In the latest arbitration over unresolved issues between UPMC and Highmark, the two Pittsburgh health giants have agreed that the ability of a Highmark member to continue receiving in-network care by UPMC physicians and hospitals will be decided by the patient and the treating physician.

The agreement released Thursday applies only to those patients who have a chronic or persistent medical condition, such as diabetes or cancer.

Also, any Highmark member with a confirmed pregnancy by Dec. 31 may continue to use UPMC on an in-network basis for the maternity care, delivery and postpartum care.

And if the patient’s physician is an independent practitioner, the patient can continue seeing that doctor on an in-network basis for a condition treated at a UPMC facility.

Advertise with us

Decisions about whether a Highmark patient could continue to see a UPMC physician now that the two health giants are going their separate ways was one of the unresolved issues that arose as they continue to unwind their contractual relationship.

UPMC maintained the decision should be left to the treating physician and the patient. Highmark argued that it applied only for serious medical conditions.

The long-standing contract between Highmark and UPMC that gave Highmark members in-network access to UPMC expired Jan. 1, although some members have retained access under provisions of state-brokered consent decree agreements signed by both parties last year.

The new agreement released Thursday applies for the duration of the consent decrees, which expire June 30, 2019.

While reaching an accord on this issue, other issues remain between the two, including a dispute now before the state Supreme Court on whether UPMC can exclude Highmark’s Medicare Advantage members.

Advertise with us

Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said the insurer was pleased with Thursday’s accord “because this agreement brings clarity to our members and the community. This agreement also is important for the next 3½ years, as our relationship with UPMC comes to a close.

“In the days and weeks ahead, we will be working with our members and providers to understand the agreement.”

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said the ruling confirms the health system’s long-held contention “that decisions regarding continuity of care are to be made by the patient and his or her treating physician, subject to appeal by Highmark to the Pennsylvania Department of Health.

“As always, consumers who want to be assured of full and unfettered affordable in-network access to UPMC physicians and hospitals should choose an insurer other than Highmark, including UPMC Health Plan, Aetna, Cigna and United Healthcare,” he said. “Consumers choosing to remain with Highmark for 2016 should consult with their physician to determine if they will be covered by this agreement.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.