Sealed in secrecy behind the ornate doors of the 15th century Sistine Chapel, a process rooted in rituals and ceremony began Wednesday to select the next leader of the 2,000-year-old Roman Catholic Church.

The College of Cardinals, made up of the 133 eligible voting cardinals representing 70 countries, began the proceedings known as the conclave inside the Vatican in Rome around 10:30 a.m. EST. The process, shrouded in oaths of secrecy carrying a penalty of excommunication, will culminate in the selection of the 267th pontiff to succeed Pope Francis, who died April 21 after 12 years leading the 1.4 billion-strong Catholics across the globe.

On Tuesday, Pittsburgh Bishop David Zubik encouraged area Catholics to pray for the cardinal-electors as they began deliberations.

“I ask everyone’s prayers for the election of a pope who will manifest the love and mercy of Christ to all people,” Bishop Zubik said. “This sacred election is a deeply prayerful undertaking, rooted in our foundational belief that the Holy Spirit guides the Church.”

Advertise with us

One of the 10 U.S. electors, Cardinal Daniel DiNardo grew up in Castle Shannon and graduated from Duquesne University. He was ordained a priest in the Pittsburgh diocese in 1977 and served as parochial vicar at St. Pius X in Carrick and taught at St. Paul’s seminary.

When electing the next pope, some say the conclave is likely to consider whether that person continues Pope Francis’ legacy of inclusion to attract those who have historically been shut out of the church, or shift toward a more conservative candidate focused on the importance of traditional doctrine and culture.

Others believe the focus will instead be more on determining who can best manage the Catholic Church amid an ongoing budget crisis and repeated sex abuse scandals.

“[Pope Francis] changed the culture very much and moved away from the kind of exclusive philosophy of everybody has to follow the rules as they were defined,” said Kevin Hayes, president of the board of directors for Catholics for Change in our Church, a Pittsburgh-based nonprofit. “I think it’s going to be a matter of [the conclave] asking themselves if they feel that Pope Francis was pushing the church in ways that rocked the boat or not.”

Mr. Hayes said the conclave’s tendency has been to elect popes in pairs — one who alters the trajectory of the church followed by another who continues his legacy in some capacity.

Advertise with us

Pope John Paul II and his successor, Pope Benedict XVI, had similar, somewhat conservative interpretations of the Second Vatican Council, a series of meetings held in Vatican City in the early 1960s to help the church connect with a increasingly modern world, according to Mr. Hayes.

“I do believe that the cardinals tend to not necessarily want to make right 90-degree turns in our church,” Mr. Hayes said. “I think they tend, as a group, to think about the church like a very large ocean liner that turns slowly, so I think there’s an unintended ballast they seek in who they choose.”

The direction the cardinals choose to go in could impact how long it takes to come to a decision, Mr. Hayes said.

“Reading the tea leaves, you think either they’re going to get together and decide quickly that they want someone to continue Pope Francis’ vision of synodality and inclusiveness. ... If instead they say they need to step back and think about some type of change, I think it’s going to be a longer conclave,” he said.

Pope Francis held a series of meetings during his papacy to determine the future of the church, which led to calls to take steps to promote women in decision-making roles and for “radical inclusion” of the LGBTQ+ community. He was known for his vision of mercy for all, and welcomed traditionally marginalized populations into the fold.

Advertise with us

Joelle Rollo-Koster, professor of medieval history at the University of Rhode Island and lead editor of the soon-to-be-published Cambridge History of the Papacy, said she believes the conclave isn’t concerned about liberal or conservative, inclusive or exclusive.

That is a “smokescreen” caused by the rhetoric swirling around the divided two-party political system in America and elsewhere, she said.

“We are projecting,” Ms. Rollo-Koster said. “People like to think the church is preoccupied by gender issues because people are preoccupied by gender issues.”

Instead, she believes the conclave will be more focused on finding a leader who can keep the church fiscally responsible and who can continue to lead an institution beset by decades of priest abuse scandals. Over the centuries, Ms. Rollo-Koster said the best popes in history have always exhibited high levels of organizational leadership, a trait she thinks the conclave will be looking for.

“My feeling is that they are going to need somebody on top of the way the administration runs: a technocrat, a bureaucrat, somebody who knows where the money is, how we can save money, what we can do,” Ms. Rollo-Koster said. “It’s something that nobody has really talked about.”

Advertise with us

Any belief that the conclave is too singularly focused on finding someone to follow closely in the footsteps of Pope Francis may lead to an unexpected surprise for many, she said.

“They are going to pull a cardinal who is going to be what this group of men think they need right now,” she said. “They aren’t thinking about liberalization or the blessing of gay marriages.”

This conclave is the most geographically diverse one in history as the 133 eligible cardinals — all have to be under the age of 80 — hail from 70 countries, which may also play into the vote. Japanese Cardinal Tarcisio Isao Kikuchi told La Repubblica that most of the 23 cardinals from throughout Asia plan to vote together.

"We Asians are probably more unanimous in supporting one or two candidates ... we will see which name will come out as the leading candidate," Cardinal Kikuchi said.

There are also 18 cardinals-electors from Africa. Neither an African or Asian pope have ever been elected.

Advertise with us

Before the conclave officially began, all of the gathered cardinals are given the opportunity to speak in a series of meetings. About 20 spoke on topics related to migration, geopolitical conflicts in some cardinals’ home territories, and relations between ethnic groups within the church.

The thoughts expressed in those meetings may carry a lot of weight, said Mr. Hayes.

“Part of it is going to be what kind of reception those voices will have among those who are going to be electors, that’s the big question,” he said.

Following the final pre-conclave meeting Tuesday, the Associated Press reported that the fundamental question among cardinals seemed less so whether the next pope is “conservative” or “progressive” but rather that the next pope needed to be someone who could act both as a pastor to lead the church, and as a teacher.

“We need a superman!” said Cardinal William Seng Chye Goh, the 67-year-old archbishop of Singapore.

Advertise with us

While the conclave is underway, the cardinals are sequestered behind the sealed doors of the Sistine Chapel and stay in a pair of Vatican guesthouses. They take an oath of secrecy regarding all details about the election while also promising to ignore any attempts from outside parties to sway the vote.

During the first vote on Wednesday evening, no candidate secured the necessary two-thirds majority, or 89 votes, so the cardinals retired for the day and returned Thursday. Black smoke again poured out of the Sistine Chapel chimney late Thursday morning, indicating no pope was elected on second or third ballots. Cardinals will now have two ballots in the afternoon, until a winner is found.

It has taken just a matter of days to elect the last three popes: Pope Francis was elected in 2013 after five ballots were held over the course of two days, and it also took two days to elect his predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI, in 2005 after four ballots. Prior to Pope Benedict XVI, it took eight ballots over two days to elect Pope John Paul II in 1978.

The longest election in papal history began in November 1268 in Viterbo, Italy and lasted nearly three years due to divisions among the cardinals. As deliberations continued, Viterbo locals became frustrated with the lack of progress and locked the cardinals in the papal palace, spurring the use of the word conclave rooted in the Latin words “cum,” meaning with, and “clavem,” meaning key.