HARRISBURG -- Highmark's contract with the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center is nearing its end, but one area lawmaker wants to ensure that subscribers who need care at the health system's specialty hospitals can still get it -- and at in-network rates.

State Rep. Dan Frankel wants to force the medical center and insurance giant back to the negotiating table, and he's using the threat of binding arbitration to get them there.

Mr. Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, is drafting legislation that would require binding arbitration if an agreement can't be reached by October 2012 -- three months after the current Highmark-UPMC contract expires.

Arbiters would include one health care consumer and one representative each from UPMC, Highmark, a business group and a community group.

Advertise with us

The threat of arbitration is meant as an incentive to get both sides to reach an agreement on their own, Mr. Frankel said. His goal is to preserve patients' access to specialty health care at facilities that have specialized equipment, clinical trials, treatments and expertise not available elsewhere in the region.

Mr. Frankel's legislation would apply to Children's Hospital, Magee-Womens Hospital, Hillman Cancer Center, Western Psychiatric, UPMC cancer centers and health care workers who provide services at those facilities.

UPMC has said it can no longer renew business with Highmark, now that the insurance giant is acquiring the financially troubled West Penn Allegheny Health System.

"They're walking away from their role as the neutral insurer and becoming a direct competitor. It would put the UPMC business at risk to contract with Highmark now," UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said.

"If there were a contract with Highmark, Highmark could go out and market our facilities, our great physicians and all the great things UPMC is. They would lure subscribers and then steer those subscribers to the West Penn Allegheny Health System," he said. "These tactics should be discouraged, not promoted by legislation."

Advertise with us

Instead of renewing its agreement with Highmark, UPMC has expanded its contracts with four other national insurers, increasing competition and, Mr. Wood said, reducing premiums.

Mr. Frankel said UPMC is behaving like a Wall Street business, not like a nonprofit community resource that receives tax exemptions and charitable contributions.

"Community members are active stakeholders [who have] earned our place in this conversation. We rightly feel these world-class facilities belong to us," Mr. Frankel said.

Highmark spokesman Michael Weinstein said the insurance company welcomes legislation aimed at getting negotiations on track.

Without an agreement, Highmark members could still go to UPMC facilities but would have to pay out-of-network rates that can be triple the in-network costs -- enough to bankrupt someone with a serious illness, Mr. Weinstein said.

Advertise with us

Highmark's contracts with most UPMC facilities end on June 30, but "run off" clauses allow subscribers to continue paying in-network rates for in-patient stays.

Mr. Frankel plans to introduce his legislation next week and already has 25 co-sponsors, mostly Western Pennsylvania Democrats.