Paula Durler knows what would have happened if she had not gotten one of the few placements in Allegheny Health Network’s year-old Medical Respite Program.
“I’d be dead,” said Ms. Durler, 43, who’s currently staying in one of the program’s 10 beds while she recovers from a serious infection related to her decade-long heroin addiction. “There is no doubt in my mind.”
The novel program is the only one of its kind in the region and only the second in the state to one in Philadelphia. It is aimed at helping people who were released from a hospital stay or surgery, and are either homeless or — like Ms. Durler — in an unstable home situation, but still need follow-up medical care.
“These folks benefit from a more continuous healthcare model,” said Patrick Perri, medical director for the program and one if its founders, “rather than a temporary experience like they’re used to” where they’re discharged to the streets or an unstable home environment.
Too often, when they’re discharged, without a stable home to return to, patients like Ms. Durler do not continue to follow their medical care, Dr. Perri said, and whatever medical issue brought them to the hospital in the first place becomes a problem again.
For Ms. Durler, being in the program has meant daily checkups with one of two full-time registered nurses assigned to the program, rehabilitation sessions and drug and alcohol addiction prevention sessions. All of that has helped keep her heroin-free for 50 straight days and counting and ensured she continued to properly take antibiotics to fight her infection.
Read More
“I’ve been to nursing homes and other places before,” she said while holding the plastic vial that supplies her body antibiotics through a permanently inserted intravenous catheter. “But there’s nothing in those places to help someone like me, nothing like they have here.”
The 10 program beds are split between two shelter locations — Bethlehem Haven in Uptown and Wood Street Commons, Downtown, — and for most of the past year have nearly always been full with patients who typically stay for about a month.
The program has saved an estimated 1,000 hospital days for the 42 patients who have taken part since it began in January 2016. That was accomplished by keeping the patients healthy and preventing readmission to hospitals, a common problem for people without stable housing, said Dr. Perri.
Perhaps even more important to the future of the program, “There were very substantial cost savings” to Allegheny General Hospital, where all the patients came from, he said.
Studies of some of the other 80 respite programs around the country have found similar positive results, both for the patients and hospitals’ bottom line.
The Pittsburgh program, which has four full-time staff, was funded by AHN, with some additional funding from the Highmark Foundation to Bethlehem Haven to support their part of the program.
Dr. Perri would not say how much AHN provided in funding, or how much the program saved, but the data from the first year was positive enough that AHN is already working on plans to expand it into a communitywide program that would take in patients from non-AHN hospitals, and possibly shelters and the community.
“We believe we have proof of concept” with the data, said Stuart Fisk, director for AHN’s Center for Inclusion Health and one of the respite program’s founders.
Christina Wilds, senior program officer at the Highmark Foundation, said the data also showed that the program “has made great strides in terms of keeping people out of the emergency room.”
The program has also gotten the attention of UPMC and UPMC Health Plan, the stated rivals of AHN and its parent company, Highmark.
Representatives from all four of the region’s dominant health players met on Feb. 21 at UPMC Mercy to talk about joining to create a larger, independent version of the respite program run either by a community group or Allegheny County government that could eventually have up to 60 beds.
While it may seem odd to have rivals talking about a joint project, it is not odd to those involved in the discussion.
“It’s not UPMC’s, or AHN’s, or Highmark’s or UPMC Health Plan’s problem,” said Sharon Mackall, director of care management at UPMC Mercy, who has been part of the talks. “It’s a Pittsburgh situation. These [patients] are our individuals, our residents, and we need to help them out.”
Although AHN and Highmark were the first to plunge ahead and create a respite program, various groups across the city have been talking independently about the need for years.
“I think my first week on the street [in 1992] I knew we needed it,” said Jim Withers, founder and medical director of Operation Safety Net, which offers health care for homeless people on the streets of Pittsburgh.
Three years ago, Ed Kelly, medical director of Catholic Charities Free Health Care Center, Downtown, since it opened in 2007, said he also “realized [a respite program] was probably the next step in the care for the homeless in Western Pennsylvania.”
Dr. Kelly and Dr. Withers began an effort to raise funds to create a respite program in the city but could not get enough support. In the last year, Dr. Withers, Mercy Behavioral Health — which oversees Operation Safety Net — and Allegheny Links have been working on another effort to create a similar program with UPMC.
UPMC has been looking at creating some kind of similar program for much of the last decade, said James Schuster, vice president of of behavioral integration at the UPMC Insurance Division.
UPMC developed a housing program with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development six years ago to serve 50 people — and now for 25 after HUD cut some funding — that provides housing for people with chronic diseases and offers support that has shown patients who take part have a “decrease in medical utilization but an increase in primary care services,” Dr. Schuster said.
Even though UPMC is working on getting its own respite care program up and running this year, he said UPMC recognizes that each hospital system or insurer operating their own respite care program does not make sense.
“It needs to be a community-based solution,” he said.
The need for a program like AHN’s has increased in recent years, Mr. Fisk and others said, with the changes in the way patient care is reimbursed by government and private insurers, changes that provide incentives to reduce re-admissions.
And looming in the near future is the possibility of a repeal of the Affordable Care Act, which has significantly benefited hospitals financially by reducing the number of uninsured and decreasing charity care and bad debt expenses.
“If we see the loss of the ACA, we’re going to see an increase in the numbers of people without insurance and increased costs on the health systems,” said Mr. Fisk, a nurse practitioner.
Nearly all of the patients the program has seen so far had some form of insurance, in some cases insurance they got through the state’s expansion of Medicaid through the ACA.
While generally Medicaid does not reimburse for respite care, there may be some aspects of the services AHN’s program provides to its patients that might be deemed “medically necessary” and eligible for coverage, said Leesa Allen, deputy secretary for the state Department of Human Services’ Office of Medical Assistance.
“Certainly our managed care plans are looking at all types of programs that would keep people out of hospitals,” she said.
So, could the region’s rival insurers and hospital systems come together to solve a problem they all know can be helped?
Mr. Fisk believes it will happen for one basic reason: “This is one of the few programs that’s come around that has the potential to bring all the health care payers together around a common cause,” he said. “We all know we have to address it.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.