Young female soccer players may be more likely to return to the field immediately after a concussion injury than male players, a new study shows.
An abstract by Shane Miller, a sports medicine physician at Texas Scottish Rite Hospital for Children, looked at 87 young athletes around 14-years-old who had sustained a concussion from soccer and were treated at his children’s sports medicine clinic in Dallas. Among the 58 female athletes, 30 returned to practice or the game the same day as the injury compared to just five of the 29 male athletes. Dr. Miller said the clinic sees a mix of patients who have recently sustained an injury and those who are recovering and are looking for another medical opinion.
Dr. Miller and clinical research coordinator at Texas Scottish Rite Hospital Aaron Zynda will present these findings in Chicago Saturday at the American Academy of Pediatrics 2017 National Conference and Exhibition.
Dr. Miller said last year he had found that among all sports, 40 percent of athletes treated at his clinic had returned to play the day of their injury despite medical guidelines. However the sample was filled with male football players and when he took a closer look at soccer — a popular sport in Texas — he said he was surprised to find a difference between female and male players.
The findings build on concerns raised from a study announced in March that suggested that high school female athletes suffer concussions at a higher rate than their male counterparts. Girls soccer resulted in the highest concussion rate among all sports, according to the study presented by Northwestern University’s Feinberg School of Medicine researchers at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. The authors speculated that the gender difference was due to heading the soccer ball, lack of protective equipment and an emphasis on in-game contact.
All 50 states have some variation of youth concussion laws that prohibit players, who show signs of concussion, from returning to play or practice until cleared by a health care provider, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported. In the last two years, both U.S. Youth Soccer and the American Youth Soccer Organization have taken measures to limit heading by players under 14, in reaction to concussion-related concerns and studies.
Read More
Despite these laws, athletes sometimes continue playing if neither the coach nor athletic trainer recognizes the symptoms or witnesses initial injury or if the player does not report the injury.
Sometimes concussion symptoms do not show up until later, said Travis Lewis, athletic trainer and physician assistant at Kids Plus Pediatrics, which has offices in Seven Fields, Greenfield and Pleasant Hills.
“I think the big barrier that we’re going to have to overcome is the culture of athletes themselves wanting to push through injuries,” Dr. Miller said. He added that it is hard to speculate why female soccer players do not follow concussion guidelines as closely as male soccer players, though one explanation could be that female players more typically may push through injuries.
At the beginning of the season, Cara Senger, head coach for Mt. Lebanon High School’s girls’ soccer team, said she makes it clear to players that they have to self report injuries since the coach’s attention is often divided.
Mr. Lewis said ignoring a concussion can prolong recovery and result in sustained symptoms. Treatment between males and females is not different, although he said women tend to report more symptoms, such as headaches and lost memory, than men do.
In the future, Dr. Miller said, he wants to find out why athletes choose to return to play. If athletes are aware of their concussions and are choosing to return to practice anyway, he said he wants to focus on reforming the culture of athletics. In comparison, if athletes and coaches are unaware of how to recognize concussions, Dr. Miller said he would focus on education.
Mr. Zynda of Texas Scottish Rite added that they intend to take a closer look at racial or school breakdowns within the students in their study.
“Despite the recommendation, it’s not a small percent of athletes that are continuing to play,” Dr. Miller said. “This is a very large problem that we need to gain a better understanding of and address.”
Amanda Zhou: azhou@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1130 or Twitter @amondozhou





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.