Autumn gloom gave way to sun and cloudless skies as hundreds gathered Thursday in Schenley Park to mark four years since an antisemitic gunman opened fire on Saturday services at the Tree of Life synagogue.

“It has been four years. It’s hard to believe,” said Lauren Bairnsfather, executive director of the Holocaust Center of Pittsburgh. “Yet the work of memory is beside us and in front of us. It’s all around us, and it is our sacred duty to remember.”

The Oct. 27, 2018, attack at the synagogue, which housed the Tree of Life Or L’Simcha, Dor Hadash and New Light congregations, remains the deadliest attack on the Jewish faith in the United States.

Family members and loved ones lit a candle for each of the 11 killed: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.

Advertise with us

The survivors and witnesses from inside the synagogue that morning, together read Psalm 23.

“Even though I walk through the darkest valley, I will fear no evil,” they read. “For you are with me, your rod and your staff, they comfort me.”

Hannah Kaye read Mi Sheberach, the Jewish prayer for the sick. She is the daughter of Lori Gilbert-Kaye, a member of Chabad of Poway, Calif. Gilbert-Kaye was killed in an attack on her synagogue exactly six months after the massacre at Tree of Life.

Ms. Kaye wept as she read, first in Hebrew and then in English, “May the holy and blessed one be filled with mercy on them, restore their health and heal them, strengthen them and renew their life.”

Rabbi Amy Bardack, of Congregation Dor Hadash, read El Malei Rahamim — a prayer for the souls of the departed, and students from the Hillel Jewish University Center of Pittsburgh, read “Each of us has a Name.”

Advertise with us

Local leaders — Mayor Ed Gainey, County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and Councilwoman Erika Strassburger — read “A Prayer for our Country,” and the Pittsburgh Youth Chorus and Rodman Street Baptist Choir sang on stage.

Representatives from the three congregations read “Epitaph: “When I die, give what’s left of me away to children and old men that wait to die.

“And if you need to cry, cry for your brother walking the street beside you. And when you need me, put your arms around anyone and give them what you need to give me.”

The overall sentiment of the ceremony was simple: May their memories be a blessing, always.

The ceremony itself was relatively small and intimate. That was by design, said Kara Spodek, a trustee for Tree of Life Or L’Simcha. It is meant to reflect the 11 lives lost four years earlier.

Advertise with us

“They were there that Saturday morning to pray — something peaceful,” she said. “They would want something peaceful like this. I don’t think they would want something with glitz and glam. This represents who they are.”

Those involved in the planning for the 2021 ceremony, which was the first held on Prospect Drive in Schenley Park, felt so right that the planning committee wanted to keep that feel.

“We represented different people in the community, we had people singing, everyone from the congregation was represented, we had a candle-lighting — it just flowed smoothly and it was perfect,” she said. “Everyone left and was in awe. It was perfect.”

Earlier Thursday, people trickled past the synagogue, which remains an empty, hulking reminder at Shady and Wilkins avenues — an unintended memorial that offers a meeting place to pay respects.

Among them was Cyril Lukas, who forged a friendship with Younger at the gym at the Jewish Community Center, where they both worked out most mornings.

Advertise with us

“He was just a nice person — a nice person to talk to,” he said.

Mr. Lukas said he felt compelled to come to the synagogue Thursday on the four year mark to honor and remember his friend, with whom he often talked sports, food, and the mundane.

After Younger was killed, Mr. Lukas had to stop going to the gym for a while.

“I missed him. You get used to someone,” he said. “They become part of your routine.”

Two congregants were injured that day and survived: Daniel Leger and Andrea Wedner. Four Pittsburgh police officers sustained gunfire-related injuries. Dan Mead and Michael Smidga were among the first officers on the scene, encountering accused gunman Robert Bowers at the synagogue entrance. Officer Smidga was hit by shrapnel, and Officer Mead was shot in the hand.

Advertise with us

Inside the synagogue, two SWAT officers were injured in a gun battle with Mr. Bowers. Anthony Burke was struck in the hand, and Timothy Matson was shot multiple times. Officer Matson did not return to duty for two years.

Tzippy and Rich Mazer walk past the synagogue often. They live in the neighborhood and go for daily walks.

“It’s fresh in our minds,” Ms. Mazer said as the pair walked on Wilkins Avenue, past the screen-printed banners displaying art submitted by kids across the country in the aftermath of the shooting.

Ms. Mazer was an administrator at the Community Day School at the time, and she said many of the congregants worked among the students on various projects.

“It feels like yesterday,” she said.

Advertise with us

Across the city and country, words poured in from leaders marking the tragedy.

“Today we commemorate the 11 lives taken from us at the attack at the Tree of Life synagogue and recommit ourselves to the hard work of ending violence, discrimination and antisemitism every single day,” Mr. Gainey said in a statement. “We as Pittsburghers are welcoming, loving and accepting of all people — that will never change.”

President Joe Biden, in a statement, recalled how the “quiet Shabbat morning was shattered by gunfire and hate.”

“In the four years since that terrible day, the people of Pittsburgh have shown us what it means to be stronger than hate,” Mr. Biden said. “The courage and character of the Pittsburgh community remains an inspiration to us all.”