Amid controversy, the Allegheny County Board of Health will discuss adding the human papillomavirus vaccine to the list of mandated vaccinations for adolescents at its public meeting Wednesday.

The idea of a mandate, which the Allegheny County Health Department introduced at a public forum on June 22, would require students to receive all three doses of the vaccine by seventh grade to remain in school. The announcement has been met with applause on one side and criticism on the other, a battle between those who tout the vaccine’s ability to protect against certain cancers and those who fret about inconsistent research and possible side effects.

On Wednesday, the board of health will hear information regarding the vaccine and public comments before deciding if it would like to move forward with drafting a proposal. If it decides to continue, the health department could present a proposal to the board of health at its meeting in September. If the health board approves the mandate, Allegheny County Council would then need to confirm the requirement in a vote.

The vaccines, Gardasil or Cervarix, are given in three doses over six months and aim to protect against HPV, a sexually transmitted virus that causes genital warts and a host of cancers, including cervical, anal, throat and neck cancers. The body can often eradicate the virus on its own, but annually there are 17,600 women and 9,300 men affected by cancers caused by HPV, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Advertise with us

“Cancer is very silent, and when it starts causing problems is usually when it spreads,” said Electra Paskett, co-leader of the cancer control research program at the Ohio State University Comprehensive Cancer Center, who recently held a health summit on the issue. “This is something that can kill you and something that can kill you fast.”

The National Institutes of Health National Cancer Institute said the vaccine prepares the body to fight the future virus by producing antibodies that will bind to the virus and prevent it from infecting other cells. Since 2006, the CDC has reported a 56 percent drop in HPV infections caused by the types of the virus the vaccine prevents among teen girls in the United States.

The CDC recommends that boys and girls receive the vaccine at 11 or 12 years old, before they come in contact with the virus and when their immune system is most receptive. Women can get the vaccine through age 26 and men through age 21. The NIH said the vaccine lasts about eight or nine years but research is underway on long-term immunity from the virus.

In part because of the lack of clear research, some people are hesitant to support a mandated vaccine. They have expressed concerns about the vaccine because of the potential side effects and the young age of vaccination for a virus that is transmitted sexually. Furthermore, some say the county should not be involved in this decision at all.

“I’m not necessarily pro vaccine or anti vaccine, I’m pro parental rights on making these decisions,” said Janet Cook, of Franklin Park, and a member of the Pennsylvania Coalition for Informed Consent.

Advertise with us

Ms. Cook said the health board should wait before making the HPV vaccine mandatory. “There are still a lot of unanswered questions about this vaccine. ... When they tell you the risk is minimal, its only minimal when it doesn’t happen to your child,” she said.

Ginger Hites, of Crafton, shares the same concern. After watching her daughter develop arthritis-like symptoms after receiving the second dose of Gardasil, she said she would home school her children if such a mandate is approved.

Her daughter, Maggie, now 13, started the vaccine series when she was 11. After the second shot, Maggie started experiencing joint stiffness and a burning sensation in her hands and feet, which later spread to her whole body, her mother said. Although her doctors could not confirm a link between the vaccine and the arthritis, Ms. Hites said they recommended that her daughter not receive the third dose.

“She’s here in Allegheny County. It’s not all these people around the world that have these reactions. We live right here,” Ms. Hites said.

Merck, which produces Gardasil, lists on its website the most common side effects: temporary pain, swelling, itching, bruising and redness at the injection site; headache; fever; nausea; dizziness; vomiting or fainting. It also lists joint pain as a possible reaction on rare occasions. The vaccine should not be given to anyone with a severe yeast allergy or who is pregnant.

Advertise with us

In the Pittsburgh region, 27 percent of girls and 21.8 percent of boys ages 14-17 were fully vaccinated in 2014, according to the Jewish Healthcare Foundation. In Pennsylvania, 48.2 percent of females between 13 and 17 years old and 26 percent of males received all three shots in 2014, according to CDC data.

Right now, Virginia, Rhode Island and Washington, D.C. require the vaccinations, but the adherence rates have not increased significantly because of lax exemption regulations. In Pennsylvania, state guidelines allow students with moral, religious or medical concerns to be exempt from vaccinations. Dr. Paskett expects parental concerns will prevent any significant increase in vaccination rates until the vaccine is “reframed” as one that prevents cancer.

“Sixty-seven billion in health care costs are spent on HPV-related diseases. People aren’t thinking about that. They’re also not thinking about how this is something that presents in an adult but you have to give the child,” Dr. Paskett said.

Karen Hacker, director of the Allegheny County Health Department, declined to comment until the board meeting Wednesday.

Richard Keiser, a McMurray resident who has studied HPV and other diseases, agreed that a public health campaign would be necessary to stop parents from wanting to “opt out” of the vaccination. In order for the Allegheny County Health Department to move forward, he said, “they have to say why.”

Advertise with us

The health board meeting, to be held 12:30 p.m. Wednesday at 542 Fourth Ave., Downtown, is open to the public.

Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1130.