Some women have become diligent, even to the point of worrying, about their annual mammograms. Other women who have been told they do not have a higher risk of breast cancer have seen no harm in having less frequent screenings.

Gradually some experts are agreeing that women of average risk of cancer are not jeopardizing their health if they start annual screenings after age 45 instead of at 40, and by age 55 they can cut back to every other year.

Twelve years after its last breast cancer screening guidelines were issued, the American Cancer Society Tuesday announced new recommendations that line up more closely to those made in 2009 by the independent panel of experts known as the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force.

“These groups are coming together,” said Nancy Davidson, director of the University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute and leading breast cancer researcher. “That’s good news for consumers, for the average-risk person. With women, breast cancer risk seems to increase as you age.”

Advertise with us

The cancer society commissioned a review of published breast cancer screening research, weighing the benefits and harms of screening, which is in Tuesday’s edition of JAMA, and updated data and analyses related to the screening interval and patient outcomes, published Tuesday in JAMA Oncology.

For women of average risk, the new screening recommendations are:

• Women should have regular mammograms starting at 45. (This was the strongest recommendation.)

• Women ages 45 to 54 should be screened every year.

• Women 55 and older should start to have screening every other year or, if they prefer, they should be able to continue having annual screening.

Advertise with us

• Women should have the chance to begin annual screening between ages 40 and 44.

• Women should continue getting screening as long as their health is good and they have a life expectancy of 10 years or more.

• Clinical breast exams by a physician are not recommended for average-risk women at any age.

About 10 percent of women have a family history of breast cancer, putting them at higher risk than those who do not. Obesity and certain lifestyle habits also can increase risk. But overall, most women have an average risk of developing breast cancer.

Task force guidelines, expected to be affirmed in its 2015 recommendations, call for screenings every other year for women ages 50 to 74. The task force has no recommendation for or against clinical exams and none for screenings for women 75 and older, saying evidence is insufficient to assess benefits and harms in that age group.

Advertise with us

Annual screening, compared with biennial, can present additional harms to women who are otherwise not likely to develop or die from breast cancer, such as more false-positive results and unnecessary biopsies that younger women can experience.

However, women younger than 45 have benefited from having mammograms every year, according to William Poller, director of breast imaging for Allegheny Health Network, since they can have more aggressive tumors that lower their survival rate.

“Taking away our screening abilities will increase mortality rates,” he predicted.

He said he opposes the new guidelines on those grounds: “What do people attribute the greater survival rates to? It’s better screening and better treatment.”

Most women are of average risk, he pointed out, and are now directed to talk to their doctor about screening before 45 or reducing screening after 55.

Advertise with us

“At 55, if they screen every two years, we will be less likely to pick up an interval cancer,” Dr. Poller said, voicing concern about the type of cancer, often more aggressive, that develops in the interval between mammogram dates.

“In my 40 years of practice, I never heard of a patient complaining that we did a biopsy and it was benign,” he said.

“I’m surprised that the prestigious American Cancer Society came out with these guidelines,” he said, adding that he hopes doctors will advise their patients to have the earlier and more frequent imaging under the 2003 guidelines.

The purpose of regular mammograms remains the same, according to Dr. Davidson, who was not part of the cancer society decision.

“The most important point is that all of us would like to detect cancer that would be life-threatening so that we could do something,” she said, “and do something earlier that would make a difference.”

Advertise with us

As new knowledge emerges, she said, “screening for women over 55 every other year is good.”

She also supported lifting the upper age on recommended screening.

“It’s not based on chronological age,” she said, adding that a younger woman in poor health or an older woman in good health could consider the 10-year guideline when thinking about getting a mammogram.

“It makes a good opportunity for a dialogue between the doctor and the patient.”

Dr. Davidson also said there’s no rush for any woman to change her usual mammogram schedule.

“Take plenty of time to review the guidelines and talk to your doctor.”