The synagogue at the corner of Shady and Wilkins avenues has sat empty for more than five years, devoid of light and life since the day a gunman driven by hate punctured the sanctuary within.
In that time, it has become the unintended tomb of the love, prayer and tradition that were abruptly ended Oct. 27, 2018.
And so each and every piece of the official memorial is intentional. Each decision has been carefully considered and weighed by those closest to the 11 killed on a rainy Saturday.
Joyce Feinberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Dan Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.
“It is a quintessential Jewish value that we start with memory — memory of loss and memory of tragedy — but from that we have to build,” said Michael Bernstein, chair of the Tree of Life Interim Governance Committee. “We have to build with hope and light and resilience. It is the classic Jewish story.”
Indeed, the memorial space at the site of the Squirrel Hill shooting will acknowledge the atrocity and the loss but focus on how each of the 11 unique individuals lived.
Read More
The designs unveiled this week offer the first glimpse of the area that will memorialize those killed. The renderings show a stone path cut across the greenery on the Shady Avenue side of the building. Eleven sculptures of open books will line the walkway and garden — one for each of the 11.
The sculptures will be inscribed with stories of how each person lived, Mr. Bernstein said, allowing visitors to get to know them as people and individual lives, not the abstract collective victims of a hate crime.
“It’s very much about life, not death,” he said.
The books represent the Jewish idea of the Book of Life: Between Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur — the Jewish New Year and the Day of Atonement — those who are leading good lives and destined for heaven are written into the Book of Life.
“It’s a way to demonstrate that these were really lives well lived,” he said.
The years’ long planning process for the memorial — punctuated by a three-month federal trial for the shooter — allowed a glimpse into those 11 lives well lived.
Rose Mallinger loved to dance, and Joyce Feinberg’s sons called her the embodiment of loving kindness. Bernice and Sylvan Simon met on a blind date, and Richard Gottfried and his sister cherished going to Pitt football games. Mel Wax loved to tell jokes. Cecil and David Rosenthal felt safe and loved in their synagogue. Jerry Rabinowitz was a doctor who still made house calls, and Irving Younger and Dan Stein would donate blood together.
Mr. Bernstein called it a gift to the city, one he believes will resonate deeply with visitors.
Diane Rosenthal, whose brothers Cecil and David were killed in the 2018 shooting, said the design is both majestic and fitting.
“All of them were very simple people,” she said. “They weren’t extravagant. They met for Shabbat services every weekend.”
To get to this point has been a multi-year process that will continue as the Memorialization Working Group moves into the next phase, said Ms. Rosenthal, a member of the working group focused specifically on the outdoor remembrance space.
“[When planning started] everyone was in their own space in terms of where they were on the spectrum of grief and anger and frustration,” Ms. Rosenthal said. “Just getting to a point where we could all openly discuss it and develop some trust among the families … was hard.”
The planning process for the memorial has run parallel to the planning for the renewed building, which also remains a work in progress. Some pieces of the current building will be demolished and rebuilt. Others will remain.
The reimagined building, simply called Tree of Life, will be multifunctional. It will include worship space, classrooms and communal areas, museum exhibits dedicated to Jewish culture, and it will house Pittsburgh’s Holocaust Center. A newly formed nonprofit also called Tree of Life is governing the project to re-envision and rebuild the sacred space, all with an eye toward the goal of eradicating antisemitism and identity-based hate.
The individual stories of the victims are key to that goal and the goal of the memorial, Mr. Bernstein said.
“The story of antisemitism is grounded in individual stories,” he said. “Because it’s not abstract. It’s real. These are real people who had families and community.”
For years, there were decisions: Who should design the memorial, and where should it be? Foundational decisions upon which the rest would be made were a painstaking process, Ms. Rosenthal said. The working group met regularly, first in person and later virtually as the COVID-19 pandemic upended normalcy.
The group chose Daniel Libeskind, the same architect designing the renewed synagogue space, to design the memorial as well — a memorial that they ultimately decided will be on the site of the 2018 shooting.
That decision took time, Ms. Rosenthal said. Many survivors and family members initially felt they could never go back to the site.
“But it can’t really be anywhere else,” Ms. Rosenthal said. “We want the world to know what happened and we want the world to come see it and feel what we feel.”
‘This should never happen again’
More and more communities across the country are finding themselves scarred by acts of mass gun violence. They are left not just with the lingering anguish of these evermore common crimes, but with the responsibility of remembering those who were killed.
Earlier this year in Las Vegas, officials unveiled the design for a memorial to the 58 people killed in a 2017 mass shooting at a country music festival on the Las Vegas Strip.
“I will not lie that this has been a simple process, because it hasn’t,” committee member Mynda Smith told the Associated Press in July. “But at the end of the day, I know this will become something of beauty and healing and love.”
Ten years after the 2012 shooting, a permanent memorial to the 20 first graders and six teachers killed in Newtown, Conn., was completed. In the time in between, plans for the memorial shifted and changed as the commission overseeing it worked to balance costs and differences of opinion.
"We had one chance to get it right," Alan Martin, vice chairman of Sandy Hook Permanent Memorial Commission, told ABC News last year. "So, we labored over the process of site selection and labored over the process of design selection. And we knew it had to be both a natural feeling, a gentle feeling, and it had to give people an opportunity to grieve."
That careful and sensitive balance was not lost on Mr. Libeskind. His portfolio includes the design of the 9/11 memorial in New York, Berlin’s Jewish Museum, and the Dutch Holocaust Memorial of Names in Amsterdam.
“Creating a meaningful memorial is a highly emotional and personal process, while at the same time, it must communicate to a broader audience,” Mr. Libeskind, the son of Holocaust survivors, said in a statement.
He said his team worked alongside the survivors and nine families of those killed throughout the years’ long process.
The design, Mr. Libeskind said, not only memorializes the 11 but also “brings the families and the community together in healing.”
That balance — the needs and wants of survivors and family members plus the larger message behind the memorial — remained on the minds of members of the working group, too.
“People had to get out of themselves and know that this memorial wasn’t just for us, but to educate the world,” Ms. Rosenthal said. “It’s going to be around way longer than we are and even our children. We want it to be a reminder that this should never happen again.”
Mr. Bernstein said that larger message was key.
“I think there was a recognition that while it does have to be personal and speak to the families themselves, it isn’t being built for them,” he said. “It is being built for generations that may not be alive today but who need to understand what happened and how it happened and who are, hopefully, living in a world where it’s no longer happening.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.