When doctors told Tom Traill in 2014 that his then 29-year-old son, Nick, was in kidney failure, he was stunned.
But when they said the option to most quickly restore Nick’s health was to get a living family member to donate a kidney, he didn’t hesitate.
“I just wanted to get it done. Whatever it took to get him healthy,” Tom Traill, 54, of North Huntingdon, said this past week, just over a year since surgeons at Allegheny General Hospital successfully took one of his kidneys and transplanted it in his son a couple weeks before Father’s Day, 2015. “Not a second thought.”
Tom Traill and his family may not have given it a second thought — his wife and older son also offered their kidneys to Nick but were not good matches — but more people are.
In a trend that has lasted more than a decade, 39 percent fewer family members — parents, children, siblings or other blood-related family — are donating one of their kidneys to a relative in need of a transplant. The dramatic turn that began in 2004 has worried and perplexed transplant experts in study after study.
“This is a big concern,” said Bertram Kasiske, director of the Hennepin County Medical Center nephrology program in Minneapolis, who has spent much of his 40-year career in the field studying the effects of kidney donation.
Even though there are about 30 percent more kidneys from non-related living donors available now than in 2004, the larger fall in family donations means there are about 1,000 fewer living kidney donations now than in 2004.
That is important for two main reasons: First, patients who get a living kidney donation do much better after transplant than patients with a kidney transplant from a deceased donor. So having fewer living kidney donations means fewer patients are getting the best possible kidney transplants.
But it’s also a concern because of the even more dramatic growth in the demand for kidneys. The waiting list for a kidney transplant has jumped 40 percent since 2004, from about 60,000 people to nearly 100,000 today. With about 1,000 fewer living donors, that means the number of people who die while waiting for a kidney has grown from about 4,100 in 2004 to about 4,400 in 2015.
“We’d all like to understand better why those [family living kidney donation] numbers have declined,” Dr. Kasiske said. “But we just don’t know. There are some theories.”
The theories range from economic concerns, to an aging populations, to a change in kidney allocations policies, or the health concerns of potential donors and other reasons.
“I think there is no one reason,” said David Klassen, chief medical director for the United Network of Organ Sharing, the private agency that oversees the nation’s transplant network.
Researchers have tried to figure out what role economics may play in the falloff, whether the recent recession played a role, or concern from potential donors that they would lose wages, or incur unreimbursed costs, while donating or recovering from donating a kidney.
This has been a persistent concern for decades. The idea has gotten traction recently and there is proposed bill in Congress from a Pennsylvania lawmaker that would help minimize those costs — though it also would seek to controversially offer incentives to people to donate.
This past week, UnitedHealthcare was cheered by the transplant community when the insurance company said it would begin reimbursing up to $5,000 in travel-related costs for donors — costs not typically covered by insurance plans — and it would cover any complications up to two years after the surgery.
Our aging population, as the Baby Boomers enter retirement age, is seen as another possible contributor. Since few kidney donations are made by those over 65, and older people typically are less healthy, they largely would be ruled out as potential donors, even if they were willing.
Some research shows that at least part of the fall off may be because of a change in the way kidneys were allocated beginning in 2005. Starting that year, kidneys from younger, deceased donors began to be more heavily given to younger — instead of sicker — patients. That may have helped lower the incentive for some family members of younger patients to consider donating their own organs.
Dr. Klassen said one of the possible factors that transplant centers regularly have to address is the out-sized concern potential donors have about the health risks for themselves.
“There does continue to be some degree of concern for the long-term safety for living donors. But the research shows the risk is very, very small,” he said.
Dr. Kasiske, who has studied the health risks to living donors, said some studies show a higher degree of risk than others but “the problem with those studies is: Who are you comparing those donors to?”
Donors are healthier than the general population because they’ve already cleared a rigorous health exam to become a donor, he said, so the risks can look smaller when compared to that group.
But when you compare them to other similarly healthy people, the differences can appear larger, he said.
One factor that holds potential to increase living kidney donations overall is the emergence in the last eight years of the so-called “paired” networks, whereby a friend or relative, or sometimes an anonymous donor, agrees to donate to a recipient, but they are not a good match.
Using complicated computer algorithms that link willing donors to those in need of a kidney all over the country, transplant centers begin a paired network chain, of one donor to another recipient they never knew.
The chains have grown as large as 34 kidney donations, which has helped push paired donor network transplants from just two transplants in 2000, to 587 in 2015.
Paired network chains “open up a whole new avenue for transplant,” Dr. Klassen said. “That has been a nice innovation in recent years.”
But how can transplant centers change the figures on family donations?
Lorenzo Machado, a kidney transplant surgeon at Allegheny General Hospital, said it is a tough issue to address for hospitals for one obvious reason.
“We generally don’t ask a person with kidney disease, ‘Hey, can you go find yourself a living donor?’ ” he said. “For most of us [in the transplant center] that would feel uncomfortable.”
But it is also uncomfortable for the person who needs a transplant, he said.
“Many of them don’t want to ask a family member because they don’t want to ask them to subject themselves to possible harm” by donating a kidney, he said.
In recent years, AGH has worked to increase the number of living donors by adopting a strategy outlined in a study at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine that seeks to train an “advocate” who will help find a living donor for the patient.
“It’s not: Show up at a family function and say, ‘Hey, you’ve got two kidneys. Give my husband one,’ ” Dr. Machado said. “It’s more about getting your story out there through your church, or social media, and educating people.”
Once someone expresses interest, their first concern is typically how their health will be impacted.
AGH’s advocates address that issue with research like that from Dr. Kasiske, conceding there is a risk of an impact on a donor’s health — including possible renal disease with the one remaining kidney — but it is small.
And then they compare it to the benefit.
“The advocate will tell them, ‘If you want your father or brother to live another 20 to 30 years or more, and be able to see his grandchildren, you can help him.’ That’s a very powerful thing,” Dr. Machado said.
Sometimes though, none of that is needed, like with the Traill family.
Tom Traill said even though he offered to help his son immediately after the idea was broached, his commitment was only strengthened in the months that followed as he watched his son go through 16 months of dialysis before the transplant.
“Dialysis is just brutal,” said Tom Traill, who is a truck driver and laborer for a pipeline company. “You just have got to do it [and donate]. You can’t let them suffer like that on dialysis.”
His son, a machinist, was in kidney failure because he had a birth defect that prevented his kidneys from growing from the time he was a boy. Instead of a typical kidney for an adult that is about 4 inches long, Nick Traill’s kidneys were about one-quarter that size.
Tom Traill and his wife, Kim, said their son is a quiet man and he did not want to comment for this story.
But Mrs. Traill said he made it clear when he woke up from his transplant on May 5, 2015, how much he appreciated what his father did for him.
“He looked awful when he woke up,” she said. “But the first thing he said was, ‘How’s dad?’ ”
For his part, Tom Traill quipped: “I’d do it again — though I don’t have another kidney to give.”
But the experience of helping to possibly save his son’s life?
“Best Father’s Day gift ever,” he said.
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.