Because of the Penguins visit to Children’s Hospital on Dec. 11, just two days before one of them began showing symptoms of having the mumps, Children’s will discuss raising awareness of possible infections with visiting sports teams in the future, according to an infectious disease doctor there.

“We will probably make sure going forward that we have a conversation” with a sports team that might be dealing with an infectious disease, said Michael Green, an infectious disease doctor at Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC.

The Penguins had not confirmed that anyone on their team had mumps before their visit to Children’s Dec. 11. Beau Bennett, a winger who went to Children’s to visit patients, started showing symptoms two days later, putting him within the two-day window of being infectious when he visited the hospital.

Penguins’ President David Morehouse said that he spoke with Children’s President Christopher Gessner earlier this week about the situation and that Mr. Gessner told him: “You guys didn’t do anything wrong. You simply didn’t know.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Morehouse added: “He knows we wouldn’t have come if we knew any of our guys are sick. Anyone around Pittsburgh knows helping kids is part of the DNA of the organization. It’s an unfortunate situation and we hope the kids are okay.”

Children’s reiterated Mr. Gessner’s position in a statement Friday, saying in part: “The Penguins and all other Pittsburgh sports teams are always welcome at Children’s Hospital. The impact of their visits on our patients, families, and staff is extremely uplifting. When we have athletes and celebrities who visit our patients, we always ask anyone who is ill to postpone their visit … All of the other players had no symptoms or signs of illness at the time of their visit. The Penguins organization handled the situation in a completely appropriate manner."

Before the visit, the Penguins knew that in the previous two weeks they had played two NHL teams that had already publicly disclosed players on their teams had the mumps. They also were trying to figure out what was causing swelling on Sidney Crosby’s neck, a process that included testing him twice for mumps. A third test after Dec. 11 confirmed Mr. Crosby did have the mumps.

And they were concerned enough about the outbreak that on Dec. 3 they tested everyone on the team to see what their antibody count was for mumps, tests that were low enough for 19 players and staff that on Dec. 6 they were given booster shots of the mumps vaccine.

Before the Penguins visited on Dec. 11, no one with the Penguins consulted with anyone at Children’s about the situation — something that infectious disease experts at other hospitals say should have happened.

Advertise with us

“If that was happening at my own institution and the New York Rangers were going to come here, that would have been something I would have wanted to discuss,” said Judith Aberg, chief of infectious diseases at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York and herself a hockey fan.

Paul Offit, professor of pediatrics in the division of infectious disease at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, agreed.

“First of all, [the Penguins’] heart is in the right place. You hate to beat them up for this,” said Dr. Offit, who did his residency at Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh in the late 1970s. “But, if there is even a question of the team having an infectious disease, they should have allowed the infectious control team at the hospital to know about it.”

Larry Kociolek, a physician in the division of infectious diseases at Lurie Children’s Hospital in Chicago, said he regularly talks with staff at his hospital when any sports team is going to visit because Lurie’s staff will screen the team by asking about any possible diseases anyone might be experiencing.

“I’ve dealt with situations where we have had to restrict [a player or team’s] visitation,” he said.

Advertise with us

All three of these outside experts, who all follow hockey as fans, were generally familiar with the situation in Pittsburgh and the NHL. But they weren’t as familiar with the timeline prior to the Penguin’s visit to Children’s, which the Post-Gazette explained based on the Penguins’ description of events, both on the Penguins’ website and in interviews.

Dr. Green said Children’s will be watching next week to see if any of their patients contracted the disease, which typically takes from 12 to 18 days after exposure for children to show symptoms.

He said that despite the possible exposure by Mr. Bennett to patients at Children’s, he still is not sure what he would have done if he knew everything the Penguins knew before they visited.

“No one ever asked me if they could come or not,” he said. “But it’s hard to say we should cancel an event without a proven case.”