The morning after the election, a few dozen faith leaders sat quietly inside Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Gardens in a room overlooking the gardens.
As rain beat down on the floor-to-wall windows, Cantor Kalix Jacobson of Temple Emanuel of South Hills pulled a ukulele from beneath a chair.
Softly, the cantor began to sing: "It's no secret, my heart is bleeding ... and I mean it; you can always call me."
Some of the leaders closed their eyes and swayed to the music, others reached for tissues as tears spilled from their eyes. The cantor wrote the song in the middle of the 2020 political divisiveness. Four years later, it resonates more now than it did before.
Months ago, faith leaders from across the Pittsburgh region agreed to meet on the day following the election regardless of the outcome of the presidential race, for a community conversation about political polarization and the fear of political violence.
In the lead-up to November, as Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump made direct appeals to and stoked fears in faith communities across Pennsylvania — the most contested swing state — leaving many religious leaders struggling with polarized, divided communities.
Read More
Sponsored by the Christian Associates of Southwest Pennsylvania and the Center for Loving Kindness at the Jewish Community Center, the Wednesday event, titled "We Have to Talk," aimed to help faith leaders reflect on the contentious election season and engage in discussions about how to bridge divides in their communities. Most of the conversations were candid, confidential, and at times tearful.
"Bridging political divides is a shared struggle and challenge for all faith leaders," said the Rev. Liddy Barlow, executive minister at Christian Associates. "And I think it's very important for people to engage as their whole selves, their real human emotions."
Because of Trump's win, the event took on a new role, too — it became a place to worry. Several faith leaders at the event spoke about their fear of a surge in threats or political violence in the wake of another Trump presidency.
For example, the former president has in recent months has amped up his anti-immigrant rhetoric, which, according to the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection, has made immigrants more susceptible to political violence.
Trump hasn't spared faith communities, either — in September, he said Jewish-American voters would be partly to blame if he lost the election to Ms. Harris.
Rev. Barlow facilitated conversations about each person's emotions throughout the election cycle and how it impacted the diverse faith communities. Then, she asked them to describe moments of hope or unity.
Gwen Puza, a faith teacher at East Liberty Presbyterian Church, recalled a conversation with a woman who voted for Trump.
Ms. Puza said the woman told her she was anti-abortion due to her experiences as a nurse. Ms. Puza, who voted for Ms. Harris, understood her point, despite being a strong supporter of abortion rights. Before abortion was declared a nationwide constitutional right in 1973, Ms. Puza said her aunt died from the aftereffects of an illegal abortion.
"It was a very fruitful conversation, which doesn't happen often," she said.
Several faith leaders in attendance agreed it would be productive to hold more space for conversations across political divides. Rev. Barlow emphasized this sentiment.
"Sometimes there's a risk in feeling like we don't even have access to the people who don't agree with us," she said.
Before dispersing, the faith leaders agreed to meet again in January and discuss, among other things, skill-building workshops to facilitate healthy political discourse. As they put on their coats and hugged goodbye, several attendees offered to host their own events in the interim.
"Gathering like this helps faith leaders not feel alone," Rev. Barlow said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.