Midway through the New Light congregation’s Shabbat service Saturday, Carol Black read a list of names of those suffering from illness along with the recitation of the Mi Sheberach, a prayer for healing.
Before she moved on with the service, Ms. Black — a survivor of the 2018 synagogue shooting — paused. “I’d like to add Tim Matson to the list,” she said, referring to a Pittsburgh police officer seriously injured in the shooting. “He has another surgery in the fall.”
For the New Light congregation, it was the first Saturday service after a jury announced a death sentence Wednesday for Robert Bowers, who killed 11 Jewish worshippers the morning of Oct. 27, 2018.

On that day, the New Light congregation was sharing the Tree of Life synagogue building with two other congregations, Tree of Life and Dor Hadash, Three of New Light’s most active members died — Melvin Wax, Daniel Stein and Ms. Black’s brother Richard Gottfried. Eight members of the two other congregations were killed: Joyce Fienberg, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon and Irving Younger.
The Saturday service at New Light, which is part of the Conservative Jewish movement, lasts about two and a half hours and is conducted primarily in Hebrew. In many ways, it is the same service that Jews have held for roughly 2,000 years, remarked one member of the congregation during the service.
But in other ways, Saturday’s service was different.
After his routine announcements near the end of the service, New Light’s co-president, Stephen Cohen, said he’d been asked by other members of the congregation to say something about the trial. He built on the sermon on the evil eye that had just been delivered by Rabbi Jonathan Perlman, who himself survived the synagogue shooting by hiding in a closet with Ms. Black.
Speaking during the service, Mr. Cohen discussed the trial verdict as the end of a chapter in the metaphorical book that has become the reality for those most directly affected by the shooting — with other unknown chapters still to come.
“We’ve gone through a traumatic experience the last three months,” said Mr. Cohen hours after the service concluded. “I think closure is the right word. Assigning him the death penalty, whether you agree with it or not, represents closure.”

Like others in the congregation, Mr. Cohen said he had grown more observant since the day of the shooting. Rabbi Perlman offered classes to the congregation to further their Jewish education, and Mr. Cohen took the opportunity to improve his Hebrew and to participate in joint religious study with two African-American Christian congregations.
“Before 2018, I would skip a Saturday here, a Sunday there, if something was more important, if there was a baseball game or something,” he said. “I don’t skip it anymore. It’s an important part of my life, that communion with God — he deserves to be acknowledged and sanctified, and that’s what Saturday morning services are all about.”
At one point during the service, an armed security guard entered the room to turn on an oscillating fan. Judaism prohibits “work” on Shabbat, including turning on lights or other electronics. Prior to the shooting, the congregation often asked a maintenance worker or other non-Jewish person present to perform the task, said Mr. Cohen. Now, there are ever-present security guards.

New Light, which was founded in 1899 by Romanian refugees to Pittsburgh, is currently in its fourth location — from its origin in the Hill District, to a former mansion in Squirrel Hill, to the Tree of Life building, which it shared with the other congregations for just under a year before the day of the shooting. After the shooting, the congregation moved into the Beth Shalom Congregation, where it plans to stay.
Some artifacts in the room likely date back over a 100 years, such as a chandelier that came from the original synagogue in the Hill District.
Other pieces are new, such as a memorial board dedicated to Wax, Stein and Gottfried, and Torah medallions that also bear their names. During the service, Ms. Black carried a Torah down the aisle before and after it was opened as worshippers touched it with their prayer books or shawls.
“The Torah medallion is something we look at every single time we are in the sanctuary,” said Mr. Cohen later in the day. “It’s a constant reminder of those we lost. Though we have completed the trial, the hurt and pain will always be with us.”

During a portion of the service that included a memorial prayer, Mr. Cohen read a list of names. Most on the list, such as former Pittsburgh mayor and New Light member Sophie Masloff, were approaching their yahrzeit — the anniversary of their death.
But then, as he has done at the conclusion of earlier phases of the trial, he read 11 additional names: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil Rosenthal, David Rosenthal, Bernice Simon, Sylvan Simon, Dan Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.
Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.