Officials at the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have long known that Legionnaires’ disease was more deadly when it infected a person receiving medical care in a hospital or long-term care facility.
And last year the CDC confirmed what many in the field had realized: There were more and more Legionnaires’ cases in recent years, for a variety of reasons.
Tuesday the CDC said that a one-year study of 20 states confirmed something else that had been speculated: Health care-associated Legionnaires’ cases are occurring all over the country — not just in the wetter Northeast that has long been known to have more cases, which spike in warmer, more humid months when the water-borne Legionella bacteria flourishes.
“Today’s news is that people are getting Legionnaires’ disease at health care facilities in most parts of the country,” Anne Schuchat, acting director of the CDC, said in a telephone news conference.
The CDC study of 20 states showed that in 2015 there were health care-associated Legionnaires’ cases in states from Colorado to Vermont and down to Georgia. Only four states in the study —North Dakota, New Mexico, South Carolina and Maine — did not have any.
Pennsylvania was not included in the study because the state — unlike the 20 states in the survey — does not report to a special Legionnaires’ reporting database that records where an infection occurred. But there have been multiple health care-associated Legionnaires’ cases just in the Pittsburgh area in recent years, including at the Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System in 2011 and 2012 (that resulted in six deaths) and at the county run Kane nursing home in McKeesport last year, among others.
Read More
The CDC used its study Tuesday to call on all healthcare facilities — hospitals and long-term care facilities alike — to create a water management plan to try to prevent Legionnaires’ cases.
“Because of the vulnerable population they serve, it’s important for health care facilities to have a water management program,” Cynthia Whitney, chief of the respiratory disease branch at the CDC, said during the press conference.
The CDC’s data found that 25 percent of the people who contracted their Legionnaires’ disease in a health care facility died of it because they had risk factors that made them more susceptible to the disease — they smoked, were older or their immune system was compromised.
Other CDC data found that of the roughly 6,000 Legionnaires’ cases reported in 2015, only about 3 percent of them were found to be health care-associated.
“We think the 3 percent is the tip of the iceberg,” she said.
Because Legionnaires’ goes widely underreported, the actual figure of cases that are health care-associated is probably much higher, about 20 percent of all cases, CDC experts believe .
“The bottom line here is the health care-associated Legionnaires’ disease is widespread, deadly and preventable,” Dr. Schuchat said.
The CDC’s call for water management programs to deal with Legionnaires’ is just a recommendation.
But Dr. Schuchat pointed out that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) recently issued a new requirement that any CMS-certified facility — the bulk of all of the nation’s hospitals and long-term care facilities — must have a water management plans to be certified by CMS.
Dr. Schuchat pointed out that researchers also know “most of these infections can be prevented.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.