Following years of considerable change — much of which occurred through a global pandemic — the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh has taken on a more compact form for the next stage in its nearly decades-long metamorphosis.

Since becoming bishop in 2007, David Zubik has guided the transformation of the 180-year-old diocese to reflect changes in the Catholic population, societal norms and financial realities.

Ahead of a time of deep renewal during the holiest week of the year for Catholics, Bishop Zubik reflected on the past and future of the diocese during a wide-ranging interview with the Post-Gazette at his residence at St. Paul’s Seminary in Carnegie.

“My greatest desire, and my greatest heartache, is the number of people who are unchurched,” he said. “The greatest challenge I face in ministry is to help people develop a personal relationship with Christ at a time when maybe relationships are not seen as important.” 

Advertise with us

Bishop Zubik said he came to a realization the diocese was teetering at a breaking point about a decade ago, amid dwindling faith in a rapidly changing world and technology that had put a strain on the physical aspects of community. 

“The more and more we rely on social media and our cellphones, people looking at screens, are all occasions for people to disconnect from each other,” he said.“

Nine years ago, Bishop Zubik launched an initiative to reconfigure the diocese to ensure its future for the more than 600,000 Catholics in southwestern Pennsylvania. The result is a greatly consolidated landscape — with 188 parishes that were then made up of 225 churches now standing at 177 church buildings serving 60 parishes.

“What surprised me the most was that there was a lot less resistance than I thought there was gonna be,” Bishop Zubik said. “We went through a reorganization of parishes back in the 1990s and there was a lot of resistance at that particular time …what's happened [this time] is that we approached the reorganization of parishes in a far more consultative and collaborative way.”

His perception of collaboration isn’t an entirely universal sentiment. Parishioners in some of the diocese’s church communities have expressed resentment and hurt, saying the churches they cherished are now shuttered and the familiar people they prayed with are scattered.

Advertise with us
St. Pio of Pietrelcina Parish in Lawrenceville is the result of a merger between the parishes of St. Maria Goretti, in the Bloomfield/Friendship/Garfield area, and Our Lady of Angels in Lawrenceville. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The most recent consolidation — a merger between the parishes of St. Maria Goretti, in the Bloomfield/Friendship/Garfield area, and Our Lady of Angels in Lawrenceville to create the new St. Pio of Pietrelcina Parish — took effect on New Year's Day. 

That merger is expected to be the last in a five-year plan that began in October 2018.

“We did an awful lot of work bringing faith communities together,” Bishop Zubik said. “I would anticipate that the biggest part of that work is really done. We said to people this is going to be a five-year-process and we kept our promise.”

Difficult decisions

For the 74-year-old bishop, who said he’s feeling healthy after recovery from his sixth back surgery in November, the decision to begin grouping houses of worship was a difficult, yet preemptive, choice made in the face of declining parish attendance, high building costs and a shrinking pool of men entering the priesthood.

Those are trends that have played out across the country in recent decades.

Advertise with us

“It’s a matter of not waiting until you reach a crisis when you absolutely have to do something,” he said.

The number of priests in active ministry within the diocese has been dropping over the decades — from 453 in 1990, to 338 in 2000, then 225 in 2015. 

Last year, there was a diocese roster of 140 priests in active ministry, although Bishop Zubik said there are currently 32 seminarians who may soon bolster those numbers.

He said the drop is due, in part, to changing family dynamics and support, as well as social media.

Bishop David Zubik said he believes the biggest part of the work to consolidate the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh is done. "We said to people this is going to be a five-year-process and we kept our promise," he said. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“When I was growing up, I think families would have been excited to support their son to become a priest or their daughter to become a sister. That's not so much the reality today because of the influence of secular culture,” he said,

Advertise with us

Also spearheading diocesan revitalization efforts has been Linda Ritzer, head of parish services, who recognized the necessity and difficulty of the decisions the bishop has made for the future of the diocese.

