The day John R. Haines died after contracting a fungal infection at UPMC Shadyside, a doctor asked his wife of 35 years, Joanne, a question that merely seemed odd at the time.

“Does he have any hobbies?” the doctor asked, according to Mr. Haines daughter, Chelsea, 31, who was present.

“He likes to garden,” Joanne Haines answered.

“Oh, all right,” the doctor said.

Advertise with us

The family thought little about that interaction until Tuesday, when UPMC claimed in a statement that Mr. Haines’ contracted the fungal infection while gardening, and not during his stay at Shadyside — even though during that same meeting in October the doctor gave the family a letter that said he contracted the infection at Shadyside.

“Now it just looks like [the doctor] was fishing around for answers that could explain that this infection didn’t come from the hospital,” Chelsea Haines said. “We feel this infection developed in the hospital. It doesn’t feel right that they’re trying to make these leaps of imagination to say otherwise.”

The Haines family on Tuesday filed a medical malpractice lawsuit in Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas. It alleges that UPMC and the company that washes all of UPMC’s laundry, Paris Cleaners, are to blame for the death of Mr. Haines, 65, an AT&T telephone line installer from Upper St. Clair, because he likely contracted the infection from hospital linens. (See the full complaint attached below this story.)

The lawsuit also refers briefly to a second previously unknown case of an unnamed woman who died at Shadyside in 2015 after acquiring a fungal infection.

That case, along with Mr. Haines, brings the total number of cases to seven of people alleged to have died after acquiring fungal infections at UPMC hospitals between October 2014 and October 2016, according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

This also is the first time a third UPMC hospital has been linked to the infection. The other five cases — all involving transplant patients — occurred at UPMC Presbyterian and Montefiore hospitals, which led to a federal investigation by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in 2015. That investigation concluded that it was unable to find the source of the mold, but focused its investigation on the use of a “negative pressure” room at Presbyterian where three of those patients stayed.

UPMC Shadyside fungal infection lawsuit

Attorneys for the Haines family, the Pittsburgh firm of Meyers Evans Lupetin & Unatin, said they believe the connection between the three hospitals and the seven cases is the hospital laundry washed Paris Cleaners’ facility in Dubois, Clearfield County, where all 22 UPMC hospitals’ laundry is washed daily.

An internal UPMC report released three weeks ago in a related civil suit showed that UPMC had its private investigator, Andrew Streifel, a prominent expert on mold, look at the possibility that the linens were the source of the mold in the cases.

His report — from inspections in February 2016 — found the presence of the same mold, rhizopus, on freshly cleaned linens at Montefiore and on the roof near the air intakes at the Paris Cleaners’ Dubois facility. The mold that infected Mr. Haines also was rhizopus.

Three weeks ago when Mr. Streifel’s report became public the Haines’ family’s attorneys said that they were preparing to bring two other fungal infection cases from UPMC Shadyside to court.

Advertise with us

Asked on Jan. 26 whether there were any hospital-acquired fungal infections cases at UPMC Shadyside, UPMC spokeswoman Allison Hydzik replied in an emailed statement: “There have been no hospital-acquired cases of mucor [fungus] at UPMC Shadyside.”

Rhizopus is part of the mold family mucorales.

Asked to explain that statement, UPMC said Tuesday that a CDC guideline required them to classify these infections as hospital-acquired and tell the families they were hospital-acquired.

“We do not believe these two patients actually contracted rhizopus infections at Shadyside as other sources (latent colonization and pre-existing sinus fungal infection) were the most likely causes,” Ms. Hydzik replied in a statement Tuesday. “Pursuant to regulatory requirements, however, we were compelled to label them as hospital associated due to our testing for it and receipt of positive results while they were hospitalized. Clinically, it’s unlikely either patient contracted their infections in the hospital.”

When asked how Mr. Haines would have contracted the infection if not at the hospital, Ms. Hydzik pointed to a statement that said, in part, that “His family told us that Mr. Haines was an avid gardener.”

Advertise with us

It is possible to acquire a mold infection outside of the hospital but it is very rare, studies show.

Jerry Meyers, one of the Haines’ family’s attorneys, was stunned by UPMC’s statement that it had to tell the family it was hospital-acquired: “It’s really amazing. [UPMC] is saying they’re required to lie to their patients.”

Despite the revelation that a third UPMC hospital has been linked to a fungal case, the CDC said on Tuesday that it would not reinvestigate the case unless the Pennsylvania Department of Health made such a request.

The Department of Health said in a statement Tuesday that it “is not aware of any mold–related deaths associated with an outbreak at UPMC Shadyside Hospital ICU. At this time, there is no evidence of an ongoing outbreak. We continue to provide consultative support to UPMC and will investigate as warranted.”

Brendan Lupetin, another of the Haines’ family’s attorneys, said he hopes the department reaches out to the CDC.

Advertise with us

“We need the CDC back,” he said. “This is a very, very rare type of fungal infection. … Let’s get the CDC back and review the deaths of other patients.”

Sean D. Hamill: Shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill.

Here is the full complaint filed by the Haines family against UPMC Shadyside and Paris Cleaners:

COMPLAINT (1) (PDF)

COMPLAINT (1) (Text)