The Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh released a report outlining the input from over 3,600 local parishioners who participated in various listening sessions with clergy members, many of which called for the creation of a more welcoming and inclusive environment and new methods for presenting the liturgy.
In October 2021 Pope Francis announced the beginning of a two-year Synod of Bishops, which originally was created as a way for church leaders across the world to come to Rome to discuss challenges their churches are facing.
This synod has a newly added component, that the Pope called “an exercise in mutual listening,” where each diocese has been asked to hold listening sessions with their churches and pass the information along to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.
Pittsburgh Bishop David Zubik lauded the experience as a way to “listen to what our fellow Catholics have to say about their experience as Catholics,” and the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh held numerous listening sessions over the past few months to gather information from its parishioners.
The key themes that came up most often in Pittsburgh’s synodal process were to create a more welcoming and inclusive church, improvements to the liturgy and a need for further teachings about the Catholic faith, according to the report.
Among other topics mentioned in the report, participants did express a feeling of skepticism or distrust for the process. They said that they were hopeful about the process, but were “doubtful that their voices would make any sort of difference.”
A letter from Bishop Zubik that was included in the report that this document is not meant to “propose changes that should take place.”
“The synthesis is not a call for action or a mandate for change; rather, it is an invitation for us to continue listening and discerning with those around us as we continue to journey together toward the Kingdom of God,” the letter said.
Bishop Zubik also indicated that some parts of the report were hard for him to read but that it is “always important to listen very carefully and not wear blinders.”
One of the main emphases of the testimonials was the desire to have a welcoming and inclusive diocese, though speakers disagreed what exactly that meant.
Some asked for more effective ways to include new members, while others noted that they felt judged for an aspect of their life, like being in the LGBTQ+ community or divorced.
With various mergers that have been occurring within the diocese, people said that they felt like outsiders at their new parish and wanted to create a more welcoming environment for people who were displaced by mergers.
Between May 2021 and May 2022, the diocese reduced the number of parishes from 81 to 63. Because of continued mergers, some parishioners expressed a desire to move away from “a pastor-centered Church” to a “community-centered Church.”
The most frequently discussed topic during the listening sessions was the church’s liturgy, according to the report. However, there wasn’t a general consensus on a single liturgical style that the diocese should adhere to.
“Some mentioned finding the Holy Spirit in contemporary music, while others told of their joy in hearing the organ and classic hymns, and still others spoke of their love for the use of Latin,” the report said.
Others wanted to return to the Mass and sacrament methods of the 1960s, according to the report.
There was also an emphasis on how important members found preaching and the Sunday homily and were worried that if those things are not done well, it could become an “obstacle to faith.”
Though the majority of the participants were over age 60, in specific listening sessions for younger church members they expressed a need for more support, the report said.
“How to effectively reach young people is seen as a significant challenge of the present moment,” the report said. “The future of the Church is at serious risk unless we establish effective, direct programs that reach out to and engage young adults. … The youth care more about what attitudes and experiences they run into through the parish and local community than what is said regarding Church teaching by the diocese or higher-level Church authorities.”
Other topics that arose during the various sessions were issues such as further support for for survivors of sexual assault and addressing problems created by the COVID-19 pandemic, like many people leaving the church after Masses were canceled.
In the wake of the report, Bishop Zubik said that the diocese wouldn’t be convening another synodal in the coming months, but encouraged parishioners to “keep listening to one another.”
The diocese also noted that this report wasn’t a list of action points for the future, but rather a presentation of what was said during the listening sessions.
The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops will take the Pittsburgh Dioceses' report and combine it with others received from dioceses across the country, before sending a final report to the Vatican.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.