A Ukrainian Catholic congregation has sued Collier, claiming the township violated the congregation’s civil rights by blocking plans to construct a new chapel.

Holy Trinity Ukrainian Catholic Church filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania on Wednesday, alleging the township violated the First Amendment — which guarantees churches the right to worship free of government interference — by denying permits for a planned expansion.

The church also claims the township is violating the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, which protects houses of worship from discrimination in zoning and landmarking laws, by “imposing unreasonable restrictions” and refusing to grant permits for the project.

“We are a parish that seeks to worship freely and serve the needs of the community while being treated fairly and equally as all organizations in the Township,"  the Rev. Jason Charron, the priest of the church, said in a statement.

Advertise with us

Brian Gabriel, the attorney representing the township, declined to comment on the lawsuit.

Holy Trinity Church, which has a registered membership of 225 families, is located in Carnegie and traces its roots  to the 19th century after Eastern Europeans came to the region to work in the steel and mining industries.

In 1953, members of the congregation bought the 41-acre “Trinity Acres” property in Collier and transformed it into a cemetery.

In 2023, the church planned to use some of the property to build a chapel and other facilities where its members and other Ukrainian Catholics could worship.

The township rejected a permit application for the new structure, according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

The church’s initial plans were to build a 13,000-square-foot chapel that would house a social hall, sanctuary, gift shop and 18-room retreat center.

Current township ordinances prohibit churches from being built on property zoned as Planned Economic Development Districts, which is the designation for the property on which the church wanted to build. The township allows schools, businesses, offices and other properties to operate within such districts.

In December 2023, the church applied to amend local zoning ordinances to allow the conditional use of planned cultural centers in the economic development zones, but the Collier commissioners denied the proposal during a public hearing in September 2024.

Months later, the church submitted a new application for a significantly scaled-down project. In June 2025, the township planning commission issued a letter approving the project if eight conditions were met.

Those included rules that the chapel and planned mausoleum should be no more than 5,000 square feet, that the height should be no greater than 35 feet, and that memorial services should only be held for people deceased after June 9, 2025.

Advertise with us

The conditions also required that church bells only be used during funerals or memorial services, and not before 9 a.m., and that the chapel and mausoleum should only be used for funerals or memorial services.

The church said the conditions meant that it couldn’t hold worship services on the property, including All Souls’ Saturday services — when the church honors all those who have died — because that includes people who passed away before June 9, 2025.

In July, the church appealed the township’s decision to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. That case remains pending.

Lawyers representing the church in its federal lawsuit claim the township did not consider, and violated, the religious land use act in ruling on the church’s application.

“You shouldn’t be treating churches worse than other secular [property] uses,” said Randall Wenger, chief counsel at Independence Law Center, which is representing the church.

Advertise with us

Holy Trinity is asking the court to prohibit the township from allegedly infringing on its rights under the religious land use act.

Mr. Wenger said if the court rules in the church’s favor, it is unclear whether the congregation would attempt to proceed with the larger project or the scaled-down version.

“I think we need to hit the reset button and find out where we can go from there,” he said.