“Bishop Zubik had the courage to pull the trigger,” Ms. Ritzer said. “It is not easy to be a leader and stand in front of people and say ‘I’m going to be an agent for change.’ That’s a hard call.”

Mergers bring hope, but for some, resentment

The decade-long series of consolidations, despite assurances that they represent a brighter future for the diocese, have been met with pushback from some local parishioners. 

Bishop Zubik believes some resistance was ultimately unavoidable. 

“There’s always going to be the starting point of negativity, that somehow because we’re consolidating parishes, it says the faith is dying,” he said. “I don’t believe that at all.” 

Advertise with us

Others feel differently about the new landscape of the diocese. 

This includes a group trying to save Corpus Christi Parish in McKeesport, which was itself created in November 2010 through the merging of three parishes — St. Martin de Porres, St. Mary Czestochowa and St. Pius V. The parishes had a combined congregation of about 2,000 families at the time they were consolidated.

About a decade after it was created, Corpus Christi Parish merged with three more parishes — St. Angela Merici Parish in White Oak, St. Patrick Parish in McKeesport and St. Robert Bellarmine Parish in East McKeesport — to create Mary, Mother of God Parish in January 2020. 

For a few years following that merger, the individual churches involved remained open and held their own services and events under the umbrella of the new parish headquartered in White Oak.

In January 2023, decisions were made to stop weekend Masses at both Corpus Christi and St. Robert churches, due to scheduling needs, although those churches have not officially closed.

Advertise with us
Parishioners (left to right) Pam Hammar, Joan Midlo, Joan Whitney, Paula Pagnotta, Michael Price, Joanne Dorazio, Ron Panek and Chris Kyle stand outside of Corpus Christi Church in McKeesport Thursday, March 28, 2024. The group, lead by Pagnotta and Dorazio, is working to get their church reopened. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Following the news, Paula Pagnotta, 69, of McKeesport, and Joanne Dorazio, 73, from White Oak, said they worked with fellow parishioners for six months to get a prayer service organized at Corpus Christi Church. They were ready to launch that effort in June, but were told no one could enter the church due to structural damage that presented a safety hazard.

Ms. Dorazio, Ms. Pagnotta and other parishioners have since written letters to the diocese, Bishop Zubik and the Vatican, in hopes of getting the building repaired to resume prayer services. The latest bulletin from Mary, Mother of God Parish stated that construction would begin March 26.

The group believes their parish should never have been merged with others to begin with.

“It keeps happening and happening with no consideration whatsoever for the people who are older who walk to church or can’t get to the other churches, or just don’t care to go to the other churches,” Ms. Pagnotta said. “You end up losing those people.”

Both women said they felt as though they had no say in the decision to merge Corpus Christi Parish, despite a series of town halls the diocese held across parishes with members in attendance.

Advertise with us

“It was kind of told to us in an overall statement that people were OK with [the merger], but that’s the furthest from the truth that there ever could be,” Ms. Dorazio said. “I think the biggest thing we found out about it is that we, as Roman Catholics in the church, have no say.”

In the meantime, both Ms. Pagnotta and Ms. Dorazio said they had been attending Masses at different churches across the area and said they believe the consolidation of the diocese has created many other “roaming” Catholics like them.

“We were a viable community and this has really torn apart, basically a church family and it wasn’t a necessary thing to do as far as we’re concerned,” Ms. Dorazio said.

“I think that a lot of people are disheartened that their churches are being closed and they keep having to move to a new church, then move to a new church,” Ms. Pagnotta said.

Bishop Zubik said the diocese worked hard to bring as many people as possible into the reformation process, noting it held 328 town hall meetings when his initiative kicked off in 2015. 

Advertise with us

“Everybody had an opportunity to speak up and hear what was happening,” he said. “And I think we've consistently remained faithful to that process.”

Others have seen silver linings to the new parish groupings while acknowledging the growing pains.

