis regulation “has stalled.”
“We just don’t know why it is not moving more quickly,” she said.
The foundation’s goal is to have sepsis regulations approved in every state by 2020.
Mr. Wardle would not make anyone available to talk about the state’s regulations.
But he explained that the process of proposing and approving new regulations is prescribed by law and takes time. The state is not yet done with its proposal, which when completed possibly by the end of the year, will then be submitted to the various state agencies and legislative committees that have to approve it before a public comment period begins. Once the draft regulations are submitted, Mr. Wardle said it can take two years for final approval.
He said that all of the state's existing hospital regulations are more than 20 years old and added: "Nothing has changed from what Dr. Murphy told [the Stauntons], just that this process is one that takes time."
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.