The Department of Veterans Affairs had hoped to mollify members of Congress and the families of victims of the Legionnaires’ outbreak at the Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System when it fired former director Terry Wolf last year.
It didn’t. In documents obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette through the Freedom of Information Act, and first revealed in a story Saturday, the VA had tried to reprimand Ms. Wolf and then demote and transfer her, which incensed family and officials alike.
“What is this, the Catholic Church?” asked Maureen Ciarolla, the daughter of John Ciarolla, 83, of North Versailles, the first of six fatalities during the outbreak when he died in July 2011. “We just transfer people around and no one will discover the atrocities she and the others are responsible for? When do we start to take a stand and protect our veterans and not these people?”
Judy Nicklas, daughter-in-law to William Nicklas, 87, of Hampton, who was the last victim of the outbreak when he died in November 2012, agreed. “It is not acceptable to simply move non-performing individuals from one site to another,” Ms. Nicklas said. “Based on the fact that six people died as a direct result of the lack of leadership and transparency, we feel that they should feel lucky to not be in prison.”
U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, who has worked with the families since the outbreak was revealed in November 2012, said in a statement, in part: “I’m alarmed that the VA’s initial response was to transfer their problems instead of fixing them.”
And even though Ms. Wolf was eventually fired, and four other officials at the Pittsburgh VA were disciplined — with at least one of them having her discipline overturned — Mr. Murphy said the punishment was too lenient.
In one document, Ms. Wolf’s attorneys revealed for the first time the titles of the four other employees who the VA says it disciplined for their roles in the Legionnaires’ outbreak.
The Post-Gazette was able confirm the names and that three of them still hold the titles they held during the outbreak: Ali Sonel, the Pittsburgh VA’s chief of staff; Lovetta Ford, associate director; and Mona Melham, the director of pathology and laboratory medicine, which was one of her titles and duties before but is now her sole position.
The other employee, Susan McCaffrey, the former vice president of facilities management services, now holds a different position that the VA would not discuss.
Dr. Melham’s attorney said she fought her reprimand and had it overturned. Dr. Sonel’s attorney said he had done everything he could during the outbreak.
Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., said through a spokesman that he was particularly upset by Ms. Wolf’s assertion that no matter what, the outbreak was “unavoidable.”
“The families who lost loved ones during this Legionnaires’ outbreak and the entire community deserve to know that every measure is being taken to hold people accountable and ensure this doesn’t happen again,” spokesman John Rizzo said in a statement.
Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, who represents the area that includes the Pittsburgh VA, would not comment.
His brother, Patrick, is director of the Pittsburgh VA’s audiology and speech pathology program.
“The congressman feels it is not appropriate to comment on personnel matters when, at least according to the Post-Gazette, people are being held accountable for their actions,” said spokesman Matt Dinkel.
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.