Toni Aceto, a parishioner at Holy Cross Parish in East Pittsburgh — created amid a series of mergers that consolidated 61 parishes into 15 new parishes in July 2020 — said the changes have been both challenging and rewarding.

“While mergers were difficult and may have caused some people to become upset, there were so many benefits such as sharing resources, gifts and talents with the wider community at large,” she said.

Ms. Aceto also helped lead a lay apostolate — a group of laypeople who perform ministry in the church — for women in her parish to serve as a conduit to help people from different churches and neighborhoods meet each other.

Advertise with us

“It was difficult at first. However, as the years advanced, people started seeing their parish as just having many campuses instead of ‘my church/their church,’” she said. “We are not finished merging: of course it takes longer to merge minds and hearts than it does buildings. However, I am pleased with what I see as far as people willing to go to other buildings for Mass and events.”

Everybody had an opportunity to speak up and hear what was happening,” he said. “And I think we've consistently remained faithful to that process.

Mary Jean Donohue, 70, of Jefferson Hills, has had a similar experience since learning that her former parish, St. Thomas à Becket in Jefferson Hills, would be merging with three other parishes to create Triumph of the Holy Cross Parish in July 2020. The new parish is headquartered in Jefferson Hills.

“My initial reaction was that it’s going to be very strange, how is that going to work?” she said. “I couldn’t imagine how it would work out…but my husband and I were very surprised at how we felt it merged so beautifully.”

Ms. Donohue said a door to a new community had been opened after her former parish was folded in with St. Clare of Assisi Parish in Clairton, St. Elizabeth of Hungary Parish in Pleasant Hills, and Holy Spirit Parish in West Mifflin, although services have continued at St. Thomas à Becket Church.

Advertise with us

“We have met so many wonderful people that we wouldn’t have met had we not merged,” she said. “I have met, at my age, a whole new group of friends. There is so much more to offer.”

‘I find a lot of hope’

The changes have attracted a new wave of young parishioners to some churches.

Nicholas Sciarappa, youth minister at St. Luke the Evangelist Parish in Ambridge, Baden and Conway in Beaver County and Franklin Park in Allegheny — which came from the merging of five parishes in July 2022 — said the number of children participating in parish youth programs has spiked following the creation of the new parish.

Mr. Sciarappa, the former youth minister at Ss. John and Paul Church before the merger, said in the past four years the youth group he leads swelled from a dozen teenage parishioners meeting once a week on average to an estimated 80 each week.

“They’re blissfully ignorant to some of the change that has been so hard for some of the parents,” he said. “In that I find a lot of hope. I find that Gen Z are most concerned about finding their purpose, being in a place that is safe and welcoming, and a place where they can make a difference.

Advertise with us

I find that Gen Z are most concerned about finding their purpose, being in a place that is safe and welcoming, and a place where they can make a difference.

“They care more about that than the building.”

With assurances that downsizing is done and the reorganization efforts are moving onto the next phase, the diocese is now in the process of working with each individual parish to determine what their vision and priorities are for the future.

Ms. Ritzer said, in her experience, each parish has had different goals but there have been some commonalities.

“Hospitality is a main theme in many of our places,” she said. “So there's some common threads around unity and there's also a real desire for vibrancy and liturgy, including how we celebrate our sacramental life.”

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh diocese has not been alone in the realization that, as the times change, so must it.

The diocese itself has, to some, represented an ideal model of change and Bishop Zubik and other diocese leaders have been asked to speak about the Pittsburgh process around the country. Diocese officials declined to provide information on where representatives have visited or plan to.

“Only now, in some cases, are other dioceses realizing that they have to do something,” Ms. Ritzer said. “They’re representing what has happened here and they don’t sugarcoat anything. Change is not easy, but it's needed with what all of us are being dealt.”

Bishop Zubik said what remains important moving forward is perspective in the face of change.

“Some people will say, ‘hey, my church isn’t opening. Why am I coming to church?’” he said. “Well then, what did it mean in the first place? Was it the building that was so important or what happened within the context of that building?”