Public health dental hygienists in Pennsylvania are seeking to practice in places where dentists rarely go. Dentists are seeking to block them, citing concerns about safety and comprehensive care.

Regulatory changes being considered in Harrisburg could expand the range of settings where Public Health Dental Hygiene Practitioners are allowed to practice -- which advocates say will increase access to dental care.

Public health dental hygiene practitioners can work without the supervision of a dentist already in certain settings, such as elementary schools, jails and personal care homes. A proposal before the Pennsylvania State Board of Dentistry would expand that to include additional places such as daycare centers, pediatrician's offices and other locations.

Lisandra Maisonet, president of Pennsylvania Dental Hygenists Association and a public health dental hygiene practitioner herself, said the issue at stake is access to care and serving populations that aren't currently getting dental care.

Advertise with us

For example, the proposed change could reach children in the offices of pediatricians who accept Medicaid, which many dentists don't take, said Helen Hawkey, executive director of the Pennsylvania Coalition for Oral Health.

They can perform services such as teeth cleaning, and refer people to dentists for further care, she said, complementing but not replacing the work of a dentist.

“You've got someone that can go out in the community and talk to parents, talk to providers, and stress the need for oral health care,” Ms. Hawkey said.

The proposal has been opposed by dental groups, who say they are concerned with issues of safety and comprehensive care.

The change “will jeopardize patient safety, and allow a standard of care below what is acceptable” said a statement on the Pennsylvania Academy of General Dentistry website, encouraging members to voice their opposition.

Advertise with us

“Only the dentist is trained in diagnosis, and only the dentist is trained in treatment for dental disease,” said Dr. Bruce Terry, president of the Pennsylvania Dental Association. The organization, which represents approximately 6,000 member dentists, opposes the proposed expansion of sites where public health dental hygiene practitioners could work.

“Those patients are really just getting cleanings and screenings, and they're not getting comprehensive dental care,” he said.

In 2011, the state's Medicaid program stopped covering adult Medicaid patients, and many low-income adults are in need of dental care. Dr. Terry said some of that need is met through charity clinics and other events where dentists donate their services.

“Our organization wants to see comprehensive care solutions and not Band-Aids. We want dental hygienists to work as a team member of a dental team, and have them connected with a dentist for everything that they do,” he said.

The Board of Dentistry is set to vote on the draft regulation Friday in Harrisburg. The board is made up of six dentists, one dental hygienist, and one expanded function dental assistant, along with board members representing a consumer protection advocate, the Secretary of Health and two members of the public. Two additional dentist spots on the board are vacant, according to state officials.

Advertise with us

Kelly Braun, dental delivery systems coordinator for the Pennsylvania Office of Rural Health, said her agency has not weighed in on either side of the debate but public health dental hygiene practitioners often work in rural clinics.

“The model is working in rural health clinic settings,” she said.

Retired state Sen. Pat Vance, R-Cumberland, who chaired the Senate Human Services Committee and introduced the initial bill to create the position, said she has written to the dental board in support of the expansion.

“I know from the calls I received when I was in office, people really need dental care...I just think it's a win-win.”

Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.