The Jewish tradition of breaking glass to end a wedding ceremony is meant to be a reminder — a symbol of the pain of the past amid the joy of the celebration at hand.
Some link its symbolism to the destruction of the first Temple in Jerusalem. Others, to the fragility of life and relationships.
On Sunday, it perhaps stood for all of that as hundreds gathered in Squirrel Hill to mark the ceremonial groundbreaking on the site of the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history.
Against the backdrop of the remaining pieces of the synagogue that once stood at the corner of Shady and Wilkins avenues, dozens of those touched by the ripple effects of Oct. 27, 2018, carried out the tradition just yards away from where the shooter’s horrific and deadly rampage was carried out.
“It is a way to hold both the joy of the moment and the heartache we experienced on the journey to the celebration,” said Carole Zawatsky, CEO of Tree of Life, the name of the nonprofit that will rebuild on the site where 11 worshippers were gunned down during Shabbat services.
Much of the synagogue has been torn down, a process that began in earnest in January, more than five years after the attack and six months after the shooter’s trial.
Read More
“Therefore, it is fitting that we break glass today in the form of small glass houses as we celebrate this new chapter of the Tree of Life,” Ms. Zawatsky said. “They are a reminder that sometimes we must tear down in order to rebuild.”
A mezuzah is a sacred Jewish object affixed near a home’s door to sanctify the space and protect it from evil, and the glass broken Sunday will be turned into mezuzahs for the new Tree of Life building — shattered pieces, symbols of pain and a broken world, turned into something meant to protect from evil.

And perhaps the reimagined space symbolizes much the same — pieces of the original synagogue, a sanctuary defiled, turned into a place of education and remembrance with the mission of driving out hatred.
“Today,” said Tree of Life Rabbi Jeffrey Myers, “we announce, loudly and clearly, to the entire world that evil did not win — that it did not chase us from our home, and it never, ever will.”
The ceremonial groundbreaking was permeated by a sense of hope as well as the lingering grief and trauma that time can’t heal.
“It is hard not to have a little bit of sadness in our hearts as we remember what was,” Ms. Zawatsky said, “and we imagine what could have been.”
Diane Rosenthal said she can still feel her brothers when she visits the site — even today, she said Sunday as she spoke to the crowd. Cecil and David, both in their 50s, were born with Fragile X syndrome, a genetic disorder that caused intellectual and some physical disabilities. They knew they were different, Ms. Rosenthal said, and they knew they were often excluded.
But not at the synagogue where their congregation, Tree of Life, shared space with the congregations Dor Hadash and New Light. They were included and welcomed there, Ms. Rosenthal said. The synagogue was a second home to them; the congregation, a second family.
The new building, simply called Tree of Life, will include a memorial to Cecil and David, to Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger. It will house Pittsburgh’s Holocaust Center and education spaces.
“My hope,” she said, “is that this new chapter will be an opportunity to welcome more people in, just as my brothers Cecil and David once welcomed everyone who came here to the Tree of Life.”
She said she knows her brothers will always be linked to the terror that unfolded at their synagogue, but she and the eight other families want to make sure their slain loved ones are remembered for how they lived rather than just how they were killed.
“The new Tree of Life will be a place where education is given to individuals of all ages who can learn what happened that day and why it happened and how to counter antisemitism and other forms of identity-based hate,” Ms. Rosenthal said. “These are the lessons that are so desperately needed in our world right now.”
To remember, said second gentleman Doug Emhoff, is paramount.
“We must never forget what the poison of antisemitism can do,” he said.
Mr. Emhoff, husband of Vice President Kamala Harris, is the first Jewish spouse of a president or vice president. He has been among the most outspoken of the Biden administration in terms of antisemitism. He called the attack on the synagogue “an unspeakable act of violence fueled by vicious antisemitic hate.”
“Since that evil day, we’ve seen antisemitism rise to unprecedented levels,” he said. “It is a crisis.”
But, he said, there is hope.
“We are turning what was once a tragic crime scene into a place of hope and inspiration — a place that is full of light,” Mr. Emhoff said. “This will be a sanctuary that reminds all of us that there is more that unites us than divides us.”
Gov. Josh Shapiro said remembrance and the fight against antisemitism is not solely on the shoulders of politicians or the Jewish community.
“Hear me on this: Remembrance cannot be a passive act,” said Mr. Shapiro, who is Jewish. “The task of remembering requires all of us to stand up, to speak out, and to ensure that everyone in this country knows the stories of the 11 people who were murdered hear and the dangers of antisemitism that fueled that hate crime.”
He said the responsibility to remember must be passed down from generation to generation — l’dor vador, in Hebrew.
“I have been humbled to walk alongside you in this journey, to listen to your stories, to share in a small way your grief,” he said. “Now, we will look forward to our shared future and know that it has been a long and difficult process to reach this.”
The groundbreaking ceremony marked another chapter in the congregations’ long book of beginning again. For more than five years, Ms. Zawatsky said, those closest to the shooting have been working toward new beginnings. The work began in the immediate aftermath, and it continued as months and then years went on, as Hanukkahs and Passovers and Yom Kippurs came and went. The shooter’s sentencing last year offered yet another new beginning.
She said she has ruminated on those words again and again over the years. What, she asked, does it mean to begin again?
“Beginning again does not mean we forget,” she said. “Rather, it means that we carry with us in our hearts the 11 who were taken, honoring them in everything we do.
“It means,” she continued, “that when we say we will not forget them, we remember their whole lives, and when we say ‘May their memories be for a blessing,’ we do all in our power to make it true.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.