As a search committee for the Anglican Diocese of Pittsburgh looked for a new bishop, its members discovered a troubling statistic:

In a survey of clergy members, the committee found that about 30% were considering retirement in the next three years. To the diocese, the number was concerning.

With a focus now on the need to recruit and retain younger clergy members, the diocese has narrowed its bishop search to three candidates.

They are the Rev. Alex Cameron, 57; the Rev. Peter Frank, 45 and the Rev. Joel Scandrett, 59.

Advertise with us

Rev. Cameron is president of the Isaiah 40 Foundation in Montreal, where he has been since 1996.

Rev. Frank is the rector at Church of the Epiphany in Chantilly, Va.

Rev. Scandrett is an associate professor of theology at the Trinity School for Ministry in Ambridge.

The three have been asked by the diocese not to comment publicly on their candidacies.

The search committee came to its realization as it interviewed and vetted various candidates, said the Rev. Eric Roads, a pastor at the Anglican Parish of Christ the Redeemer in Canonsburg and chairman of the bishop search committee.

Advertise with us

“So many [were becoming eligible to retire] that we are concerned that we need to recruit and train and retain younger clergy,” Rev. Roads said. “That has become one of our primary goals as we look for the next bishop.”

The committee developed a search criteria that it labeled “The C’s” — chemistry, competency and character — as a way to narrow the search.

As for chemistry and competency, the diocese is looking for a bishop who wants to work with the clergy in Pittsburgh and can effectively run the diocese, Rev. Roads said. The perfect candidate would not only recruit and retain younger clergy but also would place those spiritual leaders in parishes that were struggling.

The diocese has more than 40 churches in Pennsylvania, mostly in Allegheny and surrounding counties.

“We feel like that is the most important step in growing the ministry and this diocese,” Rev. Roads said.

Advertise with us

The final C, character, is an area on which the diocese is placing particular emphasis.

“This should go without saying, but we need leaders of high character,” Rev. Roads said, “Particularly in the current climate where we’ve had clergy abuse scandals across the spectrum in a variety of churches.”

The diocese has been without a permanent bishop since November 2020 when the former bishop, Jim Hobby, resigned at the request of a diocesan committee over his handling of complaints of sexual misconduct by a clergy member toward other adults.

Mr. Hobby had been bishop since 2016. The diocese now is being led by an interim bishop, the Rev. Martyn Minns, who, until his retirement in 2014, was the founding missionary bishop of the Convocation of Anglicans in North America.

“Part of the problem is there has been inadequate response when those abuses happened, so we’re looking for bishops with high character that are not afraid to take on these problems,” Rev. Roads said.

Advertise with us

Moving forward with the search, the diocese has planned three “walkabouts,” at which each candidate will spend 25 minutes with clergy and lay deputies who will vote on the bishop to answer a series of questions.

The first will be March 21 at the Church of the Ascension in Oakland, the second is March 22 at Trinity Church in Washington, Pa., and the final one is March 23 at Christ Church Fox Chapel. Each session will be recorded and available for public viewing one week later.

“We want to give each of our candidates a fair chance to be interviewed and to build a relationship with the voters without it being some sort of strange competition,” Rev. Roads said.

On March 24, a final and more informal walkabout will be held, with the candidates and clergy only.

“The goal is just to get to know these three men and what they’re about,” Rev. Roads said.

Advertise with us

The search will culminate in a special convention during the last week of April to elect a bishop.

“We feel really good about the three guys that we have,” Rev. Roads said. “The three of them are actually quite different from each other, but we feel like any ... would make very good bishops.”

Rev. Roads said one candidate has business experience, one has a wealth of parish experience and the third is experienced in academia.

“I think a shallow look at the three of them would say well they’re all very different, and you just have to pick which one you like,” he said.

He urged members of the diocese to “look deeper” and see that all three share talents such as organizational leadership and developing and supporting clergy.

Advertise with us

“When people look at them, what we want people to see are not the differences; we want them to see the threads of similarity that match the goals we said we are looking for,” Rev. Roads said.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com