When Cardinal Robert Prevost appeared on the balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica on Thursday and was announced as the first American pope to lead the 1.4 billion-strong Roman Catholic Church, shockwaves rippled through the faithful in Pittsburgh and across the world.

As the College of Cardinals prepared for the conclave inside the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican this week, speculation was rampant about who they would select as the 267th pope to succeed Pope Francis, who died April 21. Four names rose to the top as front-runners —three of Italian descent and one Filipino.

American-born Cardinal Prevost, a Villanova University graduate and Chicago native who spent decades ministering in Peru, was not among them.

“When the news came out, I was shocked,” Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh Bishop Zubik said hours after the announcement. “That’s the way the Holy Spirit works. Over the course of the last couple of weeks, everybody’s been speculating and putting names out there, and there were Las Vegas bets about who it was going to be. … while a lot of people will look at a conclave as somehow being akin to the politics that exist in our country. It isn’t the way that it works.”

Advertise with us

The bishop said the choice for an American-born pontiff to lead the 2,000-year-old Roman Catholic Church makes history and “breaks a lot of taboos.” And former Cardinal Prevost’s choice of the name Pope Leo XIV is important, too, Bishop Zubik said, as Pope Leo XIII focused much of his papacy on social justice and “spoke out about the dignity of the working person” and was “one of the greatest popes of the last century.”

“A lot of people said there could never possibly be an American pope because of America being a superpower,” Bishop Zubik said. “But once again, it goes beyond our own understanding of the way politics works, and that’s not what this was. I think that I’m thrilled with his election.”

Although the selection stunned many, Bishop Zubik said he wasn’t surprised the 133 voting cardinals made their choice on the second day of the conclave.

The first vote took place on Wednesday evening, and no candidate secured the necessary two-thirds majority, or 89 votes. The voting papers were then burned in a stove inside the Sistine Chapel with a chemical that produced black smoke and sent it billowing from the chapel chimney, indicating to the world that no pope was elected.

The cardinals retired for the day and returned Thursday morning for another vote, which didn’t reach the majority needed, and then a third vote in the early afternoon, which also sent black smoke pouring from the chimney. On the fourth vote, the choice was made and the white smoke sent the message those around the world had been waiting for.

Advertise with us

“I anticipated it was going to happen [Thursday]. ... The vote that was taking place [Wednesday] night, it seemed to me that that took a long time. … I sensed [Wednesday] night that it took a long time for the black smoke to come up, which seemed to me to say that they were probably pretty close to a decision,” Bishop Zubik said. “So I would have been surprised if the election didn’t happen.”

Bishop Zubik said Pope Leo XIV’s background as a missionary mirrored Pope Francis’ missionary work in Argentina and his mindset of embracing those struggling with poverty, hunger and war.

“I think because [Pope Francis and Pope Leo XIV] worked in countries where there were many people in need of economic help or encouragement, that stands to give us a sign that his heart is full of compassion,” the bishop said.

His first impression upon seeing the new pope greet the crowd of thousands in St. Peter’s Square and throngs watching around the world was a good one.

“As Pope Leo XIV was on the loggia, there were a good number of times when he was holding back tears, obviously trying to grasp the moment,” he said. “You have [so] many people out there in the square, but they were only a snapshot of the people that he was going to be leading. That said to me he was very humble.”

Advertise with us

The bishop said he expects to see the effects of Pope Leo XIV’s papacy reflected on the Catholic community in Pittsburgh soon.

“Watch, for the next couple years, Leo is going to become a very popular name that people are going to be giving their kids for either baptism or kids are going to take it when they’re coming to receive the sacrament of Confirmation,” he said.

‘The new light’

Kevin Hayes, president of the board of directors for Catholics for Change in our Church, a Pittsburgh-based nonprofit, said the choice of an American pope was surprising, as it would add more weight to the influence of the United States, which already wields significant power politically and economically.

“I was just stunned,” he said.

