Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton yesterday said she still found it "distressing" that doctors failed to detect her husband's heart disease during his presidency. More than 41/2 years after leaving office, former President Bill Clinton underwent quadruple bypass surgery.
"He had very thorough medical exams every year ... and he kept getting clean bills of health from everybody," Mrs. Clinton said during a meeting with the Post-Gazette editorial board. "People would say, 'Yeah, you should exercise more and lose weight,' but there were no danger signals. And, in fact, there were, and they were missed."
But local cardiologists say Mrs. Clinton might be mistaken.
Dr. David M. Lasorda, director of interventional cardiology at Allegheny General Hospital, said Mr. Clinton likely had his cholesterol and blood pressure measured each year, along with an electrocardiogram (EKG) and stress test -- the same tests used today to test heart function. One can pass those tests even with some arterial blockage.
"He was relatively young [as president] and not having any symptoms," Dr. Lasorda said.
Plaque buildup occurs for years without limiting blood flow, he said. When it reaches a critical point, often at 70 percent blockage, impairment can be detected with an EKG and stress test, which shows when the body's demand for blood and oxygen is higher than the circulatory system can provide.
EKGs and stress tests reveal only "with relative certainty" that a person "doesn't have significant blockage," Dr. Lasorda said. "A 50 percent blockage can show up as normal. But that doesn't mean you have pristine, normal arteries."
Mr. Clinton's bad diet as president is legendary. The White House chow hound feasted on a diet often featuring cheeseburgers, steaks, fried foods and dishes laden with cheese.
When abnormalities do arise, a heart catheterization -- an invasive procedure -- is used to determine the locations and degree of blockages. Newer imaging technologies have better resolution and a new scanning technology can show blockages noninvasively, but health plans generally don't reimburse for the procedure, Dr. Lasorda said.
Mr. Clinton's doctors also would have been well aware of any history of heart disease in his family. That he developed serious heart problems 41/2 years later "doesn't surprise me at all," Dr. Lasorda said.
Dr. Alan Gradman, director of the Cardiology Fellowship Training Program at West Penn Hospital, said he doesn't know Mr. Clinton's health history, "but I suspect her thinking is wrong."
Even if a person has blockages, pinpointing when problems will occur is not yet possible. "This is a big problem in coronary disease," he said. "I suspect they didn't miss anything, as carefully as he was evaluated as president."
What happened to Mr. Clinton "we see every day," Dr. Gradman said, noting that people can have atherosclerosis, or inflammation response in the arteries, for 10, 15 and even 20 years before a heart attack occurs.
"She may know something I don't know, that he was having symptoms," he said. "So I don't want to say she's absolutely wrong. But dealing with typical situations, I suspect that she is.
"Here's a guy that went through incredible stress with impeachment," in his final years of presidency. "Usually that can take its toll."
During Mrs. Clinton's visit, Post-Gazette co-publisher and editor-in-chief John Robinson Block gave her a copy of the Cleveland Clinic's book, "Healthy Heart: Lifestyle Guide and Cookbook" published in 2007.
Mr. Block said he's giving each presidential candidate a copy with hope it will help them "improve the health of America."
In the book's foreword, Dr. Steven E. Nissen, chairman of Cleveland Clinic's Department of Cardiovascular Medicine, said that if every American followed its dietary and lifestyle guidelines, marvelous things would happen, including dramatic reductions in heart disease, diabetes and the nation's health care costs.
After his surgery, Mr. Clinton announced he'd adopted the South Beach Diet and had slimmed down. His foundation now focuses on health issues, including ways to reduce obesity in children.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.