Family members say the last photo of Rabbi Eli Schlanger was taken 30 minutes before he was shot and killed on a beach in Australia Sunday evening. 

Thousands had flocked to Bondi Beach to celebrate the first night of Hanukkah, some of the first people in the world to mark the start of the eight-day holiday.

Then the unthinkable happened.

Just minutes after Rabbi Schlanger, 40, was photographed, two gunmen opened fire, killing him and 14 others during what was meant to be a joyous event celebrating the Jewish festival of lights.

Advertise with us

In the photo, Rabbi Schlanger can be seen helping an attendee put on their tefillin — a pair of black leather boxes containing Hebrew parchment scrolls — one for the head and one for the arm. 

The Torah commands Jewish men to bind tefillin to their head and upper arm every weekday, according to Chabad, a Jewish movement with 3,500 affiliated institutions in more than 100 countries worldwide. 

In the Jewish faith, tefillin is considered a powerful mitzvah — a good deed. 

In Rabbi Schlanger’s final minutes, he was doing just that.

“That is what he was all about,” his cousin Rabbi Moishe Mayir Vogel, who lives and works in Squirrel Hill, told the Post-Gazette on Monday.

Advertise with us

“And that's what he would want us to do, given this tragedy.”

Rabbi Schlanger’s time in Pittsburgh

The event on Bondi Beach marked the start of Hanukkah, which commemorates the rededication of the Temple of Jerusalem after a war between the Maccabees and a Greek army. 

Observers light a candle for each of the eight nights of the holiday to remember when a small supply of oil — enough to provide light for just a single day — lasted for eight.

Since Sunday’s attack, Rabbi Vogel said he has been in constant contact with his family. 

“It’s a painful, traumatic time,” said Rabbi Vogel, who has done prison ministry in Pittsburgh for over 30 years through the Aleph Institute in Squirrel Hill.  

Advertise with us

As a child, Rabbi Schlanger spent several weeks living in Pittsburgh while his immediate family decided whether to settle in the city, Rabbi Vogel said, although they ultimately ended up in New York.

“They heard so many nice things about the Pittsburgh community, and they were considering moving here,” Rabbi Yisroel Rosenfeld, who was the dean of Yeshiva Schools of Pittsburgh at the time, told the Post-Gazette.

Rabbi Schlanger, who served as assistant rabbi of Chabad of Bondi, had organized the Chanukah by the Sea event where Sunday’s fatal shooting took place, according to Chabad. His in-laws founded Chabad of Bondi decades ago. 

Rabbi Schlanger had been living in Sydney for the past 18 years, Rabbi Vogel said, where he was working to grow Chabad of Bondi’s membership and build a new synagogue with room for 300 people. 

“He built a beautiful community,” Rabbi Vogel said. 

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh continues to celebrate Hanukkah

Hours after the attack in Sydney, Chabad’s decades-old “menorah parade” tradition in Pittsburgh returned Sunday evening. 

Amid freezing temperatures, hundreds attended the event as dozens drove cars with menorahs strapped to their roofs. Turnout was higher than expected, said Rabbi Yitzi Goldwasser, who oversaw some of the planning for the annual celebration.  

“People were afraid,” he said. “Yet people felt the need to be there.”

Rabbi Goldwasser said he took pause when he first heard the news — especially as he was preparing to celebrate the holiday in the city where a gunman killed 11 people at a Squirrel Hill synagogue in 2018 in the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history.

“I froze,” he said. “This could have happened to anyone.”

Advertise with us

The parade concluded with a gathering in Greenfield, where Rabbi Menachem Aron of Chabad of Rural and Regional Australia called in to lead a prayer for the victims and their families.

With more Hanukkah events scheduled around Pittsburgh in the coming days, including a menorah lighting at the City-County Building set for Monday night, safety officials say additional patrols have been added throughout the city.

“Pittsburgh police officers are conducting additional, directed patrols around synagogues, schools and Jewish institutions out of an abundance of caution,” Public Safety spokeswoman Cara Cruz said.

Shawn Brokos, director of community security for the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh, said she had asked for a larger local law enforcement presence at the Hanukkah events throughout the city this week. 

Officials were not aware of any threat in Pittsburgh tied to Sunday’s incident, she said. The added security aims to put some fears at ease.

Advertise with us

“Being Pittsburgh, it raises a lot of previous trauma from the Tree of Life building shooting,” she said. “This additional presence … helps the community go out and be able to enjoy some of the festivities without some of that anxiety.”

‘Bring more light into the world’ 

Rabbis who spoke to the Post-Gazette said lighting the menorah this Hanukkah is now more important than ever. 

“Do what you can to bring more light into the world,” Rabbi Rosenfeld said. 

The message of Hanukkah, he said, is to not back down in the face of a challenge. 

Just like the Maccabees, he said, Jewish people today need to continue to overcome.

Advertise with us

Last Hanukkah, Rabbi Schlanger posted a video on social media showing how he thought people should respond in the face of antisemitism, according to Chabad. 

In the video, he can be seen dancing toward his car before placing a menorah on top of it — just like the dozens of Pittsburghers who took part in Sunday’s parade. 

“Despite what went on, we've got to move forward,” Rabbi Vogel said. 

“We've got to move on and spread more light.”