But Pope Leo XIV, born Robert Francis Prevost in 1955 in Chicago, is also a Peruvian citizen who spent two decades there, first as a missionary and then as Archbishop of Chiclayo, Peru, and head of the Augustinian religious order. He did not speak English in his first speech as the new Holy See, initially speaking Italian and then switching to Spanish.

Advertise with us

“He’s spent so much of his time in Peru and outside of America,” Mr. Hayes said. “He doesn’t have the American aura around him.”

Mr. Hayes said he was glad the conclave chose someone who would continue the legacy of Pope Francis, who championed marginalized communities and whose papacy was dedicated to spreading the message that all are deserving of mercy.

“His first comments were wonderful and even very much in the same tone of Pope Francis’ first remarks with a lot of humility, trust in God, and trust in Mary, the mother of God … also saying the church is for everyone and the church needs to be compassionate to those in need. It was just wonderful,” he said.

The conclusion of the conclave and announcement of Pope Leo XIV’s papacy was streamed throughout schools in the Pittsburgh diocese as students took a break from classes to watch the introduction of the new head of the Catholic Church.

“It’s kind of like when everyone watches the parade when the Steelers win the Super Bowl, for at least one class period. … They were excited to see who the next pope is,” said Nick Sciarappa, youth minister at St. Luke the Evangelist Parish in Ambridge and Sewickley. “There’s an added wow factor that he’s American, but this happened with Pope Francis, too. There’s just a buzz that we have a new pope.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Sciarappa said that many young Catholics in the area have since taken to social media to post about the new pope.

“It’s across the board,” he said. “It’s chaotic. There’s a lot of memes. It’s just the exciting thing of the day. … These teens will be raised with this missionary pope, who was from Chicago, is a Cubs fan. That’s so relatable.”

Mr. Sciarappa said the ritual and pageantry of the conclave also enthralled many young Catholics.

“It’s a rare case where teenagers were interested in an institution and thought it was cool, which is not the millennial mindset, Gen X or anything like that,” he said. “They just felt like they were part of something grounded, something that is sturdy in a world where the life of a teenager is full of anxiety and what’s going to happen next for them. The institution of the church is a place of comfort because it’s unchanging. Its got this history. It’s something that’s solid in their life.”

Some said that Pope Leo XIV’s election signals a new increasingly global era for the Catholic Church.

Advertise with us

“For centuries, it’s been a role seen as very Eurocentric,” said Stephen Calme, assistant professor of theology at Carlow University. “But with both Pope Francis and now Pope Leo, we’re seeing more of what a truly global church looks like.”

He said the appointment aligns with Pope Francis’ focus on reaching Catholics around the world, adding: “The fact that the new pope has spent time in Peru — he’s not just someone who has operated in English-speaking areas — I think this is very much in line with the direction Pope Francis has set.”

For others, the election for Pope Leo XIV represents a reassurance of America’s role in the world.

“The election of Cardinal Robert Prevost as the new pope — taking the name Pope Leo XIV — is historic and should be reassuring to Catholics worldwide,” Duquesne University President Ken Gormley said in a statement. “The first American-born cardinal to become pope — at a time when the United States faces challenges in conveying a positive image around the world — is a historic nod to this nation’s importance in the global community.”

As Rev. Samir Chebli prepared for Mass Thursday evening at Our Lady of Victory Maronite Church in Beechview, he said he believed it was “God’s message” that the world needed an American pope.

Advertise with us

“God has his own way of giving us a new pope,” he said. “The world needs a person like him for this moment. What we need is light and the pope is the new light — that man will bring peace to the whole world.”

Now, as the Catholic Church prepares to embark on its latest chapter, it remains to be seen what issues Pope Leo XIV will choose to take up.

Bishop Zubik said he hopes the new pontiff chooses to continue Pope Francis’ legacy of inclusion and mercy.

“If we’re going to be really honest with each other, we’ve done a heck of a job of building walls and I think that was precisely the movement that Pope Francis had, to tear down those walls and build bridges,” he said. “The fact that [Pope Leo XIV] spoke directly to that image, I think, says something else as well.”

-—Laura Esposito and the Associated Press contributed to this report