HARRISBURG -- Pennsylvania House Republicans Tuesday beat back a series of proposed changes to a bill that would tighten supervision of abortion clinics by holding them to the same regulations that apply to free-standing ambulatory surgical centers.
The one-sided results in the floor debate over amendments strongly suggested the GOP majority would have little trouble passing the measure in an expected vote today and sending it to the state Senate.
"This shouldn't be about whether you are pro-life or pro-choice," said the prime sponsor, Rep. Matt Baker, R-Tioga. "This is about patient safety."
Supporters said drastic changes were warranted in the wake of a scandal involving a Philadelphia abortion clinic, where a grand jury reported filthy and unsafe conditions. The doctor who owned the clinic is being held without bail on murder charges for allegedly performing illegal abortions that killed a patient and viable infants, severing their spinal cords with scissors.
"We cannot tolerate this -- we can't call it a loophole," said Rep. Mauree Gingrich, R-Lebanon. "We have to fix it, we have to stop it. We have to do more; we can't do less."
Republican supporters said drastic measures were necessary to solve the problems at Dr. Kermit Gosnell's Women's Medical Society in West Philadelphia and shortcomings uncovered during inspections at other Pennsylvania clinics.
"When you have three out of 23 clinics closing their doors because of substandard care, and an additional 15 failing to pass inspections, I think there is a much broader problem," said Rep. Bryan Cutler, R-Lancaster.
The only proposed amendment sponsored by a Republican, patterned largely on a bill that has been moving through the state Senate, would have focused on how inspections are conducted and the handling of complaints by state agencies.
The amendment pushed by Rep. Chris Ross of Chester County came closest to passage of any of the eight votes, but it failed, 130-68. Six Republicans joined Ross in voting for it, while 27 Democrats joined nearly all Republicans in casting "no" votes.
Democrats said the underlying bill would place onerous requirements on abortion clinics and result in far less access to the procedure for women.
Proposals failed that would have phased in the changes over more time, exempted entities that only facilitate birth control, clarified that the Abortion Control Act would apply if the laws contradict each other, or grandfathered clinics already in operation.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.