Get your Clorox wipes ready. With the busy holiday travel season coming up, the trip-calculating website Travelmath.com recently sent a microbiologist to collect samples from public surfaces on airplanes to see where the most germs were lurking.
The unpleasant results showed the dirtiest places weren’t in the restrooms.
By far the No. 1 bacteria-laden surface was the tray table, with an average germ population per square inch more than seven times that of the No. 2 dirtiest spot — the overhead air vent.
The toilet flush button came in third among the four areas tested, followed closely by the seat belt buckle.
“A clear takeaway from this is to eliminate any direct contact your food has with the tray table,” Travelmath said. “It’s also advisable to bring hand sanitizer for any other dirty surface you may touch along your journey.”
An average of 10 million passengers fly on U.S. airlines each week, according to the National Association of Airline Passengers.
Kristen Mertz, an epidemiologist with the Allegheny County Health Department, said that overall, the results weren’t surprising, noting that public surfaces in general harbor a multitude of germs.
Dr. Mertz couldn’t explain why the tray tables beat out the restroom for germiness. “I don’t know how often they clean [tray tables] — probably less than they used to,” she said.
At Southwest Airlines, aircraft are “tidied and refreshed” between flights, while at night, crews perform “a thorough, top-to-bottom cleaning” that includes cabins, lavatories and galleys, spokeswoman Melissa Ford said.
She didn’t say specifically whether areas such as the overhead controls or seat belt buckles were part of the routine.
“This study demonstrates the need for tray tables to be cleaned between flights,” Travelmath said.
American Airlines, owner of the former US Airways, referred questions about cleaning procedures to the industry trade group Airlines for America, which declined to answer inquiries.
There are a number of illness-causing germs that travelers could pick up on planes, Dr. Mertz said, such as cold and flu viruses, noroviruses — which cause vomiting and diarrhea — and E. coli bacteria, which also cause intestinal symptoms.
None of the specimens collected by Travelmath contained fecal coliforms, such as E.coli, the site said.
Besides testing cabins on four flights, Travelmath checked two public surfaces at five airport terminals. It found drinking fountain buttons on average had nearly 18 times more germs [colony-forming units] than the bathroom stall locks.
“Bathrooms were some of the cleaner surfaces tested, which may be contrary to conventional thought,” the website said. “Regular cleaning schedules mean these surfaces are sanitized more frequently.”
Dr. Mertz said the risk of getting sick on a plane probably isn’t any greater than being in any other crowded quarters.
She recommended people protect themselves by washing their hands frequently; using an alcohol-based hand sanitizer; coughing into their elbows or shoulders to help reduce the spread of germs; and getting flu vaccines in the fall.
Would it be overkill if travelers used antibacterial wipes to sanitize tray tables, overhead controls and other festering surfaces when boarding a plane?
“I’ve seen people bring alcohol wipes and wipe the tray table,” Dr. Mertz said.
“It’s not going to hurt.”
Patricia Sabatini: psabatini@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.