A wrongful termination lawsuit claims Allegheny County Health Department director Bruce Dixon was fired at County Executive Rich Fitzgerald's direction.
The lawsuit filed late Friday afternoon in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court names the county, health board and Mr. Fitzgerald as defendants. It seeks a declaratory judgment and reinstatement of Dr. Dixon, 73, whose 20-year tenure as director was terminated by what the suit said was an illegal vote of the board March 7.
According to the 42-page filing, the county executive can appoint board members and approve or disapprove board-passed regulations but has no authority to administer the department or control the actions of the health board or its director because the department is an independent agency. Only the health board can appoint or remove the department director, the suit said.
The suit claims Mr. Fitzgerald directed the board to terminate Dr. Dixon and threatened to remove board members who did not vote to do so.
Before the nomination and appointment of five board members just days before the vote, Mr. Fitzgerald required them to submit undated and signed letters of resignation that he could use if the board members didn't vote to fire Dr. Dixon, according to the lawsuit.
The suit said the county executive's actions "harmed the administration of matters of public health and represent a clear and present danger to the protection of public health in Allegheny County."
Amie Downs, Mr. Fitzgerald's spokeswoman, said he would not comment on the lawsuit.
Dr. Dixon was fired by the board on a vote of 6-0 with one abstention. Under the terms of his contract, which was to run through June 2013, the county paid $175,000 a year to the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, where Dr. Dixon is a tenured member of the faculty.
Prior to voting to oust Dr. Dixon, the board held a 90-minute closed-door session and engaged in no public discussion of the issues it had considered in reaching its decision. The suit claims that the board cannot remove the director without cause.
In the weeks prior to the firing of Dr. Dixon, Mr. Fitzgerald had made it clear that he wanted to put his own stamp on the Health Department and had taken issue with the Dr. Dixon's handling of a recent restaurant-grading controversy, diesel-idling regulations and delays in air pollution permitting, among other issues.
On the day before Dr. Dixon was terminated by the board, Mr. Fitzgerald called him and asked him to voluntarily resign, but Dr. Dixon refused.
In a statement issued by Mr. Fitzgerald following Dr. Dixon's termination by the board, he said it was "time to take the department in a new direction and to ensure that our public health, air quality, food safety and other critical services are among the best in the nation."
Since the termination vote, the lawsuit claims, Mr. Fitzgerald, his staff and a county solicitor have held weekly, unadvertised meetings with the board in violation of the state Sunshine Act, which requires that such meetings be publicly advertised and open for public attendance.
Lee Harrison, the board chairman, could not be reached for comment Monday afternoon.
Such meetings have interfered with Dr. Dixon's ongoing administration of the department and are in violation of the state Local Health Administration Law, which is intended to insulate the public health system from the political process, according to the lawsuit. The county's personnel and human resources department, at the direction of the county executive, is working on hiring a new director, a task that is delegated by law to the health board, the suit said.
Virginia Cook, a tax attorney who filed the lawsuit as Dr. Dixon's personal attorney, declined comment.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.